Skip to content
The Chat Archive
o3-mini· OpenAI LMArena Human Preference 140K

are there four fractions a1/b1, a2/b2, c1/d1, c2/d2 such that a1/b1 > c1/d1 , a2/b2 >…

  1. User

    are there four fractions a1/b1, a2/b2, c1/d1, c2/d2 such that a1/b1 > c1/d1 , a2/b2 > c2/d2 but (a1 + a2)/(b1 + b2) < (c1 + c2)/(d1 + d2)?

  2. Assistant

    We will show that it is indeed possible to choose four fractions

    [ \frac{a_1}{b_1},\quad \frac{a_2}{b_2},\quad \frac{c_1}{d_1},\quad \frac{c_2}{d_2} ]

    so that

    1. In “Group 1” we have [ \frac{a_1}{b_1} > \frac{c_1}{d_1},, ]
    2. In “Group 2” we have [ \frac{a_2}{b_2} > \frac{c_2}{d_2},, ] but when we “aggregate” the two groups we obtain [ \frac{a_1+a_2}{b_1+b_2} < \frac{c_1+c_2}{d_1+d_2},. ] In words, although in each group the “(a/b)” fraction is larger than the “(c/d)” fraction, the combined ratio of the two (a)’s to the two (b)’s is less than the combined ratio of the two (c)’s to the two (d)’s.

    This is an instance of what is sometimes called Simpson’s paradox (or a related “aggregation paradox”). (In Simpson’s paradox one may have, say, two treatments each “winning” in separate subgroups, yet overall the aggregated success rate is lower.) In our situation the “weights” (that is, the denominators and how they are combined) are chosen in such a way that the aggregate inequality is reversed from the individual ones.

    Below is one explicit example.


    An Example

    Choose the numbers as follows:

    • Group 1:

      • Treatment: (a_1=510,; b_1=1000) so that [ \frac{a_1}{b_1}=\frac{510}{1000}=0.51. ]
      • Control: (c_1=5,; d_1=10) so that [ \frac{c_1}{d_1}=\frac{5}{10}=0.50. ] Clearly, (0.51>0.50).
    • Group 2:

      • Treatment: (a_2=19,; b_2=20) so that [ \frac{a_2}{b_2}=\frac{19}{20}=0.95. ]
      • Control: (c_2=940,; d_2=1000) so that [ \frac{c_2}{d_2}=\frac{940}{1000}=0.94. ] Again, (0.95>0.94).

    Now, let’s look at the aggregated ratios:

    • Treatment aggregated:

      [ \frac{a_1+a_2}{b_1+b_2}=\frac{510+19}{1000+20}=\frac{529}{1020}\approx 0.5186. ]

    • Control aggregated:

      [ \frac{c_1+c_2}{d_1+d_2}=\frac{5+940}{10+1000}=\frac{945}{1010}\approx 0.9356. ]

    Thus, even though in each group the treatment fraction exceeds the control fraction (0.51 > 0.50 in Group 1 and 0.95 > 0.94 in Group 2), the overall (aggregated) treatment ratio is

    [ 0.5186 ]

    while the overall control ratio is

    [ 0.9356,, ]

    so

    [ \frac{a_1+a_2}{b_1+b_2} < \frac{c_1+c_2}{d_1+d_2},. ]


    Comments

    How can this happen? Notice that when forming the ratios (\frac{a_1+a_2}{b_1+b_2}) and (\frac{c_1+c_2}{d_1+d_2}) the groups are “weighted” differently. In our example the treatment “Group 1” (with ratio 0.51) is given a heavy weight (its denominator is 1000, compared to only 20 in Group 2), while in the control data the numbers have been chosen so that Group 2 (with a very high ratio of 0.94) dominates the overall control total (its denominator is 1000 compared to 10 in Group 1). That “imbalance” in the weights is what allows the overall (aggregated) inequality to go in the opposite direction from the inequality in each group.


    Final Answer

    Yes, there exist four fractions with [ \frac{a_1}{b_1} > \frac{c_1}{d_1}\quad\text{and}\quad \frac{a_2}{b_2} > \frac{c_2}{d_2}, ] yet [ \frac{a_1+a_2}{b_1+b_2} < \frac{c_1+c_2}{d_1+d_2},. ]

    One acceptable example is given above. (Any example exhibiting this Simpson‐paradox phenomenon is correct.)

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.