Can you rephrase the following email in a polite, clear, and convincing manner: Thank…
- User
Can you rephrase the following email in a polite, clear, and convincing manner:
Thank you for your feedback and for considering our submission JRSSB-Jan-2025-0054. We appreciate the opportunity to submit our work to JRSS-B.
We are writing to express some concerns regarding the review process for our manuscript. While we fully acknowledge that our submission is not without areas for improvement, we were disappointed by the overall quality and depth of the reviews received, particularly given the high standards typically associated with JRSS-B.
In our case, we received two reviews: one generally positive and one more critical with two concerns. The Associate Editor (AE)’s decision appears to have relied primarily on the two claims from the critical review and added a third point that, unfortunately, seems to contradict even the reviewer's own assessment. We believe all three key criticisms are based on misreadings of the manuscript, which we detail below.
We recognise that editorial decisions are challenging and based on many factors, but we are particularly concerned because the core critiques—on which the rejection seems to rest—are factually incorrect and addressed clearly in the manuscript. For completeness, we have attached a brief document highlighting these points with references to specific sections of the paper.
Novelty of the Algorithmic FrameworkThe algorithmic framework is not novel, as the only improvement is on the score function. The proof techniques are the same. – Reviewer and AE
This statement overlooks the central contribution of the paper: a generalised framework that interpolates between previously published methods, offering a flexible spectrum of trade-offs between validity and statistical variability. This extension leads to new theoretical results (e.g., Table 5), based on different proof techniques than those used in our ICML 2023 work. These points are outlined in the abstract, introduction, and Sections 4–5.
Value of Impossibility ResultsImpossibility results are useless because the intuition existed. – AE
While some intuition existed for the first impossibility result, a formal proof—particularly one showing a square-root rate—was lacking in the literature. Moreover, the subsequent results in Section 2.2 (acknowledged as solid and interesting by the reviewer) go well beyond prior intuitions and show limitations that were previously unproven. The AE’s critique also misrepresents our handling of MCAR vs. MAR: our results precisely show that going beyond MCAR is provably infeasible under certain conditions. These points are outlined in the introduction and Section 2.
Omission of Contributions in Sections 3 and 5The methodological part of this paper is exclusively MCAR. – Reviewer and AE These sections, including comprehensive experiments under MCAR, MAR, MNAR, and other realistic settings, were not acknowledged in the AE report. The reviewer stated that “the methodological part of this paper is exclusively MCAR,” which is demonstrably incorrect (this is outlined before Section 5, e.g. in the introduction and Table 2). We raise these points not to challenge editorial discretion, but because we believe the decision was based on demonstrable inaccuracies. This is particularly disheartening given the care we put into this work—and especially for me as corresponding author, having recently invested substantial time in reviewing another JRSS-B submission (JRSSB-Oct-2024-0581), where I ensured thoughtful and thorough feedback despite early reservations about fit.
We hope this note and the attached document are helpful in clarifying our concerns. We would be grateful if the editorial team could reconsider the decision, or at least acknowledge the issues raised in the process.
Thank you again for your time and for your ongoing work in maintaining the high standards of JRSS-B.
Best regards,
- Assistant
Certainly! Here's a polite, clear, and convincing rephrasing of your email:
Subject: Request for Reconsideration of Manuscript JRSSB-Jan-2025-0054
Dear [Editor’s Name],
Thank you for your valuable feedback and for considering our submission JRSSB-Jan-2025-0054. We are grateful for the opportunity to present our work to JRSS-B.
We are writing to respectfully raise concerns about the review process for our manuscript. While we acknowledge that our submission has room for improvement, we were somewhat disappointed by the quality and depth of the reviews, particularly given the high standards typically associated with JRSS-B.
We received two reviews: one generally positive and one more critical, with two specific concerns. The Associate Editor's (AE) decision appears to have primarily relied on the critical review's claims, adding a third point that seems to contradict the reviewer's own assessment. We believe these three key criticisms are based on misreadings of our manuscript, as detailed below.
We understand that editorial decisions are complex and multifaceted. However, we are particularly concerned because the core critiques—on which the rejection seems to rest—are factually incorrect and are clearly addressed in the manuscript. For your convenience, we have attached a document that highlights these points with references to specific sections of the paper.
1. Novelty of the Algorithmic Framework
"The algorithmic framework is not novel, as the only improvement is on the score function. The proof techniques are the same." – Reviewer and AE
This statement overlooks the central contribution of our paper: a generalised framework that interpolates between previously published methods, offering a flexible spectrum of trade-offs between validity and statistical variability. This extension leads to new theoretical results (e.g., Table 5), based on different proof techniques than those used in our ICML 2023 work. These points are outlined in the abstract, introduction, and Sections 4–5.
2. Value of Impossibility Results
"Impossibility results are useless because the intuition existed." – AE
While some intuition existed for the first impossibility result, a formal proof—particularly one showing a square-root rate—was lacking in the literature. Moreover, the subsequent results in Section 2.2 (acknowledged as solid and interesting by the reviewer) go beyond prior intuitions and show limitations that were previously unproven. The AE’s critique also misrepresents our handling of MCAR vs. MAR: our results precisely show that going beyond MCAR is provably infeasible under certain conditions. These points are outlined in the introduction and Section 2.
3. Omission of Contributions in Sections 3 and 5
"The methodological part of this paper is exclusively MCAR." – Reviewer and AE
These sections, including comprehensive experiments under MCAR, MAR, MNAR, and other realistic settings, were not acknowledged in the AE report. The reviewer's statement that “the methodological part of this paper is exclusively MCAR” is incorrect, as outlined before Section 5, e.g., in the introduction and Table 2.
We raise these points to highlight that the decision may have been based on demonstrable inaccuracies. This is particularly disheartening given the substantial effort we invested in this work, and especially for me as the corresponding author, having recently reviewed another JRSS-B submission (JRSSB-Oct-2024-0581), where I ensured thoughtful and thorough feedback despite early reservations about fit.
We hope this note and the attached document clarify our concerns. We would be grateful if the editorial team could reconsider the decision or at least acknowledge the issues raised in the process.
Thank you again for your time and for your ongoing commitment to maintaining the high standards of JRSS-B.
Best regards,
[Your Full Name]
On behalf of all co-authors
This version aims to be polite, clear, and convincing, while maintaining the integrity and detail of your original concerns.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.