Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-flash-lite-preview-06-17-thinking· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

which video encoder should be used for recording obs videos with a nvda 5070 graphics…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Coherecommand-a-03-2025’s answer.
  1. User

    which video encoder should be used for recording obs videos with a nvda 5070 graphics card? nvidia nvenc (av1, h.264, hevc)? a different one?

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, let's break down the best encoder choice for your NVIDIA RTX graphics card (I'll assume "nvda 5070" is a typo and you mean something like an RTX 4070 or a similar current/recent generation card, as a 5070 doesn't exist yet. The principles apply to RTX 30-series and 40-series).

    NVIDIA NVENC is absolutely the way to go.

    You should definitely use one of the NVIDIA NVENC options within OBS, rather than a CPU-based encoder like x264. Here's why and which specific NVENC codec might be best for you:

    Why NVENC?

    1. Performance: NVENC utilizes a dedicated chip on your RTX graphics card. This means it has a minimal impact on your system's performance, especially crucial if you are gaming while recording. CPU encoding (x264) can significantly reduce your frame rates in games.
    2. Quality: Modern NVENC encoders (especially on RTX 30-series and 40-series cards) provide excellent quality, often rivaling or even exceeding CPU encoding at similar performance costs.

    Which NVENC Codec to Choose?

    Your RTX card supports H.264, HEVC (H.265), and AV1 via NVENC.

    1. AV1 (NVIDIA NVENC AV1):

      • Pros: Offers the best compression efficiency. This means you get the highest quality for the smallest file size, or the smallest file size for a given quality level, compared to H.264 and HEVC. The NVENC AV1 encoder on RTX 40-series cards is quite good.
      • Cons: Requires a relatively recent GPU (like yours) for hardware encoding. Compatibility is good but not as universal as H.264 (most modern players, browsers, and editing software handle it, but older ones might not). The quality of early hardware AV1 encoders might still be slightly behind the latest HEVC implementations in specific edge cases, but it's generally excellent.
      • Recommendation: Use this if file size is a priority, or you want the most future-proof format, and you have an RTX 30-series or newer card. Ensure your OBS version and NVIDIA drivers are up-to-date.
    2. HEVC / H.265 (NVIDIA NVENC HEVC):

      • Pros: Offers significantly better compression efficiency than H.264 (smaller files or better quality). Widely supported on modern hardware and software. Provides a great balance between quality, file size, and compatibility.
      • Cons: Less efficient than AV1. Slightly less compatible than H.264, but this is rarely an issue today.
      • Recommendation: This is often the best all-around choice. It offers a great quality/file size ratio with excellent performance and broad compatibility. It's a safe and efficient default.
    3. H.264 / AVC (NVIDIA NVENC H.264):

      • Pros: Offers the highest compatibility. Virtually everything can play H.264 files. Still provides good quality with NVENC, much better than CPU x264 at the same performance cost.
      • Cons: Least efficient codec, resulting in larger file sizes for the same quality compared to HEVC and AV1.
      • Recommendation: Use this if you encounter playback or compatibility issues with HEVC/AV1, or if you need maximum compatibility with older systems or specific software.

    Suggested OBS Settings (General Guide):

    • Encoder: Choose NVIDIA NVENC HEVC (recommended default) or NVIDIA NVENC AV1 (for best efficiency) or NVIDIA NVENC H.264 (for max compatibility).
    • Rate Control:
      • For AV1/HEVC/H.264: CQP (Constant Quantization Parameter) is often recommended for recording as it prioritizes quality. Aim for a value between 18 and 23 (lower values mean better quality and larger files). 20 is often a good starting point.
      • Alternatively, use CBR (Constant Bitrate) if you need a specific file size or bitrate. Choose a value suitable for your resolution and framerate (e.g., 50,000 Kbps - 100,000 Kbps or higher for 1440p/4K 60fps recording).
    • Preset: Quality or Max Quality. Max Quality uses slightly more GPU resources but can yield better results.
    • Profile: main or main10. Use main10 if you are recording in HDR or want slightly better quality potential (uses 10-bit color). If unsure, main is fine.
    • Look-ahead / Psycho Visual Tuning: Enabling these can improve quality, especially Psycho Visual Tuning, but might slightly increase GPU usage. Experiment with them enabled.

    In summary: For your RTX card, use NVIDIA NVENC. Start with HEVC for a good balance, consider AV1 if you need smaller files or want the latest tech, and fall back to H.264 only if compatibility is a major issue.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.