For an ESL english session with ~40 asian adults, I need to come up with some questions…
- User
For an ESL english session with ~40 asian adults, I need to come up with some questions that can be discussed around a table with 6 people each. The session will loosely be based on 'The Great Banquet' from Luke 14.
What I have so far is:
FaithTalk Session Would you rather go to a dinner with friends, or finish off some work you wanted to do for a while? If you could have dinner with any three famous people, living or dead, who would they be, and what would you want to talk about? What was the best party or event you've ever been to and why? Is it easy for you to say ‘no’ to someone? What makes that easier or harder? Have you ever planned an event, but some guests said they couldn’t come? - Optional, probably too much How would you feel, and what might you do next? ⏳Transition: Give every student a small sheet of paper and let them write down the most ridiculous excuse they can think of not to go to a dinner invitation. Then read them to each other on the table, each table selects the best/funniest, then we read the ‘winners’ from each table to the whole class (and maybe write them down/explain/…) BibleTalk Session Why do you think some people decided not to attend the banquet? Do you think they had good reasons? Why or why not? How do you think the master felt each time he extended the invitation? What would you have felt and done? How would you feel being invited to a free but limited event with a star or important personality? How ‘far’ would you go to attend that event? Were there opportunities in your life that you did or didn’t take? Is there one right now or one that you're waiting for?I need to change these questions slightly:
- I need a TOPIC for the FaithTalk session
- The first two questions in the 'FaithTalk' session should be more fun icebreaker questions, while the next two can go a bit deeper.
- I need a TOPIC for the BibleTalk session
- Assistant
Your session plan is already well-structured, and with a few tweaks, it can be even more engaging for your group of ESL adult learners. Below, I’ll provide suggestions for refining your questions, adding a clear topic for each session, and ensuring the icebreaker questions are fun and accessible while still tying into the theme of "The Great Banquet" from Luke 14. I’ll also ensure the questions are culturally sensitive and appropriate for a diverse group of Asian adults.
Revised Plan with Topics
FaithTalk Session
Topic: "Invitations and Choices"
This topic ties into the theme of "The Great Banquet" by focusing on the idea of being invited to events, making choices about attending, and prioritizing what matters. It’s broad enough to allow for fun icebreakers while also setting the stage for deeper discussions.Revised Questions:
-
Icebreaker Question 1 (Fun):
Original: "Would you rather go to a dinner with friends, or finish off some work you wanted to do for a while?"
Revised: "If you were invited to a huge party with free food and music, but you had to finish a big project by tomorrow, which would you choose and why?"- Why the change? This version is more engaging because it paints a vivid picture (a "huge party" vs. a "big project") and encourages learners to share their reasoning, which helps with language practice. It also ties into the banquet theme by emphasizing invitations and choices.
-
Icebreaker Question 2 (Fun):
Original: "If you could have dinner with any three famous people, living or dead, who would they be, and what would you want to talk about?"
Revised: "Imagine you are invited to a magical dinner party where you can sit next to any three famous people (from history, movies, music, etc.). Who would you pick, and what fun question would you ask each of them?"- Why the change? This version adds the word "magical" to make it more whimsical and fun, and it shifts "what would you talk about" to "what fun question would you ask," which encourages creativity and lowers the pressure for complex answers. It’s still an icebreaker but ties into the idea of being invited to a special event.
-
Deeper Question 1:
Original: "What was the best party or event you've ever been to and why?"
Revised: "What was the most special invitation you ever received (for a party, event, or something else), and what made it so memorable?"- Why the change? This version broadens the scope beyond just parties to include other types of invitations (e.g., weddings, ceremonies, or even job offers), making it more inclusive for learners who may not have party-focused experiences. It also ties into the theme of invitations and prepares for the BibleTalk session.
-
Deeper Question 2:
Original: "Is it easy for you to say ‘no’ to someone? What makes that easier or harder?"
Revised: "When someone invites you to an event, is it easy or hard for you to say ‘no’? What helps you decide whether to say ‘yes’ or ‘no’?"- Why the change? This version is more specific to the context of invitations, which connects directly to the banquet story. It also adds the second part ("What helps you decide…") to encourage more detailed responses and help learners practice expressing reasoning.
-
Optional Activity (Keep as is):
Original: "Give every student a small sheet of paper and let them write down the most ridiculous excuse they can think of not to go to a dinner invitation. Then read them to each other on the table, each table selects the best/funniest, then we read the ‘winners’ from each table to the whole class (and maybe write them down/explain/…)"- Why keep it? This is a fantastic, lighthearted activity that ties directly into the excuses given in "The Great Banquet." It’s perfect for encouraging creativity, laughter, and language practice. Consider adding a quick follow-up question after the activity, such as, "Do you think people in real life use excuses like these? Why or why not?" to transition smoothly into the BibleTalk session.
