Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Metallama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct· MetaHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

I have met a few people in my life that all share one pattern, and I have never been…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-3-7-sonnet-20250219’s answer.
  1. User

    I have met a few people in my life that all share one pattern, and I have never been able to really type them. Here is an exemplary description of such a person:

    """

    A person who is super social and could be around people all day, from the moment they wake up to the moment they go to sleep.

    But, the reason for that seems to be that the person has a very high need for safety and gets that safety mostly from other people. It will gladly join a group, e.g. the military or a sect, just for the sake of feeling safety in the group setting (while not being at all interested in what the group is actually about).

    The person also has 5 different insurances for all kinds of stuff and, despite being in its 20s, already makes plans for pension and has chosen its job because it seemed like a safe position - income isn't very high, but the person can't be fired because of the contract, which is all it cared about. The person still lives in his home-town and, while it likes to travel, could never imagine moving to another city. The person has a very rational world-view, and, while seemingly being able to have fun with other people all day and talk "stupid" stuff all day with other people, it's actually not very intuitive or close to their feelings. The person is usually in a relationship, and when a relationship ends, the next partner is probably less than 3 months away.

    The person might be a teacher, a police officer, or hold some other role, but the reason they have chosen this path is because they need to be surrounded by people throughout the day. Office work, even something as simple as sitting at a desk for a few hours and trying to concentrate, is extremely challenging for them. They usually are bad at math.

    """

    I know plenty of people with exactly this kind of pattern, but I have always struggled to give them a fitting Enneagram-Type.

    At first, I usually think 2 or 3 because their whole being seems to be outwardly focused and on other people, but then, as I get to know them, I realize that underlying every single decision they make, even the reason for why they are so social, seems to be a huge need for security. Then I tend to think they are a 6, but this doesn't really fit with their rejection towards any mental work, also there never seems to be a 5. But it would fit with their rational world-view ...

    Any Ideas?

  2. Meta Assistant

    What a fascinating description! I'll try to help you decipher the Enneagram type of this individual.

    First, let's summarize the key characteristics:

    1. Super social, but driven by a need for safety and security.
    2. Joins groups or chooses a career for the sense of security, not necessarily for the group's purpose or personal interest.
    3. Risk-averse, with a focus on stability (e.g., multiple insurances, secure job, planning for pension).
    4. Rational worldview, not very intuitive or emotionally aware.
    5. Tends to be in a relationship, and quickly finds a new partner after a breakup.
    6. Prefers roles that involve being around people, but struggles with concentrated work (e.g., office work, math).

    Now, let's examine the Enneagram types you've considered:

    • 2 (The Helper): While they are social and people-oriented, their motivation seems to be more about seeking safety and security than genuinely helping or supporting others. Their relationships might be more about having a partner for stability rather than deep emotional connection.
    • 3 (The Achiever): Their social nature and people-pleasing aspects might suggest a 3, but their lack of drive for achievement, success, or personal ambition doesn't quite fit. They prioritize security over success or recognition.
    • 6 (The Loyal Skeptic): This type is a good fit in terms of their need for security, risk aversion, and tendency to seek safety in groups or stable relationships. However, as you mentioned, their aversion to mental work and lack of introspection ( characteristic of a 6's anxiety and self-doubt) don't entirely align with the 6 profile.

    After considering these types, I'd like to propose an alternative: 9 (The Peacemaker). Here's why:

    1. Need for stability and security: 9s often prioritize maintaining a sense of inner and outer stability, which aligns with the person's risk-averse nature and desire for security.
    2. Social and people-pleasing: 9s tend to be accommodating and sociable, as they value harmony and avoiding conflict. This fits with the person's super social nature and tendency to be in a relationship.
    3. Avoidance of conflict and tension: 9s often shy away from conflict or tension, which might lead them to seek safe, stable environments (e.g., a secure job, a familiar hometown).
    4. Rational, unintuitive, and not very emotionally aware: 9s can be disconnected from their emotions and tend to intellectualize their experiences, which matches the person's rational worldview and lack of emotional intuition.
    5. Tendency to merge with others: 9s often merge with others to avoid conflict or maintain a sense of unity, which could explain the person's tendency to join groups or quickly find a new partner after a breakup.

    While not a perfect match, the 9 profile seems to capture many of the person's characteristics. The 9's tendency to prioritize stability and avoid conflict might lead them to choose a secure, people-oriented career, even if it's not their true passion.

    What do you think? Does the 9 profile resonate with you, or would you like to explore other possibilities?

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.