Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.0-flash-001· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

I had a mentee that I worked with who wants a short recommendation on linkedin. Can you…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Metallama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct’s answer.
  1. User

    I had a mentee that I worked with who wants a short recommendation on linkedin. Can you ask me a few questions so that I can find out what I should write about him?

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, great! To help me craft a strong and impactful LinkedIn recommendation for your mentee, let's consider these questions:

    About the Mentee's Strengths and Qualities:

    1. What were the mentee's standout qualities or skills that you observed during your mentorship? (Think about things like their work ethic, problem-solving abilities, creativity, communication skills, leadership potential, technical proficiency, etc.)

    2. What specific goals or projects did the mentee work on during your mentorship? (Knowing the context will help me be more specific.)

    3. What was the biggest area where you saw growth or improvement in the mentee? (This shows the impact of the mentorship.)

    4. What soft skills does the mentee have that are worth highlighting? (Think about things like teamwork, adaptability, communication, leadership skills, etc.)

    5. If you were hiring for a role, what would be the mentee's biggest selling point? (What makes them a valuable asset?)

    About the Mentorship:

    1. What was the overall focus of your mentorship? (e.g., career development, skill building, specific project support, etc.)

    2. How long did you mentor this person and in what capacity? (Formal program? Informal guidance? For how many months/years?)

    About the Recommendation's Purpose:

    1. What kind of role is your mentee looking for, or what industry are they trying to break into? (This will help tailor the recommendation to their specific goals.)

    2. Is there anything specific the mentee would like you to highlight? (Sometimes they have a particular achievement or skill they want to emphasize.)

    Once I have this information, I can help you write a concise, impactful, and authentic LinkedIn recommendation.

  3. User

    Thanks! Here are my answers. Can you write 2 suggestions what I should write as a recommendation.

    Q: What was the context of your mentorship? Was it a formal program, or an informal arrangement? How long did you work together? A: I was the program manager of a software product development team and he was a business analyst. It was informal he asked me for advice. We worked for about ~1.5 years

    Q: What were your mentee's goals or objectives during the time you worked together? Were there any specific areas they were trying to improve or develop? A: Yes, he wanted to become a better manager, especially better moderating meetings, preparing them, and leading small projects

    Q: What were some of the mentee's strengths that you observed or that they demonstrated during your time together? A: He not just took advice but implemented it eagerly. That was his standout qualification!

    Q: Were there any notable achievements, successes, or accomplishments that your mentee made during your mentorship? A: He started a small project that get praises by other managers because it was so well prepared

    Q: What kind of tone are you aiming for in the recommendation? Do you want it to be formal and professional, or a bit more personal and friendly? A: More personal :)

    Q: What specific goals or projects did the mentee work on during your mentorship? (Knowing the context will help me be more specific.) A: He worked on a new feature for one of the software products we developed

    Q: What was the biggest area where you saw growth or improvement in the mentee? (This shows the impact of the mentorship.) A: He improved his communication, his presentation skills, learned how to manage meetings and small projects.

    Q: What soft skills does the mentee have that are worth highlighting? (Think about things like teamwork, adaptability, communication, leadership skills, etc.) A: He was incredible at networking and knowing the right people or knew how to find them, build rapport, etc.

    Q: If you were hiring for a role, what would be the mentee's biggest selling point? (What makes them a valuable asset?) A: Quick learner, actually implements what he learns, great networker and gets things done

    Q: What was the overall focus of your mentorship? (e.g., career development, skill building, specific project support, etc.) A: It was career development to bring him from an SME to a business analyst position and building up fundamental managmeent skills

    Q: How long did you mentor this person and in what capacity? (Formal program? Informal guidance? For how many months/years?) A: about half a year

    Q: What kind of role is your mentee looking for, or what industry are they trying to break into? (This will help tailor the recommendation to their specific goals.) A: He works in insurance but he just wants a recommendation without any goal

  4. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, great! Based on your input, here are two options for a LinkedIn recommendation for your mentee, with a personal and friendly tone:

    Option 1 (Focus on action and implementation):

    I had the pleasure of working with [Mentee's Name] while he was a Business Analyst on my team. What truly impressed me about [Mentee's Name] was his eagerness to not just learn, but to implement. He consistently sought advice and then put it into practice, leading to significant growth in his communication, meeting management, and project leadership skills. He even spearheaded a small project that received high praise! [Mentee's Name] is a quick learner, a fantastic networker, and someone who truly gets things done. Any team would be lucky to have him!

    Option 2 (Focus on growth and potential):

    I thoroughly enjoyed working with [Mentee's Name] over the last six months. During that time, I witnessed a remarkable transformation in his skills and confidence. He's a natural networker with a knack for building rapport, and he's always eager to learn and grow. I had many conversations on leadership topics with him and it was wonderful to see his project management and communication skills flourish – particularly his ability to lead meetings and small projects. [Mentee's Name] has the potential to achieve great things, and I highly recommend him. He's a valuable asset with a bright future!

    Key takeaways in both recommendations

    • Mentions his drive to implement advice and learnings
    • Highlights the skills he developed (communication, meeting management, project leadership, networking)
    • Emphasizes his value as a quick learner and "gets things done"
    • Maintains a friendly and personal tone.

    Choose the one that best reflects your experience and the aspects of your mentee's development you want to highlight. Good luck!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.