Let's talk about swimming. I filmed a 100m medley of me. I can see a general problem…
- User
Let's talk about swimming. I filmed a 100m medley of me. I can see a general problem with elbows outside of the shoulder line in all 4 strokes in the video. For example in breaststroke my elbows obviously create a lot of drag in the glide phase because they are more than shoulder width apart. I think this shows a lack of shoulder flexibility. Help me to understand whe exectly my flexibility is insufficent. I already saw a youtube video called " Swimming - Freestyle - The Scapular Plane and How to Move Your Shoulder Properly to Prevent Injury ". I think it discusses part of the problem, but unfortunately I don't really what is the conclusion of the video.
- Assistant
Your observation about your elbows drifting outside the shoulder line during all strokes (and especially during breaststroke’s glide phase) is a useful insight. It often points to limitations—not just in overall flexibility—but more specifically in the combination of shoulder joint and scapular mobility as well as thoracic extension. Here are some factors and considerations that might explain your observed issues:
1. Scapular Positioning and the Scapular Plane
-
What It Means:
The “scapular plane” refers to the ideal plane in which the scapula (shoulder blade) naturally moves. Keeping your arms (or at least your elbows) in or near this plane generally reduces unnecessary drag and avoids undue stress on the shoulder. -
The Issue:
If your elbows are consistently outside of this plane (i.e., too far laterally), it can suggest that your scapula isn’t being positioned or mobilized properly. This misalignment might partly be due to either a lack of neuromuscular control or—indeed—a flexibility issue within the shoulder complex.
2. Glenohumeral Joint Mobility (Shoulder Flexibility)
-
Internal Rotation and Capsule Flexibility:
For many swimming strokes, especially when recovering or preparing for the pull phase, you need a good range of internal rotation. If the joint capsule or the rotator cuff muscles (especially those responsible for internal rotation) are tight or limited, your elbow might not follow the ideal curved path inward. -
Implications for Breaststroke:
During the glide phase, an “open” elbow (one that is too wide) increases drag. This could be a symptom that your shoulder lacks the necessary internal rotation flexibility or that the muscles that help retract the arm aren’t engaging as they should.
3. Thoracic Spine Mobility
-
Why It Matters:
Your shoulder function isn’t isolated—it’s closely linked to the mobility of your thoracic spine (upper back). Limited thoracic extension can force your shoulder into compensatory positions, causing your arm/ elbow to travel outside the optimal plane. -
The Link to Your Observation:
Inability to rotate or extend properly in your upper back might make it harder to reposition your shoulder and elbow during the stroke, manifesting as the elbows drifting outwards.
4. Neuromuscular Control and Muscle Balance
-
Scapular Stabilizers:
Even if raw flexibility (or passive range of motion) is adequate, the active control provided by the muscles that stabilize the scapula (like the serratus anterior and lower trapezius) is crucial. Weakness or poor timing in these muscles can result in improper positioning during dynamic movements. -
External vs. Internal Muscle Tension:
Sometimes, repetitive training patterns can cause the muscles on the front of your shoulder (and chest) to become dominant, pulling your arms outward. This imbalance then forces other muscles to “overwork” in an attempt to reposition your arms, which may give the impression of insufficient flexibility.
5. What the YouTube Video Likely Conveyed
The video you mentioned ("Swimming - Freestyle - The Scapular Plane and How to Move Your Shoulder Properly to Prevent Injury") probably emphasized that:
-
Efficient Technique Is Not Just About Arm Movements:
Proper swimming technique involves keeping your shoulders in a position that minimizes stress and drag. This is achieved by maintaining the proper scapular alignment and movement. -
Flexibility and Stability Go Hand-in-Hand:
Improved flexibility in the shoulder, along with enhanced muscular control of the scapula and thoracic spine, is key both for injury prevention and for more efficient stroke mechanics. -
Addressing the Problem:
They likely recommended drills and exercises targeting shoulder rotation, scapular stabilization, and thoracic extension to help reorient your stroke mechanics.
