Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o3-2025-04-16· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

yes please prioritize and also give approaches how to mitigate these vulnerability, in…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-3-7-sonnet-20250219-thinking-32k’s answer.
  1. User

    yes please prioritize and also give approaches how to mitigate these vulnerability, in some custom module we are using spring mvc how to mitigate these vulnerability with liferay OOTB features also provide approaches.

  2. Assistant

    1 Why these CVEs suddenly show up

    After moving from an on-premise 6.2 portal to Liferay DXP 7.4 in the cloud you are:

    • Packaging your custom code as OSGi modules but you still depend on Spring MVC / Spring Security / Spring Data Jars.
    • Black Duck scans the full container image, so it also inspects:
      • The Spring libraries already shipped by Liferay.
      • The (older) Spring jars that are shaded or embedded in 3ʳᵈ-party libraries you added yourself.
    • As a result you see many duplicates of the same CVE and some “future” or “unknown” entries that are simply finger-print mismatches.

    2 Prioritised list (what really matters for a typical Liferay DXP 7.4 stack)

    PriorityCVEComponentFixed versionExploitability in Liferay
    🔴 Critical (RCE)2022-22965 (Spring4Shell)spring-webmvc ≤ 5.3.17 / 5.2.195.3.18 / 5.2.20Always relevant – classic RCE via data binding
    2018-1270Spring Data Commons1.13.11, 2.0.6, 2.1.0RCE but only if you expose Repository REST or custom converters
    2018-1272Spring Data REST2.6.9, 2.7.5, 3.0.1idem
    2020-5421Spring Cloud Function3.1.7, 3.2.3Only if you run SCF in your bundle
    2022-22968Spring Cloud Gateway3.0.7, 3.1.1Rare in Liferay – check reverse proxy modules
    🟠 High2023-20861 / 20863Spring Framework5.3.28 / 6.0.10DoS via PathPattern & ReDoS – reachable via standard controllers
    2018-1271 / 1275spring-webmvc / Spring Security≥ 5.0.6Multipart traversal & SpEL injection
    2022-22950 / 22971 / 22970Spring Cloud familysee advisoriesMostly N/A unless micro-services used
    🟡 Medium2018-1199 / 11039 / 1257 / 15756Spring Boot Actuator, Binding, OAuthpatch in Boot 1.5.14 / 2.0.4 / etc.Relevant only when actuator endpoints are exposed
    ⚪ Possibly false-positive / future2024-388xx, 2025-22233, “Unknown”––Not in NVD – ignore for now
    🟤 Low2016-9878 / 5007 / 1000027Old Spring / Bouncy Castlefixed years agoAlready fixed in Liferay’s bundles

    👉 Action rule: If the vulnerable class is not present in your final OSGi container or is overriden by a newer version, the CVE is already mitigated.


    3 How to mitigate – 4-layer approach

    Layer 1 (Liferay baseline)

    1. Upgrade to the latest Liferay DXP 7.4 Update / Cumulative Fix Pack – each update contains patched Spring bundles.
      ./patching-tool.sh auto-discovery
      ./patching-tool.sh info
      ./patching-tool.sh install <latest-fix-pack.zip>
      
    2. Re-start the portal; check the Gogo shell:
      lb spring | grep "Resolved"    # every Spring bundle should show ≥ 5.3.29
      

    Layer 2 (Dependency governance for custom modules)

    For every *-service, *-web or integration module:

    Gradle example

    plugins { id "com.liferay.plugin" }
    repositories { mavenCentral() }
    
    ext.springVersion = "5.3.30"   // or 6.x if you compile for JDK 17+
    
    dependencies {
        compileOnly group: "org.osgi", name: "org.osgi.service.component.annotations", version: "1.5.0"
        compileOnly platform("org.springframework:spring-framework-bom:${springVersion}")
        compileOnly "org.springframework:spring-webmvc"
        // … other Spring deps
    
        // Enforce versions to override transitive old ones
        constraints {
            implementation("org.springframework:spring-beans:${springVersion}") { because "Patch Spring4Shell" }
            …
        }
    }
    

    Rules

    • compileOnly / provided – so the jar is not embedded in the module.
    • Use a BOM or if you are on Maven.
    • Add a Gradle resolution strategy (all*.dependencySubstitution) to fail the build if something pulls an outdated Spring jar.

    Layer 3 (Configuration hardening)

    Even after upgrading, tighten attack surface:

    Spring MVC controller hardening

    @InitBinder
    public void binder(WebDataBinder binder) {
        binder.setDisallowedFields("class.*", "*.class.*", "*.*.class.*");
    }
    

    Global properties (in portal-ext.properties or system-settings):

    # Disable dangerous SpEL in data binding
    spring.mvc.format.use-global-cache=true
    spring.expression.cache.enabled=true
    # Ensure multipart config limits
    spring.servlet.multipart.max-request-size=10MB
    spring.servlet.multipart.max-file-size=10MB
    

    Disable/secure Actuator endpoints (management.endpoints.web.exposure.include=health,info).

    Layer 4 (Leverage Liferay OOTB instead of Spring MVC where possible)

    FeatureSpring wayLiferay native & safer
    Portlet MVC@Controller with SpringMVCMVCPortlet or RestBuilder generated *ResourceImpl
    REST API@RestControllerLiferay REST Builder → JAX-RS whiteboard; auto-security, rate-limit
    SecuritySpring Security filtersLiferay’s AuthVerifier, CSRFToken, OAuth2 apps
    Background jobs@ScheduledLiferay SchedulerEntryImpl, Dispatch App
    Configapplication.propertiesConfigurationProvider, System Settings UI

    Migrating to these reduces the number of external Spring libs you carry, hence fewer CVEs to watch.


    4 Concrete next steps checklist ✅

    1. Check your current Liferay fix-pack level → install the newest.
    2. Produce an SBOM (gradle cyclonedxBom) – confirm no Spring ≤ 5.3.17 left.
    3. Clean build.gradle / pom.xml: use BOM and compileOnly.
    4. Re-run Black Duck; the list should shrink to informational items.
    5. For the remaining true-positives, apply the Layer 3 hardening snippets.
    6. Where feasible, plan tech-debt sprint to swap Spring MVC controllers for Liferay REST Builder / MVCPortlet patterns.

    Need deeper help?

    If you want a script that walks your repo and rewrites old spring-*.jar versions, or sample code that replaces a Spring MVC controller with an Liferay REST Builder resource, let me know and I’ll include it.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.