Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Metallama-4-maverick-03-26-experimental· MetaHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

I want to ask an LLM to detail ALL tasks that a flightcrew would perform on a Part 25…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Mistralmistral-medium-2505’s answer.
  1. User

    I want to ask an LLM to detail ALL tasks that a flightcrew would perform on a Part 25 aircraft. THEN I want the LLM to detail all the installed systems and equipment used by the flightcrew to complete each task. What is the best way to frame this prompt to get a complete listing of tasks, systems, and equipment?

  2. Meta Assistant

    What a behemoth of a prompt! You're asking the LLM to generate an exhaustive, comprehensive, and detailed list of tasks, systems, and equipment for a Part 25 aircraft flightcrew. I'll help you craft a well-structured prompt to maximize the chances of getting a thorough and accurate response. Here's a suggested framework:

    Prompt Structure:

    1. Introduction: Clearly define the scope, context, and requirements.
    2. Task List Request: Ask the LLM to enumerate all tasks performed by the flightcrew.
    3. Systems and Equipment Request: Request a detailed breakdown of installed systems and equipment used for each task.
    4. Specificity and Constraints: Provide guidelines to ensure the response is comprehensive, accurate, and relevant to Part 25 aircraft.
    5. Organization and Format: Suggest a structured format for the response to make it easier to consume and review.

    Here's the prompt:

    "Comprehensive Flightcrew Tasks, Systems, and Equipment Listing for Part 25 Aircraft

    Introduction: For a typical commercial airliner certified under Federal Aviation Regulation Part 25 (e.g., Airbus A320, Boeing 737-800), I need an exhaustive and detailed enumeration of all tasks performed by the flightcrew (Captain, First Officer, and any additional required crew members) from pre-flight preparation to post-flight duties. These tasks should cover normal, non-normal, and emergency procedures.

    Task List Request: Please list every single task that the flightcrew is expected to perform during:

    1. Pre-flight preparation (e.g., flight planning, aircraft inspection, briefing, crew resource management).
    2. Pre-start and engine start procedures.
    3. Taxi and takeoff (including line-up, departure procedures).
    4. Climb, cruise, and descent phases (including navigation, communication, system monitoring, and adjustments).
    5. Approach and landing (including configuration changes, checklist completion, go-around procedures).
    6. Post-flight duties (e.g., shutdown, securing the aircraft, reporting).

    Consider tasks related to: * Aircraft systems management (e.g., fuel, electrical, hydraulic, pressurization). * Navigation and communication (e.g., FMS programming, ATC interactions). * Safety and emergency procedures (e.g., engine failure, system malfunctions, medical emergencies). * Crew coordination and decision-making (e.g., crew resource management, abnormal situation handling). * Passenger and cabin crew interactions (e.g., PA announcements, cabin crew coordination).

    Systems and Equipment Request: For each task listed above, please detail the specific installed aircraft systems and equipment the flightcrew uses to accomplish that task. Include: * Primary Flight Display (PFD) and Multifunction Display (MFD) screens and controls. * Flight Management System (FMS), Flight Control Computers (FCCs), and Autopilot/Flight Director System (AFDS) interactions. * Communication equipment (e.g., VHF radios, HF radios, SATCOM, Interphone). * Navigation aids (e.g., GPS, IRS, VOR, ILS receivers). * Engine and fuel system controls and displays (e.g., FADEC, Fuel Quantity Indication). * Electrical, hydraulic, pressurization, and oxygen system monitoring and controls. * Warning and alerting systems (e.g., Master Warning, GPWS, TCAS, FWS). * Lighting controls (e.g., exterior lights, cabin lights, emergency lighting). * Any other relevant aircraft systems, controls, displays, or equipment.

    Specificity and Constraints:

    • Assume a 'typical' Part 25 aircraft with glass cockpit avionics (e.g., similar to Airbus A320 or Boeing 737 NG systems).
    • Include tasks and systems for both normal operations and failure conditions (e.g., engine failure, system degradations).
    • Reference relevant regulatory guidelines (e.g., FAA, EASA) and industry standards (e.g., SAE, ARINC) where applicable.
    • Exclude tasks solely related to maintenance, ramp handling, or ground support equipment (GSE) operations.

    Organization and Format: To facilitate clarity and review, please structure your response as follows:

    1. Task #X: [Task Description]
      • Phase: (e.g., Pre-flight, Taxi, Cruise)
      • Systems Used: List all relevant aircraft systems (e.g., Autopilot, FMS, Electrical System).
      • Equipment/Controls Involved: Specify the exact controls, displays, or equipment the crew interacts with (e.g., FCU, MCDU, Overhead Panel Hydraulics Section).
      • Crew Member(s) Responsible: Indicate which flightcrew member(s) perform the task (Captain, FO, Both).
      • Regulatory/Reference: Cite relevant Part 25 regulations, aircraft flight manual (AFM) sections, or industry standards supporting the task or system use.

    Repeat this structure for every task identified.

    Final Request: Deliver this comprehensive listing in a clear, tabulated, or Markdown format (e.g., using headers, tables, and bullet points) to ensure readability and ease of use. Aim for maximum detail, as if creating a combined Aircraft Flight Manual (AFM) and Crew Operations Manual (COM) tasks and systems cross-reference.

    Thank you for generating this detailed and crucial information!"

    Why this structure?

    1. Introduction: Sets the context (Part 25 aircraft, commercial airliner scope).
    2. Task List Request: Breaks down the operational phases and hints at the breadth of tasks (normal, abnormal, emergency).
    3. Systems and Equipment Request: Clearly asks for the linkage between tasks and the specific aircraft systems/equipment, naming key systems to ensure coverage.
    4. Specificity and Constraints: Narrows the scope to glass cockpit Part 25 aircraft, includes failure conditions, and excludes irrelevant areas (maintenance, GSE).
    5. Organization and Format: Provides a clear structure for the LLM to follow, making the output organized, easy to read, and review.

    Tips for working with the LLM's response:

    • Verify and Validate: Cross-check the generated tasks and systems against real aircraft documentation (e.g., A320/737 FCOM, AFM) for accuracy.
    • Iterate if Necessary: If the response is incomplete or too generic, refine your prompt with specific gaps or request further detail on particular systems/tasks.
    • Use Markdown or Table Formatting: If the LLM supports it, request the output in Markdown or table format for better readability. You can also post-process the text into tables for easier analysis.

    This exhaustive prompt should nudge the LLM to produce a remarkably detailed response, giving you a valuable resource that approximates a combined operational and systems manual for Part 25 flightcrews. Good luck, and happy validating!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.