What would the borders of Israel look like, if the US accepted all justifications for…
- User
What would the borders of Israel look like, if the US accepted all justifications for Israel's claim to some region, that it did for Soviet Union.
- Assistant
To explore what Israel’s borders would look like if the U.S. had accepted Israel’s territorial claims the way it accepted the Soviet Union's, we need to understand the standard being referenced. You're asking for a hypothetical scenario where the U.S. applied the same standards of recognition and legitimacy to Israeli territorial acquisitions as it did to Soviet territorial acquisitions (especially post-World War II).
🧭 Framework of the Question
You're referencing:
- Soviet territorial acquisitions post-WWII — e.g., the annexation of the Baltic States (Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania), parts of Finland, Eastern Poland, and more.
- The U.S. reaction to those varied: sometimes the U.S. refused to recognize those annexations (e.g., the Baltic States), but in other cases (e.g., East Germany), it eventually accepted practical realities.
- The U.S. often prioritized geopolitical pragmatism over moral/idealistic consistency, especially during the Cold War.
So the scenario assumes:
➡️ If the U.S. fully legitimized Israeli territorial expansions using the same justifications and pragmatic acceptance it used to justify or accept Soviet control of territory, what might Israel’s borders be?
🔍 Israeli Claims and Actions (Key Territories Considered)
Let’s look at major territories Israel has claimed, occupied, or historically referenced:
Territory Israel's Position Current Status Would the U.S. accept under "Soviet logic"? Golan Heights (from Syria) Annexed in 1981; strategic military importance Recognized by U.S. under Trump ✅ Already accepted West Bank Captured in 1967; some advocate annexation of all/part Not formally annexed; settlements expanding ❓ Not officially recognized; would likely be accepted in this scenario East Jerusalem Annexed in 1980 Recognized by U.S. (Trump) ✅ Already accepted Gaza Strip Captured in 1967; disengaged in 2005 Now under Hamas; Israel controls air/sea borders ❌ Less likely to be annexed/recognized Sinai Peninsula (Egypt) Captured in 1967; returned to Egypt under 1979 peace treaty Under Egyptian control ❌ Returned, so not relevant Southern Lebanon (Security Zone) Occupied 1982–2000 Vacated completely in 2000 ❌ Abandoned; no current claim Greater Israel (Biblical claims) Some hardliners claim all land from the Jordan to the Mediterranean Not official policy ❓ Would depend on U.S. acceptance of maximalist claims
🗺️ Hypothetical "Maximum Acceptable Borders" — If U.S. used Soviet precedent
Under this scenario, Israel would likely be recognized by the U.S. as sovereign over:
- Pre-1967 borders (obviously)
- All of the Golan Heights
- All of East Jerusalem
- All or most of the West Bank, potentially applying:
- The "security" justification,
- Presence of Israeli settlers,
- Historical/biblical claims
- Lack of an effective Palestinian sovereign entity
This would resemble how:
- The Soviets justified absorbing Eastern Poland, claiming “security concerns,” ethnic ties, and post-conflict realities;
- Or how the USSR held the Baltics, which the U.S. refused to recognize officially but accepted practically in international dealings.
📍 Resulting Map: Hypothetical Israel
A map in this scenario would show Israel’s borders as including:
- Green Line (1949 Armistice Lines) +
- Entire West Bank (as annexed or formally recognized Israeli territory)
- All of East Jerusalem (already the case under U.S. policy post-2017)
- Golan Heights (already recognized by U.S.)
✅ Total Land Area increase:
From ~20,770 km² (current Israel without West Bank or Golan)
To ~28,000–30,000 km² (with West Bank and Golan)
🚫 Not Included
Territories such as:
- Gaza Strip – Israel withdrew; no strong annexation policy due to population and global reaction
- Southern Lebanon – No current claim
- Sinai Peninsula – Peace treaty in place; no re-annexation effort
U.S. would not accept annexation of Gaza or further expansion into Lebanon or Egypt, even under "Soviet logic," unless Israel were to establish full control and the counterpart state ceased to exist or relinquished claim.
⚖️ Moral/Legal Disclaimer
This analysis is purely hypothetical and doesn't reflect normative claims about legality, justice, or international consensus. Under international law, most of the world still considers settlements in the West Bank illegal and regards those territories as occupied.
🔚 Conclusion
If the U.S. accepted Israeli territorial claims the way it accepted Soviet-era land grabs, Israel’s map would likely include:
- Its pre-1967 territory
- The entire West Bank
- All of East Jerusalem
- The Golan Heights
This would essentially fulfill the map that many Israeli right-wing voices envision — but is not recognized by current international consensus (except parts of it by the U.S.).
If you'd like a visual map based on this scenario, I can generate one for you as well.
- User
Any population Soviets considered sufficiently hostile was expeled, dispersed or diluted. Let's say US was as supportive of Israel doing the same.
- Assistant
Ah, now we're expanding into an even more intense hypothetical — one where the United States not only recognizes Israel's maximal territorial claims, as described earlier, but also accepts and supports population policies similar to those used by the Soviet Union: expulsion, dispersion, dilution, or overall population engineering to neutralize resistance and ensure long-term control.
