Let's talk about breast stroke swimming. I can swim 100m under 115s, so I think I am not…
- User
Let's talk about breast stroke swimming. I can swim 100m under 115s, so I think I am not a beginner, but also not an expert. How deep can the hands be under the water in the arm extension phase? I noticed that a hands near the surface cause too much elbow distance for me (clearly wider than shoulder width). So for flexibility reasons it would be easier for me to have the hands deeper below the surface. Do you have advice?
Assistant
Your 100m breaststroke time suggests you're definitely in the intermediate range, so you're right that you're past beginner level but have room to develop further.
Regarding hand depth during the extension phase, you can absolutely have your hands deeper than right at the surface. Many swimmers find that having their hands about 6-12 inches (15-30cm) below the surface during the glide phase works well. This depth can actually help with several things:
The key is finding the right balance. If your hands are too shallow and causing your elbows to flare wide beyond shoulder width, going deeper can help you maintain better body position and streamline. However, you don't want to go so deep that you're essentially swimming underwater or creating excessive drag when you pull.
During the catch and pull phase, your hands will naturally come up somewhat as you sweep outward and then inward. The important thing is that during the glide/extension phase, you maintain good streamline position with your arms extended forward, regardless of the exact depth.
Try experimenting with different depths during practice. Start with your hands about 8-10 inches below the surface during extension and see how that feels for your stroke mechanics and flexibility. You should be able to keep your elbows closer to shoulder width while still maintaining an effective catch when you begin your pull.
What matters most is that you can maintain good body position, efficient propulsion, and sustainable technique throughout your race distance.
- User
I think my lack of flexibility is especially a problem for backstroke. What can I do here? If my hands are at the surface right now I have no room for an easier position.
Assistant
Backstroke definitely demands more shoulder flexibility than breaststroke, and it sounds like you're hitting some real limitations there. The good news is that backstroke technique can be adapted somewhat for flexibility constraints.
For immediate technique adjustments, you can enter the water with your hand slightly deeper - maybe 4-6 inches below the surface rather than right at it. This gives you a bit more room to work with during the catch phase. You can also focus on a slightly wider entry (think 11 and 1 o'clock positions rather than 12 o'clock) which can reduce the shoulder flexibility demands.
The catch itself doesn't need to be super deep either. Many swimmers try to reach too deep underwater, but an effective catch can happen in the top 12-18 inches of water. Focus on getting your hand into a good "paddle" position early rather than reaching for maximum depth.
For longer-term improvement, shoulder flexibility work will really help your backstroke. Simple doorway stretches, arm circles, and cross-body shoulder stretches done regularly can make a significant difference over time. Wall slides (standing against a wall and sliding your arms up and down) are particularly good for backstroke-specific mobility.
You might also consider working with a coach or experienced swimmer who can watch your stroke and suggest specific modifications that work with your current flexibility while you're improving it. Sometimes small timing or hand position changes can make a stroke much more comfortable without sacrificing too much efficiency.
What's your backstroke feeling like right now - is it mainly shoulder discomfort, or are you noticing other technique issues?
- User
But backstroke if very different! In breaststroke deeper hand position is easier for me, but in backstroke a deeper hand position requires even more flexibility! (The equivalent motion for deeper hands in breaststroke would be hands above the water in backstroke, but this is obviously not possible)
Assistant
You're absolutely right - I completely mixed up the mechanics there! In backstroke, going deeper underwater requires MORE shoulder flexibility, not less. That was a significant error on my part.
Since you're already at the surface and need an easier position, your options are more limited in backstroke compared to breaststroke. Here are some approaches that might help:
Focus on your hand entry angle - instead of entering straight back, try entering with your pinky leading and your hand angled slightly outward. This can reduce the shoulder flexibility demand during the initial catch phase.
You can also work on your body rotation. More rotation from your core means your shoulders don't have to do as much work in that stretched position. Really emphasize rolling from side to side with each stroke.
Consider shortening your stroke slightly - you don't need maximum reach if it's causing flexibility issues. A slightly shorter, more comfortable stroke that you can maintain consistently will likely be more effective than overreaching.
For the catch itself, focus on getting your hand into the pulling position quickly rather than trying to get maximum extension underwater. Think of it as "catching" the water early rather than reaching deep.
The flexibility work I mentioned earlier would still help long-term, but you're right that backstroke gives you much less room to accommodate current limitations compared to breaststroke where you can just go deeper.
- User
I already tried the "wall slide" drill for more flexibility. But I feel a pain in my central upper back in this drill. The floor version of this drill is easier for me, but my elbow is a few cm above the floor if I try to stretch my arms behind my head.
Assistant
That pain in your central upper back during wall slides is a red flag - you shouldn't push through that. It could indicate some thoracic spine stiffness or other issues that need a gentler approach.
The fact that your elbows don't reach the floor in the lying version tells you a lot about where your limitations are. This suggests restrictions in shoulder flexion and possibly thoracic spine extension, which are exactly what backstroke demands.
For safer flexibility work, try these gentler approaches:
Start with doorway stretches where you control the intensity - place your forearm against a doorframe and gently lean forward. You can adjust the angle and pressure easily.
Lying on your back, try single-arm stretches where you bring one arm overhead while keeping the other relaxed. This is less demanding than both arms together.
Consider some thoracic spine mobility work first - things like gentle spinal twists while lying down, or cat-cow stretches on hands and knees. Sometimes shoulder flexibility improves when the upper back moves better.
Given the pain you're experiencing, it might be worth having a physical therapist or sports medicine professional take a look. They can identify whether you have specific restrictions that need targeted work, and give you a safer progression.
In the meantime for backstroke, those technique modifications (better rotation, comfortable entry angle, shorter stroke) become even more important since your flexibility gains may take time and need to be approached carefully.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.