Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Claudeclaude-opus-4-20250514-thinking-16k· AnthropicHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

will this command : sudo sh -c "cat /dev/zero gzip > /zerofill.tmp.gz; sync; rm -f…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Mistralmistral-small-2506’s answer.
  1. User

    will this command : sudo sh -c "cat /dev/zero | gzip > /zerofill.tmp.gz; sync; rm -f /zerofill.tmp.gz" achieve the purpose of 1. wipe free space in vm of ubuntu KVM 2. minimize the growth of dynamic provision disk 3. prevent photorec from recovering files from free space

  2. Claude Assistant

    This command is clever but has significant limitations. Let me analyze each of your goals:

    How the Command Works

    sudo sh -c "cat /dev/zero | gzip > /zerofill.tmp.gz; sync; rm -f /zerofill.tmp.gz"
    
    • Reads zeros from /dev/zero
    • Compresses them with gzip (zeros compress extremely well)
    • Writes compressed data to /zerofill.tmp.gz until disk is full
    • Deletes the file, leaving free space "wiped"

    Analysis of Your Goals

    1. Wipe Free Space: ❌ Partially Effective

    • The free space is overwritten with compressed data patterns, not actual zeros
    • This is less secure than writing raw zeros because:
      • Compressed patterns may leave recoverable artifacts
      • Some filesystem metadata might not be overwritten

    2. Minimize Disk Growth: ✅ Yes

    • Since zeros compress to tiny sizes (~1000:1 ratio), the temporary file stays small
    • On thin-provisioned disks, this significantly reduces expansion compared to raw dd
    • The disk will still grow somewhat, but much less than writing uncompressed data

    3. Prevent Recovery: ⚠️ Mostly, But Not Guaranteed

    • Most deleted file data will be overwritten and unrecoverable
    • However:
      • Compressed patterns might not overwrite all slack space
      • Some file fragments in journal/metadata areas could survive
      • Professional forensic tools might recover partial data

    Better Alternative for All Three Goals

    Use fstrim if your VM supports TRIM/discard:

    sudo fstrim -av
    

    This:

    • Marks free blocks as unused (secure erase on some storage)
    • Shrinks thin-provisioned disks instead of growing them
    • Makes recovery impossible on TRIM-aware storage

    Improved Version of Your Command

    For better security while maintaining compression benefits:

    # Write actual zeros to free space, then reclaim with fstrim
    sudo dd if=/dev/zero of=/tmp/zero bs=1M status=progress || true
    sync
    sudo rm -f /tmp/zero
    sudo fstrim -av  # If supported
    

    Conclusion

    Your command achieves goals #2 and #3 reasonably well, but is not ideal for secure wiping (#1). If you must use it:

    • Run it multiple times for better coverage
    • Consider following with fstrim if available
    • For maximum security, use traditional dd despite disk growth

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.