BibleTalk Session
Topic: "Responding to God’s Invitation"
This topic directly reflects the core message of "The Great Banquet" parable, where the master invites people to a great feast, but many refuse, and others are invited in their place. It encourages learners to think about how they respond to opportunities, especially spiritual ones, while keeping the discussion accessible for ESL learners.Revised Questions:
-
Original: "Why do you think some people decided not to attend the banquet? Do you think they had good reasons? Why or why not?"
Revised: "In the story, some people said ‘no’ to the banquet because of work, family, or other reasons. Why do you think they made those choices? Do you think their reasons were good or bad? Why?"- Why the change? This version adds specific examples ("work, family, or other reasons") to help learners recall the story and make it easier to discuss. It also uses "good or bad" instead of "good reasons" to simplify the language while still encouraging critical thinking.
-
Original: "How do you think the master felt each time he extended the invitation? What would you have felt and done?"
Revised: "How do you think the master felt when people said ‘no’ to his invitation? If you were the master, how would you feel, and what would you do next?"- Why the change? This version simplifies the phrasing by focusing on the rejection ("when people said ‘no’") rather than the more abstract "each time he extended the invitation." It also splits the question into two clear parts (feelings and actions) to make it easier for learners to respond.
-
Original: "How would you feel being invited to a free but limited event with a star or important personality? How ‘far’ would you go to attend that event?"
Revised: "Imagine you are invited to a free dinner with a very famous person, but there are only a few seats. How would you feel? What would you do to make sure you could go?"- Why the change? This version adds the word "imagine" to make it more engaging and uses "very famous person" instead of "star or important personality" for simplicity. It also rephrases "how far would you go" to "what would you do to make sure you could go," which is more concrete and easier for ESL learners to answer.
-
Original: "Were there opportunities in your life that you did or didn’t take? Is there one right now or one that you're waiting for?"
Revised: "Think about a time when you were invited to do something special (like a job, a trip, or an event) but said ‘no.’ Why did you say ‘no’? Is there an invitation or opportunity you are thinking about now?"- Why the change? This version ties the question more closely to the theme of invitations by using examples ("a job, a trip, or an event") and focuses on the act of saying "no" to parallel the parable. It also simplifies the second part by asking about current invitations or opportunities, making it more personal and relevant.
Final Plan Summary
FaithTalk Session
Topic: "Invitations and Choices"
- If you were invited to a huge party with free food and music, but you had to finish a big project by tomorrow, which would you choose and why?
- Imagine you are invited to a magical dinner party where you can sit next to any three famous people (from history, movies, music, etc.). Who would you pick, and what fun question would you ask each of them?
- What was the most special invitation you ever received (for a party, event, or something else), and what made it so memorable?
- When someone invites you to an event, is it easy or hard for you to say ‘no’? What helps you decide whether to say ‘yes’ or ‘no’?
- ⏳Activity: Give every student a small sheet of paper and let them write down the most ridiculous excuse they can think of not to go to a dinner invitation. Then read them to each other on the table, each table selects the best/funniest, then we read the ‘winners’ from each table to the whole class (and maybe write them down/explain/…). Optional follow-up question: "Do you think people in real life use excuses like these? Why or why not?"
BibleTalk Session
Topic: "Responding to God’s Invitation"
- In the story, some people said ‘no’ to the banquet because of work, family, or other reasons. Why do you think they made those choices? Do you think their reasons were good or bad? Why?
- How do you think the master felt when people said ‘no’ to his invitation? If you were the master, how would you feel, and what would you do next?
- Imagine you are invited to a free dinner with a very famous person, but there are only a few seats. How would you feel? What would you do to make sure you could go?
- Think about a time when you were invited to do something special (like a job, a trip, or an event) but said ‘no.’ Why did you say ‘no’? Is there an invitation or opportunity you are thinking about now?
Additional Tips for Facilitation
- Cultural Sensitivity: Be mindful that some Asian cultures may place a high value on work, family obligations, or social harmony, which could influence how learners respond to questions about saying "no" or prioritizing invitations. Encourage open sharing without judgment, and affirm that all perspectives are valid.
- Language Support: Provide key vocabulary on a handout or whiteboard (e.g., "invitation," "excuse," "banquet," "opportunity") to help learners express themselves. You could also model a sample answer for each question to give them a starting point.
- Group Dynamics: With tables of 6, ensure everyone gets a chance to speak by assigning roles (e.g., a timekeeper, a note-taker, or a spokesperson) or by going around the table for each question.
- Timing: Allocate about 30 minutes for the FaithTalk session (including the activity) and 30 minutes for the BibleTalk session to keep the session engaging and on track.
This revised plan should create a fun, interactive, and meaningful session for your learners while staying true to the theme of "The Great Banquet." Good luck!
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.