Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwen3-235b-a22b-no-thinking· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Please recommend best free non repainting indicator for mt4

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-sonnet-4-20250514’s answer.
  1. User

    Please recommend best free non repainting indicator for mt4

  2. Qwen Assistant

    When looking for free non-repainting indicators for MetaTrader 4 (MT4), it's important to understand that "non-repainting" means the indicator does not change or redraw past signals once they have been plotted. Many custom indicators repaint, especially those using future data or repainting logic in their code, which can be misleading during backtesting or live trading.

    Below are some of the best free non-repainting indicators for MT4, commonly used by traders:


    ✅ 1. Heiken Ashi Smoothed (Non-Repainting Version)

    • Purpose: Helps identify trends more clearly than regular candlesticks.
    • Why It’s Good: The smoothed version removes market noise and provides clean trend signals.
    • Non-Repainting: Yes, if coded properly.
    • Where to Get It:
      • MQL4 Forum
      • GitHub or trusted MT4 indicator repositories
    • Usage Tip: Combine with other tools like moving averages or support/resistance levels.

    ✅ 2. Fractals Indicator (Standard MT4 Built-in)

    • Purpose: Identifies potential reversal points.
    • Why It’s Good: Comes built into MT4; does not repaint if used correctly.
    • Non-Repainting: Yes, though some custom versions may repaint.
    • Tip: Use the default version from MT4 platform under “Bill Williams.”

    ✅ 3. ZigZag Indicator (Non-Delay / Non-Repainting Version)

    • Purpose: Highlights major price swings and patterns.
    • Why It’s Good: Useful for identifying swing highs/lows and chart patterns.
    • Non-Repainting: Standard ZigZag can lag, but many modified versions exist that avoid repainting.
    • Where to Find:
      • MQL4.com or Code Base
      • Search: ZigZag no repaint or ZigZag non repainting

    ✅ 4. Moving Averages (MA, EMA, SMA, etc.)

    • Purpose: Trend identification and dynamic support/resistance.
    • Why It’s Good: Fully non-repainting as they're based on historical data.
    • Non-Repainting: Yes, always.
    • Tip: Use combinations like the 50 & 200-period MA crossovers (Golden Cross/Death Cross).

    ✅ 5. RSI (Relative Strength Index) – Standard Version

    • Purpose: Overbought/Oversold levels, divergence detection.
    • Why It’s Good: Classic oscillator; widely used and reliable.
    • Non-Repainting: Yes, unless customized with lookahead bars.
    • Tip: Avoid aggressive signal lines like RSI 30/70; use 20/80 for better accuracy.

    ✅ 6. MACD (Moving Average Convergence Divergence)

    • Purpose: Momentum and trend changes.
    • Why It’s Good: One of the most popular and reliable momentum indicators.
    • Non-Repainting: Yes, standard version doesn't repaint.
    • Tip: Use histogram crossovers and zero-line crosses for confirmation.

    ✅ 7. Volume Indicator (Tick Volume or Real Volume if available)

    • Purpose: Measures strength behind price moves.
    • Why It’s Good: High volume confirms trends or warns of reversals.
    • Non-Repainting: Yes, although tick volume ≠ real exchange volume.
    • Tip: Combine with price action for confluence.

    🚫 Avoid Repainting Indicators Like:

    • Fibonacci Retracements drawn after the fact
    • Custom repaint MT4 indicators (e.g., “90% win rate” arrows that disappear/change)
    • Indicators using iBands, iEnvelopes, or future data` in calculation

    🔍 How to Check If an Indicator Repaints:

    1. Test it on a static chart – draw lines/arrows and scroll left/right.
    2. Use Strategy Tester – see if signals disappear or change over time.
    3. Review the source code (if available) – look for shift values or future data references.

    💡 Bonus: Free MT4 Indicator Sources


    Summary Table

    IndicatorTypeNon-RepaintingBuilt-in
    Heiken Ashi SmoothedTrend Filter✅ (custom)❌
    FractalsReversal✅✅
    ZigZagSwing Points✅ (modified)❌
    Moving AveragesTrend✅✅
    RSIOscillator✅✅
    MACDMomentum✅✅
    VolumeConfirmation✅✅

    If you'd like, I can provide download links or attach specific .mq4 files (where allowed), or help you modify existing indicators to prevent repainting.

    Let me know what strategy or trading style you're using — I can tailor the recommendation!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.