Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o4-mini-2025-04-16· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

If I want to make a carbonic maceration white wine what are some considerations I should…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with MiniMaxminimax-m1’s answer.
  1. User

    If I want to make a carbonic maceration white wine what are some considerations I should have in terms of when to pick the grapes and what the process should look like for the first 5 days of the wine making process

  2. Assistant

    Here are some key considerations and a day-by-day sketch of how you might approach a carbonic-maceration “white” wine.

    1. Harvest timing
      • Target somewhat underripe fruit (18–20°Brix) so you retain bright acidity (TA ~7–9 g/L) and moderate pH (3.1–3.3).
      • Avoid any rot or botrytis—the whole‐cluster style demands super‐clean fruit.
      • Choose a grape with aromatic potential (e.g. Muscat, Riesling, Grüner Veltliner) so you’ll pick up those juicy ester notes.

    2. Equipment & setup
      • A sealed stainless or plastic tank with a gas‐tight lid.
      • CO₂ on hand to purge O₂ (you want a fully anaerobic headspace).
      • Temperature control: aim for 18–22 °C to encourage intracellular (enzymatic) fermentation without excessive heat.
      • A gentle pump/press for Day 4 or 5.

    3. SO₂ strategy
      • If you’re sensitive to oxidation, dose juice or must with 20–30 ppm SO₂ at crush/press.
      • Keep everything as reductive as possible until you press.


    First-5-Day Outline

    DayWhat’s HappeningTargets & Tasks
    0 (harvest & fill)– Bring in whole clusters (no destem)– Cull rotten berries– Fill tank ¾–100%– Purge headspace with CO₂– Seal up– Fruit at ~18–20°Brix, TA ~8 g/L– Tank O₂ < 0.5 ppm– Temp set 18–22 °C
    1 (kick-off)– Intracellular fermentation begins: • Malic → ethanol (~1–2% ABV) • Aroma precursors (esters) form– Check temp & gas seal– Maintain 18–22 °C– Top up with CO₂ if needed
    2 (monitor)– Continue anaerobic maceration– Some berries may start to “blow”—tiny gas pockets inside
    – Taste for early aromatic lift (banana, stone-fruit, bubble-gum notes)– Check temp twice daily– Ensure no O₂ ingress
    3 (evaluate)– You’ve generated ~2–3% ABV inside the berries
    – Assess need to press soon (if too much juice is escaping, you risk oxidation at the bottom)– Measure Brix trend (down ~2–4°Brix)– Decide pressing day (3, 4 or 5)
    4 (press)– Gently press all berries & must
    – Collect free-run first (highest quality)
    – Run press fraction if desired– Press at low pressure (<0.5 bar)
    – Transfer juice to fermenter under CO₂ blanketing
    – Top with SO₂ up to 30 ppm if not already done
    5 (post-press)– Primary fermentation now finishes as a “normal” white wine– Optionally inoculate with wine yeast to ensure it goes dry– Keep it cool (15–18 °C) & reductive– Monitor density (fermentation rate)– Rack off gross lees after 24–48 h if needed

    A Few Extra Tips

    • Because you’re macerating white grapes you won’t pick up much color, but you will get an intense fruit-driven palate and some extra glycerol.
    • If you love funk, let the pressed juice rest on lees for a week or two before racking.
    • Keep everything as oxygen‐free as possible to preserve freshness and avoid browning.
    • Taste every day—carbonic maceration is as much art as science.

    Enjoy the process! 🍇✨ What variety are you thinking of using?

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.