how to tailoring my data science with my passionate topic as manchester united fan and…
- User
how to tailoring my data science with my passionate topic as manchester united fan and deliver into data science project to see what's the problem of the team end so bad in league standings and what they need to do to find player who fit into manchester united philosophy for next season. start from understanding the use case, finding the dataset
- Assistant
Of course! This is a fantastic way to blend your passion with your data science skills. A project like this is not only engaging but also creates a compelling portfolio piece that demonstrates your ability to handle a real-world problem from end to end.
Let's break down how you can structure and execute this project, starting from the very beginning.
Phase 1: Understanding the Use Case & Defining the Core Questions
This is the most critical step. We need to translate your broad goal into specific, measurable questions that data can answer.
The Overarching Goal: Analyze Manchester United's performance to identify key problems and recommend suitable player profiles for the next season.
Let's break this into two "Use Cases":
Use Case 1: The "Team Doctor" - Diagnosing the Problem
- Objective: To pinpoint why Manchester United finished poorly in the league. "Bad" is subjective, so we need to define it with Key Performance Indicators (KPIs).
- Specific Questions to Answer:
- Attack: Is the problem scoring goals? Are we creating enough high-quality chances (Expected Goals - xG)? Are our forwards finishing poorly (Goals vs. xG)? How do we compare to the top 4 teams?
- Defense: Is the problem conceding goals? Are we allowing too many high-quality chances (Expected Goals Against - xGA)? Is the issue in open play, or from set pieces? Are we failing at specific defensive actions (e.g., tackling, interceptions, pressing)?
- Midfield & Build-up: Is the problem controlling the game? Are we losing possession in dangerous areas? Are we unable to progress the ball from defense to attack effectively (e.g., low progressive passes/carries)?
- Consistency & Fitness: Is performance dropping in the second half of games? Is there a correlation between key player injuries and poor results? How does our squad's injury record compare to rivals?
- Tactical System: Does the data show a clear, consistent style of play? Or does it look chaotic compared to teams like Man City or Arsenal?
Use Case 2: The "Director of Football" - Prescribing the Solution
- Objective: To define the "Manchester United philosophy" using data and find players who fit this mold.
- Specific Questions to Answer:
- Defining the Philosophy: What does "the Manchester United way" or the manager's (e.g., Erik ten Hag's) ideal philosophy look like in terms of data? (e.g., High pressing, quick transitions, possession-based control). We can create a "data-driven archetype."
- Identifying Weak Links: Based on the diagnosis from Use Case 1, which positions are the highest priority for an upgrade? (e.g., "We need a ball-playing center-back" or "We need a defensive midfielder who can cover ground").
- Scouting with Data: Can we screen thousands of players across Europe to find a shortlist of 3-5 players per position who match our defined philosophy and are within a realistic age and value profile?
Phase 2: Finding and Gathering the Dataset
For a personal project, you won't have access to the expensive data providers like Opta or StatsBomb, but there are incredible free resources.
Primary Data Sources:
-
FBref (powered by StatsBomb): This is your holy grail. It provides comprehensive player and team statistics for all major leagues, including advanced metrics like xG, xA, pressures, progressive passes, and more.
- How to get it: You can manually copy-paste tables into Excel/Google Sheets, but the best way is to scrape the data using Python libraries like
pandasandBeautifulSouporrequests. There are many tutorials online for "scraping FBref with Python".
- How to get it: You can manually copy-paste tables into Excel/Google Sheets, but the best way is to scrape the data using Python libraries like
-
Understat: The best public source for Expected Goals (xG) data, including shot maps for matches. This is excellent for analyzing attacking and defensive performance in granular detail.
- How to get it: The site is very friendly to scraping. There are existing Python packages like
understat-pythat make it easy to pull match, player, and league data.
- How to get it: The site is very friendly to scraping. There are existing Python packages like
-
Transfermarkt: The go-to source for player market values, contract lengths, age, positions, and injury history.
- How to get it: Also scrapable with Python. This is crucial for the "scouting" phase to filter for realistic targets.
What data to collect:
- Team-level Data (for Diagnosis):
- From FBref: Get the "Squad Stats" tables for the Premier League for the last 2-3 seasons. Collect stats like Goals, xG, Shots, Possession, Passes, Pressures, Tackles, etc. Make sure to get the "vs. Opponent" stats too.
- Player-level Data (for Scouting):
- From FBref: For your target leagues (e.g., Premier League, La Liga, Bundesliga, Serie A, Ligue 1), collect the "Standard," "Shooting," "Passing," "Defensive," and "Possession" stats for all players. Crucially, use the "Per 90 Minutes" stats to compare players who have played different amounts of time.
