Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwen3-30b-a3b· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Are british hotels always so expensive, e.g. Edinburgh normal hotel around $150-200 a…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Qwenqwen3-235b-a22b-no-thinking’s answer.
  1. User

    Are british hotels always so expensive, e.g. Edinburgh normal hotel around $150-200 a night

  2. Qwen Assistant

    British hotels, including those in Edinburgh, are not always expensive, but prices can vary significantly depending on factors like season, location, and type of accommodation. Here's a breakdown to help clarify:

    1. Edinburgh's Hotel Prices

    • Average Range: A mid-range hotel in Edinburgh (e.g., 3-4 stars) typically costs £100–£180 per night (roughly 120–120–220 USD), depending on the season and booking time. So 150–150–200 is within the typical range for a decent hotel, especially during peak times.
    • Peak vs. Off-Peak:
      • Peak seasons (e.g., Edinburgh Festival Fringe in August, summer months, or weekends) can push prices higher, sometimes exceeding £200/night.
      • Off-peak (e.g., January–March, weekdays) may offer discounts, with budget hotels or guesthouses available for £60–£100/night (70–70–120 USD).

    2. Factors Affecting Costs

    • Location: Hotels near major attractions (e.g., the Royal Mile, Edinburgh Castle) tend to be pricier. Consider staying slightly outside the city center for better deals.
    • Seasonality: Prices drop significantly in winter or during low-demand periods.
    • Type of Accommodation:
      • Budget options: Hostels, guesthouses, or boutique hotels can be much cheaper.
      • Luxury hotels: Expect to pay £200+ (around $250+ USD) for upscale properties.

    3. Alternatives to Traditional Hotels

    • Airbnb/Short-Term Rentals: Often cheaper for longer stays, though prices vary.
    • Hostels: Dorm beds start at £20–£40/night (25–25–50 USD), ideal for budget travelers.
    • B&Bs: A good middle ground, often cheaper than hotels and offering a more personalized experience.

    4. Why It Might Feel Expensive

    • Tourism: Edinburgh is a major tourist hub, driving up demand and prices.
    • High Operating Costs: UK hotels often have higher overheads (e.g., taxes, staffing) compared to some other regions.
    • Exchange Rates: If you're paying in a currency weaker than the GBP, prices may feel steeper.

    5. Tips for Saving Money

    • Book early or last-minute for discounts.
    • Look for special offers on sites like Booking.com, Expedia, or Airbnb.
    • Consider weekdays over weekends, as prices often drop.

    Conclusion

    While Edinburgh hotels can be pricey, especially during peak times, 150–150–200/night is reasonable for a mid-range stay. By planning ahead, choosing budget-friendly options, or traveling during off-peak seasons, you can find more affordable accommodations. Always compare prices across platforms and consider alternatives like hostels or B&Bs for flexibility.

  3. User

    wow, interesting! I didn't expect them to be so expensive

  4. Qwen Assistant

    Ah, I totally get it! The UK (and Edinburgh in particular) can feel pricey compared to other places, especially if you're used to lower costs elsewhere. But here’s the thing: it’s not always expensive—it just depends on how you plan and where you go. Let me break it down a bit more to help you feel more confident:


    Why It Feels Expensive (But It’s Not the Whole Story)

    1. Tourism Hotspot: Edinburgh is one of the UK’s most visited cities, especially during festivals (like the Fringe) or summer. That drives up demand and prices. But if you avoid peak times, you’ll find much better deals.
    2. Cost of Living: The UK has higher living costs overall (taxes, wages, etc.), which can make hotels seem pricier. But this also means the quality of service and amenities is often top-notch.
    3. Location Matters: Staying near the city center or attractions is pricier, but staying a bit farther out (e.g., near a train station or in a quieter area) can save you 20–30% on accommodation.

    How to Save Money Without Sacrificing Comfort

    • Book Early or Last-Minute: Prices often drop if you book 2–3 months in advance or wait until the day before (especially in off-peak seasons).
    • Use Price Comparison Sites: Platforms like Booking.com, Expedia, or Hostelworld let you compare hotels, hostels, and B&Bs.
    • Consider Alternatives:
      • Hostels: Dorm beds start at £20–£30 (£25–£35 USD) for a basic stay.
      • B&Bs: Often cheaper than hotels and offer a cozy, local feel. Look for ones with good reviews on Airbnb or TripAdvisor.
      • Guesthouses: Smaller, family-run places that are often more affordable and personalized.
    • Travel Off-Peak: January–March or weekdays (not weekends) can cut prices in half. Even a 2–3-day trip in winter can be much cheaper.

    Pro Tips for Edinburgh Specifically

    • Stay Near the Train Station: Places like Waverley Station or Haymarket are cheaper and still a short walk or tram ride to the city center.
    • Check for Deals: Some hotels offer free breakfast or discounts for students (if you’re eligible).
    • Use Public Transport: A day pass or single tickets are super affordable and help you avoid parking costs.

    Final Thought

    Yes, Edinburgh hotels can feel pricey, but with a bit of planning, you can find great stays for 100–100–150/night (or even less). And remember: the city itself is worth the investment! The architecture, history, and atmosphere are unforgettable. If you’re flexible with dates or accommodation type, you’ll likely find something that fits your budget.

    Let me know if you’d like help finding specific deals or comparing options! 😊

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.