Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4.1-2025-04-14· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

How many satellites in a constellation would you need for a 10 min revisit rate? Use…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.5-flash’s answer.
  1. User

    How many satellites in a constellation would you need for a 10 min revisit rate? Use maxar imaging sats with 30 cm res. Give 10 min revisit rates for UK and southern usa.

  2. Assistant

    Let's break down your question and provide a detailed answer:

    1. Key Parameters

    • Satellite Type: Maxar imaging satellites (e.g., WorldView-3/4)
    • Resolution: 30 cm (0.3 m)
    • Orbit: Sun-synchronous, ~500-700 km altitude (typical for Maxar)
    • Swath Width: ~13.1 km (WorldView-3 at nadir)
    • Revisit Rate: 10 minutes (i.e., the same location is imaged every 10 minutes)
    • Locations: UK and Southern USA

    2. Understanding Revisit Rate

    • Revisit Rate: The frequency with which a satellite can image the same location.
    • 10 min revisit: Extremely high; requires a large constellation.

    3. Calculating Number of Satellites Needed

    A. Single Satellite Revisit

    • Maxar satellites in sun-synchronous orbits typically have a revisit time of 1-2 days at nadir, but with off-nadir pointing, they can revisit more frequently (a few times per day).
    • Off-nadir imaging increases revisit but reduces resolution and increases atmospheric path length.

    B. Constellation Calculation

    To achieve a 10-minute revisit, you need enough satellites so that at least one is always in position to image the target area every 10 minutes.

    Key factors:

    • Orbital period: ~95 minutes (for 500-700 km altitude)
    • Earth rotation: Affects ground track
    • Swath width: 13.1 km (nadir), up to ~26 km (off-nadir, with reduced resolution)
    • Latitude: Higher revisit at higher latitudes (UK) due to orbit convergence

    C. Approximate Calculation

    Step 1: Fraction of Time a Satellite Can See a Target
    • For a single satellite, the time it can see a specific point per orbit is limited.
    • For a 13.1 km swath at 700 km altitude, the dwell time over a point is a few seconds per orbit.
    Step 2: Number of Orbits per Day
    • ~15 orbits per day per satellite
    Step 3: Coverage Gaps
    • To cover every 10 minutes, you need to fill the 24-hour day with 10-minute intervals: 144 intervals per day.
    Step 4: Satellite Constellation Sizing
    • Rule of thumb: For low-latitude targets (e.g., Southern USA), you need more satellites than for high-latitude targets (e.g., UK).
    • For 10-minute revisit globally: Commercial estimates (e.g., Planet, BlackSky) suggest 40-60 satellites for 10-15 min revisit at moderate resolution (3-5 m). For 30 cm resolution, the swath is much narrower, so you need more satellites.
    Step 5: Estimate for Maxar-Class (30 cm) Satellites
    • UK (higher latitude): Orbits converge, so fewer satellites needed.
    • Southern USA (lower latitude): Orbits more spread, so more satellites needed.

    Rough estimate:

    • UK: ~40-50 satellites for 10-min revisit at 30 cm
    • Southern USA: ~60-80 satellites for 10-min revisit at 30 cm

    4. Summary Table

    LocationSatellites Needed (10-min revisit, 30 cm)
    UK40-50
    Southern USA60-80

    5. Notes and Caveats

    • Assumptions: All satellites are in optimal orbits, can point off-nadir, and weather/clouds are ignored.
    • Real-world factors: Cloud cover, tasking conflicts, and off-nadir resolution loss may require even more satellites.
    • Current Maxar fleet: Only a handful of satellites, so current revisit is hours to days, not minutes.

    6. References


    If you need a more detailed calculation (e.g., orbital mechanics, swath overlap, or a simulation), let me know!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.