- From Transfermarkt: Player age, market value, primary/secondary positions, contract expiry.
Organizing your Data: Use a tool like pandas in Python. You'll likely have several dataframes:
team_stats_pl.csv: Season-by-season stats for all Premier League teams.player_stats_top5_leagues.csv: Per 90 stats for all players in the top 5 leagues.player_info.csv: Market value, age, etc., from Transfermarkt.
Phase 3: The Project Execution - A Step-by-Step Guide
Here’s a potential workflow using Python.
Part A: The Diagnosis (Answering Use Case 1)
-
Benchmarking:
- Create bar charts comparing Man Utd's key metrics (xG for, xG against, Pressures in Attacking 3rd, Progressive Passes) against the Top 4 teams and the league average.
- Visualization: A simple bar chart from
matplotliborseabornwill immediately show where United is lagging. Are they creating as much as Arsenal but conceding as much as a mid-table team?
-
Trend Analysis:
- Create line charts showing Man Utd's key metrics over the last 3-5 seasons. Is the defense getting progressively worse? Did the attack fall off a cliff this season?
- Visualization: A line chart showing
xGA per Seasoncan be a powerful narrative tool.
-
Deep Dive - The Problem Areas:
- Defense: Use
Understatdata to plot shot maps of goals conceded by United. Are they conceding a lot of high-xG chances from inside the box? This points to a problem with defensive structure. Compare this to a team like Man City. - Attack: Compare individual players'
Goalsvs. theirxG. Is Rashford underperforming his xG significantly compared to last season? This indicates a finishing problem. - Build-up: Look at the
Progressive PassesandProgressive Carriesstats for United's defenders and midfielders. How do they rank compared to their positional peers at other top clubs? If your defenders are in the bottom percentile for progressing the ball, you've found a major bottleneck.
- Defense: Use
Part B: The Recruitment (Answering Use Case 2)
This is where it gets really fun.
-
Define the "Ten Hag" Player Archetype with Data:
- Let's say you want to find a new midfielder. The philosophy demands a player who is press-resistant, a good progressor of the ball, and defensively active.
- Translate to Metrics:
- Press-Resistant: High Pass Completion %, Low Miscontrols per 90, High number of Touches.
- Ball Progressor: High Progressive Passes per 90, High Progressive Carries per 90.
- Defensive Action: High Tackles + Interceptions per 90, High number of successful pressures.
-
Filter the Universe of Players:
- Start with your dataset of all players from the top 5 leagues.
- Filter by position:
Position = 'Midfielder'. - Filter by realistic constraints from Transfermarkt:
Age < 28,Market Value < €60m. - Filter for minimum playing time to ensure a good sample size:
Minutes Played > 1500.
-
Find Similar Players (The Core of the Analysis):
- Method 1: Percentile Ranking: For each of your key metrics (e.g., Progressive Passes per 90), calculate the percentile rank of every player. Create a composite "Philosophy Score" by averaging the percentile ranks across your chosen metrics. The players with the highest score are your top targets.
- Method 2: Clustering or Similarity Score (More Advanced):
- Select your key "philosophy" metrics as features.
- Normalize the data (so one metric doesn't dominate the others).
- Use an algorithm like K-Means Clustering to group players into different play styles, or use Cosine Similarity to find players who are most "similar" to a benchmark player (e.g., a prime Frenkie de Jong).
-
Visualize and Deliver the Recommendation:
- Don't just provide a table. The best way to present a player recommendation is with a Radar Chart.
- Create a radar chart showing your target player's stats (in percentiles) against the average Premier League midfielder. This gives an instant visual snapshot of a player's strengths and weaknesses.
- Example Recommendation: "Based on the data, Player X from the Bundesliga is a top target. He ranks in the 95th percentile for progressive passes and 92nd for press resistance, directly addressing our midfield build-up issues. His profile is a strong data-driven match for the manager's philosophy."
Tools of the Trade
- Language: Python
- Libraries:
pandas: For data manipulation and cleaning.numpy: For numerical operations.requests&BeautifulSoup4: For web scraping.matplotlib&seaborn: For static visualizations (bar charts, line charts, scatter plots).plotly: For interactive visualizations.mplsoccer: A fantastic Python library specifically for creating football visualizations like radar charts and pitch maps.scikit-learn: For clustering or similarity analysis.
By following this structured approach, you'll move from being a passionate fan to a data-driven analyst, creating a project that tells a compelling story and showcases your technical skills. Good luck
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.