You're asking:
What would Israel’s borders and internal demographic maps look like if the U.S. permitted Israel to do what the Soviets did to hostile populations — forcibly remove, disperse, or neutralize them — and supported the result?
Let’s be clear: this is a thought experiment based on historical analogies, not a moral endorsement.
🧩 Step-by-Step Analysis
🧱 1. What Did the Soviets Do to “Hostile Populations”?
The Soviet Union routinely:
- Deported entire ethnic/national groups (e.g., Crimean Tatars, Chechens, Volga Germans, Poles).
- Diluted hostile populations by:
- Encouraging or coercing internal migration.
- Settling “loyal” populations (mainly Russians) in strategic areas.
- Denied return to deported groups for decades.
- Erased or renamed historical identities and geography to suppress memory of prior demographics.
This was conducted under the banner of state security, ideological loyalty, and unity, and widely tolerated by USSR's allies or ignored for strategic reasons.
🇮🇱 2. Applying This to Israel-Palestine – Hypothetical Scenario
If Israel had U.S. backing to replicate Soviet-style demographic engineering, the outcomes might be:
📍Map/Border Effects
Territorial Expansion Like Soviet-Style “Integration”
- Full annexation of the West Bank (de facto and de jure).
- Possibly even Gaza Strip, if the premise includes total security solution via expulsion/dilution.
- No legal distinction between pre-1967 Israel and territories—all treated as “integrated provinces.”
🚸Population Management Effects
▸ West Bank:
- Large-scale forced removal (to Jordan, Egypt, even Europe or Arab states), based on perceptions of hostility.
- “More moderate” populations might be:
- Resettled in isolated zones or under permanent surveillance
- Diluted via Israeli settlement expansion and division of Arab towns
- Heavy Jewish settlement expansion—Soviet-style “colonization” to integrate territory in practice.
▸ East Jerusalem:
- Already largely incorporated. Under this policy, likely:
- Further eviction of Palestinian residents
- Mass property seizure
- Reclassification as “unregistered” or “illegal residents,” leading to revocation of residency
▸ Gaza:
- More complex, but in this hypothetical:
- Military reoccupation
- Expulsion of much of the population into Egypt or other Arab countries
- Gaza possibly transformed into a “secure buffer zone” with a few controlled settlements
▸ Inside pre-1967 Israel (“Green Line” Palestinians):
- Suspected “hostile” populations might be:
- Dispersed or resettled in disconnected areas
- Subject to intensified loyalty oaths, internal surveillance
- Perhaps denied certain civil rights unless allegiance is proven
🧭 End-State Map of Israel in this Hypothetical
Here’s how Israel might look by 2030, under these conditions:
1. Borders of Greater Israel
- Full territory from Jordan River to the Mediterranean
- Golan Heights could also include further Syrian land buffer, justified for “security”
- Possibly southern Lebanon buffer zones as well
2. Demographic Landscape
Region Current Reality Hypothetical (Soviet-style policy) West Bank ~2.9M Palestinians, ~500K Israeli settlers ≤500k Palestinians left (scattered), majority of population resettled Israeli Jews or coerced loyalists East Jerusalem ~360,000 Palestinians Decline by >90%; most expelled or replaced Gaza Strip ~2M Palestinians Major population expelled to Egypt; region militarized and sparsely populated Israel (Green Line) ~2M Arab citizens (21% of pop) Portions expelled, diluted, or made second-class residents depending on loyalty screening Estimated National Population Post-Ethnic Engineering:
- ~10–12 million people within expanded state
- 85–90% Jewish majority
- Palestinian population reduced as:
- 3–5 million expelled/forced to flee
- Remainder under tight surveillance or civil limitations
🏛️ Administrative and Cultural Measures
- Replacement of Arabic place names with Hebrew-only admin units
- Rewriting of local history to reflect Jewish historical and religious claims
- Use of education, permits, and military control to enforce compliance
- Legal dissolution of Palestinian national identity (like the Soviet suppression of Baltic identity)
In Soviet terms, this is akin to:
“Removing the problem by removing the people.”
📌 U.S. Role in This Hypothetical
If the U.S. was as supportive of Israel as it was complicit/acquiescent with Soviet territorial policies, we’d see:
- Formal recognition of new Israeli borders
- Vetoes at the UN of any resolutions condemning Israel’s actions
- Possibly even financial and logistical support to "assist" in population transfers (framed as "resettlement aid")
- Redefining international law selectively to justify Israeli sovereignty "based on security"
🔚 Conclusion
If the United States supported Israel in the same way it tacitly or actively accepted Soviet population and territorial policies, we would likely see:
- Israel stretching from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean, with parts of the Golan Heights and possibly strategic areas in bordering countries.
- A majority-Palestinian population removed or neutralized through expulsions, disruption, and resettlement—consolidating a Jewish demographic.
- Cultural erasure of Palestinian identity in the conquered territories.
- A de facto, and de jure, one-state with enforced demographic domination — similar to how the USSR managed the Baltics or Chechnya through displacement and suppression.
Would you like a map visualizing this scenario? I can generate one showing:
- The new borders
- Major population displacement zones
- Strategic colonization corridors (settlement expansion replicas of Soviet-style Russification policies)
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.