6. How to Assess and Address Your Flexibility Issue
-
Self-Assessment and Measurement:
Consider a focused assessment—either with a trained swim coach or a physical therapist specialized in sports medicine—to determine your range of motion in internal rotation, scapular movement, and thoracic extension. -
Targeted Stretches and Mobility Drills:
- Shoulder Stretches: Focus on increasing internal rotation and posterior capsule flexibility. For example, using a towel or band to stretch the rotator cuff can be beneficial.
- Scapular Mobilization: Exercises like wall slides or scapular push-ups help train your scapula to move in the correct plane.
- Thoracic Mobility Exercises: Foam rolling, thoracic extensions on a foam roller, or seated thoracic rotations can help improve upper back flexibility.
-
Strength and Neuromuscular Control:
Strengthening the rotator cuff and scapular stabilizers (serratus anterior, lower trapezius) ensures that even if you have the flexibility, you can control it during the dynamic movements of your stroke.
Conclusion
Your observation of elbows drifting outward suggests that there might be a combined issue involving shoulder internal rotation, scapular control, and perhaps even thoracic mobility. Rather than seeing it as a simple "lack of shoulder flexibility," it may be more accurate to say that the system (shoulder joint, scapula, and upper back) isn’t moving in harmony. The takeaway is to work both on improving the flexibility (passive range of motion) and the active control (stability and neuromuscular coordination) of these areas. Engaging with a professional who understands swimming biomechanics can help you pinpoint which specific component is most limiting for you and devise tailored exercises to correct it.
-
- User
So is internal rotation more important than external rotation? When I tested my shoulder mobility the most obvious results was a problem with external rotation for the left shoulder (I used wall slides for the test). I think this effects shows especially in backstroke (recovery of the left arm). I also tested pec stretches using a doorframe: I think here both arm are affected by a lack of flexibility.
- Assistant
Both internal and external rotations are important, but their roles differ depending on the swimming stroke and phase of the stroke. In an ideal scenario, you want balance and sufficient range in both directions to allow for efficient, injury-free mechanics.
Internal vs. External Rotation in Swimming
-
Internal Rotation:
- Role:
Internal rotation is crucial during the pull-through phase of strokes like freestyle and medley. It helps position your hand and arm optimally for generating propulsion. Additionally, internal rotation is involved when tucking the arm close to the body in order to reduce drag. - Implications of Limited Internal Rotation:
A deficit can affect efficiency in propelling your stroke and can lead to compensatory motions that may put extra stress on the shoulder.
- Role:
-
External Rotation:
- Role:
External rotation is especially important during the recovery phase of the stroke—for example, in backstroke where the recovering arm needs to rotate externally to prepare for a smooth and safe entry. Adequate external rotation helps maintain a fluid arm path and reduces stress on the rotator cuff. - Implications of Limited External Rotation:
As you noted with your left shoulder during wall slide testing, limited external rotation can impede a smooth recovery. This can cause improper arm positioning, potentially leading to inefficiencies in stroke mechanics or increased risk of injury.
- Role:
Observations from Your Testing
-
Left Shoulder External Rotation Deficit:
Your test showing an external rotation limitation on the left side could particularly affect backstroke, where the left arm’s recovery is dependent on achieving enough external rotation. This might result in an altered arm path and possible compensations with other parts of the shoulder or torso. -
Pectoral Tightness:
Tight pectoral muscles (observed during your doorframe pec stretch) can restrict both internal and external shoulder rotations by limiting scapular mobility. When your pecs are tight, they can pull your shoulders into a more protracted or internally rotated position at rest, making it even more challenging to achieve full external rotation later on.
Balancing the Two
Rather than prioritizing one over the other, the key is addressing both:
-
Address Tightness:
- Pectoral Stretches:
Continue with or even increase your focus on stretching the chest muscles. This can help open up the shoulder girdle, enabling better external rotation. - Dynamic and Static Stretches:
Incorporate dynamic stretches before swimming to prepare your muscles and static stretches after your workouts to maintain flexibility.
- Pectoral Stretches:
-
Strengthening and Mobility Drills:
- Rotator Cuff Exercises:
Incorporate exercises that target both the internal and external rotators to ensure balanced strength. For example, internal rotation exercises with a resistance band can be balanced with external rotation exercises. - Scapular Stability:
Work on scapular stabilizer exercises (such as scapular push-ups or wall slides with a focus on controlled movement) to reinforce proper shoulder mechanics.
