Which Deltarune character do you believe will be revealed to be the Roaring Knight?
- User
Which Deltarune character do you believe will be revealed to be the Roaring Knight?
Assistant
This is one of the biggest mysteries in Deltarune, and there are many theories circulating! While Toby Fox is famously unpredictable, here are the leading candidates and why they're considered:
1. Kris (The Most Popular/Compelling Theory)
-
Evidence:
- They open the fountains: At the end of Chapter 1, Kris rips out their SOUL, throws it in a cage, and then stabs the floor, creating a Dark Fountain in their living room. At the end of Chapter 2, they do it again, creating another fountain in the computer lab. Kris is the only character we've directly seen create a Dark Fountain.
- Player vs. Kris: The game heavily emphasizes the distinction between the player's control and Kris's own actions. The Roaring Knight could be Kris acting independently when the player isn't in control, or when they've been freed from player control.
- Hidden Motivation: Kris is a silent protagonist with a lot of hidden depth. Their past, their feelings about their family, and their general demeanor are still largely unknown. Perhaps they have a strong, albeit misguided, motivation for wanting to "merge" the worlds or create a specific kind of Dark World.
- Narrative Impact: This would be a massive, emotionally resonant twist. The protagonist being the antagonist (or a misguided one) is a powerful narrative device.
-
Counter-Arguments/Nuances:
- Too Obvious?: Some feel it's too direct given Toby Fox's penchant for surprising twists.
- Possession/Manipulation: If it is Kris, it might not be their conscious will. They could be possessed, influenced by an external force (like Gaster), or an alternate personality.
- Ralsei's Warnings: Ralsei constantly warns against creating more fountains, stating it will lead to the "Roaring." If Kris is the Knight, why would Ralsei be so against it and yet seemingly work with Kris? This could imply Ralsei is unaware, or perhaps Ralsei himself has a hidden agenda.
2. Gaster (The Orchestrator Theory)
-
Evidence:
- Omnipresent Influence: Gaster's presence is subtly felt throughout Deltarune – through cryptic messages, sound effects, and the overall meta-narrative. He's associated with experimentation, other dimensions, and disrupting established realities.
- Knowledge: He seems to have a vast understanding of the game's mechanics and the larger lore. He could be manipulating events to achieve his own goals, using the Roaring Knight as a pawn or even being the unseen force behind their actions.
- Mystery: Gaster is the ultimate enigma, making him a prime candidate for a hidden antagonist.
-
Counter-Arguments:
- Indirect Role: Gaster usually seems to operate more as a puppet master or observer rather than a direct physical participant. He might be behind the Knight, but not be the Knight themselves.
3. Someone New / Unrevealed Character
- Evidence:
- Toby's Style: Toby Fox has introduced significant new characters unexpectedly in Undertale and Deltarune before. It's entirely possible the Knight is someone we haven't met or who has only been hinted at vaguely.
- Preserving Mystery: Introducing a new character would maintain the surprise factor and allow for fresh lore.
Less Likely but Interesting Theories:
- Asgore/Toriel: Unlikely due to their established personalities and motivations. It would feel like a character assassination.
- A "Misguided" Lightner: Someone who genuinely believes creating more Dark Worlds will lead to a better outcome, perhaps by bringing loved ones back or creating a utopia, unaware of the "Roaring" consequences.
My Best Guess:
Given the direct evidence shown in-game and the narrative themes, Kris is currently the strongest candidate for being the Roaring Knight. However, it's highly unlikely to be a straightforward "Kris is evil" reveal. More likely, if Kris is the Knight, it will come with a significant twist:
- Kris is being controlled/possessed.
- Kris has a fragmented identity, and the Knight is an aspect of them.
- Kris believes they are preventing an even worse outcome, and the "Roaring" is a necessary evil in their eyes.
- The Player's own actions are tied into Kris becoming the Knight.
Toby Fox has a talent for subverting expectations, so the actual reveal will undoubtedly be surprising and complex, no matter who it turns out to be.
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.