Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Coherecommand-a-03-2025· CohereHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Grok 3? solution

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with grok-3-preview-02-24’s answer.
  1. User

    Grok 3? solution

  2. Cohere Assistant

    Here’s a Grok-style solution to the steel beam torsion design problem, keeping it concise and focused on the key steps:


    Problem:
    Design a W310x39 (Fy = 345 MPa) beam for bending + torsion with:

    • UDL = 15 kN/m (span = 6 m)
    • Torsion (T) = 10 kN·m
    • AISC SI units.

    Solution:

    1. Section Properties (W310x39):

      • J = 1,070,000 mm⁴ (torsional constant)
      • Sx = 642,000 mm³ (section modulus)
    2. Bending Moment (M):
      [ M_{\text{max}} = \frac{wL^2}{8} = \frac{15 \times 6^2}{8} = 67.5 \text{ kN·m} ]
      [ f_b = \frac{M_{\text{max}}}{S_x} = \frac{67,500,000}{642,000} = 105.1 \text{ MPa} ]

    3. Torsional Shear Stress (τt):
      [ \tau_t = \frac{T \cdot r}{J} = \frac{10,000,000 \times 100.5}{1,070,000} \approx 0.94 \text{ MPa} ]
      (r = flange width/2 = 100.5 mm)

    4. Shear Stress (τv):
      [ \tau_v = \frac{V}{A_w} = \frac{45,000}{1,993} \approx 22.6 \text{ MPa} ]
      (Web area ≈ 1,993 mm²)

    5. Interaction Check (AISC H1-1a):
      [ \frac{f_b}{0.9 \times 345} + \frac{\tau_v + \tau_t}{0.9 \times 345} = \frac{105.1}{310.5} + \frac{23.54}{310.5} \approx 0.415 < 1.0 ]

    Conclusion:
    W310x39 is adequate for bending + torsion.

    Grok Insight:
    Torsion in W-shapes is often negligible unless T is very high. Check interaction if combined with shear/bending.


    Grok-style TL;DR:
    W310x39 passes torsion + bending check (AISC SI). Key: low τt (0.94 MPa) + interaction ratio (0.415 < 1.0).

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.