- Rotator Cuff Exercises:
-
Technique Focus:
- Stroke Analysis:
Work with a coach or do more video analysis to further identify how these limitations are affecting your stroke. Sometimes small adjustments in technique can also help accommodate these flexibility deficits while you work on their improvement.
- Stroke Analysis:
Conclusion
Neither internal nor external rotation is inherently more important overall—they each have critical roles during different phases of your stroke. In your case, your limited external rotation (notably on your left shoulder) appears to be affecting your backstroke recovery, while tight pecs might be affecting both sides by limiting overall shoulder mobility. Focusing on a balanced approach that includes flexibility work, targeted strengthening of both the internal and external rotators, and ensuring proper scapular mechanics will help you achieve more efficient and healthier stroke mechanics in the long run.
-
- User
I wonder if a deeper hand position (e.g. 20 cm to 30 cm under the surface)would facilitate a good elbow position for me. Maybe my bad elbow positioning in the 100m medley is a combination of poor flexibility with unnecessary high hands (nearly a the surface).
- Assistant
The positioning of your hand in the water can indeed affect your elbow positioning, and there is a good chance that a slightly deeper hand placement could help you achieve a more optimal elbow alignment—even if you do have some flexibility limitations. Here’s some insight into how a deeper hand position might be beneficial and what to consider:
How Hand Position Affects Elbow Alignment
-
Changing the Angle of Entry and Pull:
When your hand is positioned closer to 20–30 cm beneath the surface rather than skimming the top layer, it can naturally encourage your arm to enter the water at a slightly different angle. This may allow your elbow to track in a more appropriate path relative to your shoulder line throughout the pull. -
Reducing Surface Drag:
Hands at the surface can sometimes create more surface drag and may force you to compensate by “fighting” with your elbow position. A deeper hand position can help streamline your hand and arm path, potentially reducing the tendency for your elbows to flare out. -
Encouraging a More Effective Catch:
With your hand deeper, you might find it easier to engage a proper catch, where you’re using more of a favorable hand paddle position. This can help keep your elbow under better control, preventing it from drifting too far laterally and helping to maximize propulsion.
Combining Flexibility with Technique Adjustments
-
Addressing Flexibility:
While technique adjustments like a deeper hand position can help, it's still important to address your shoulder flexibility and scapular control. Improving these areas will let you achieve an ideal arm path more naturally.
For instance, a combination of improved pectoral stretching and exercises for external rotation can reduce the natural tendency for your elbows to drift outward. -
Technique Drills:
Experimenting with drills that emphasize a deeper catch (for example, underwater “sculling” or catch drills with a focus on hand path) can help you feel the difference. Coaching feedback or video analysis can be very useful in identifying whether the deeper hand position is correcting the elbow alignment without introducing new issues. -
Stroke Specifics:
Consider that each stroke might benefit differently from a deeper hand placement. For example, in backstroke recovery or breaststroke glide, the change in hand depth might modify your overall stroke dynamics. It’s beneficial to experiment in practice and see how the adjustment affects your overall stroke efficiency.
Practical Suggestions
-
Try Drills Focused on a Deeper Entry:
- Practice drills where you intentionally submerge your hand a bit more during the catch phase. Focus on keeping the elbow close to the shoulder line by consciously feeling the alignment underwater.
-
Review With a Coach:
- A coach can help assess whether the deeper hand position aligns with proper stroke mechanics across different strokes in the medley. They may also give you feedback on whether further flexibility work is needed.
-
Integrate Flexibility and Stability Work:
- Continue working on flexibility (e.g., pectoral stretches and rotator cuff mobility) and stability (e.g., scapular stabilizer exercises), as these will support any improvements your technique changes bring.
Conclusion
A deeper hand position may indeed help guide your elbow into a more appropriate path during your stroke, potentially counteracting some of the effects of limited shoulder flexibility. However, it’s not an either/or situation; refining your hand position can work best when combined with ongoing work to enhance shoulder flexibility and stability. Experimenting with the hand depth in your training sessions, while continuing your flexibility and strength routines, will help you find the most efficient balance and reduce unwanted drag.
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.