Suppose that I push a merry-go-round. Does conservation of angular momentum imply that I…
- User
Suppose that I push a merry-go-round. Does conservation of angular momentum imply that I create a small change in the angular momentum of the Earth?
- Assistant
Good question! Let's work through it carefully.
When you push on a merry-go-round, you exert a torque on it, causing it to spin up (increase its angular momentum). According to the principle of conservation of angular momentum, the total angular momentum of an isolated system remains constant unless acted on by an external torque.
Now, if we consider the system to be just the merry-go-round, then your push is an external torque, and angular momentum is not conserved for the merry-go-round alone.
But if we expand the system to include you and the Earth (and the merry-go-round), then your push is an internal force within the system. In that case, the total angular momentum of the system (Earth + you + merry-go-round) should be conserved, assuming no external torques (like from the Moon or Sun) are significant over the short time of the push.
When you push the merry-go-round, you exert a torque on it, but by Newton's third law, the merry-go-round exerts an equal and opposite torque back on you. Since you are standing on the Earth, and friction holds you to the Earth, this torque is transmitted to the Earth. Thus, the Earth experiences a tiny torque in the opposite direction.
As a result, the Earth’s angular momentum changes slightly in the opposite direction to the merry-go-round’s change in angular momentum, so that the total angular momentum remains constant.
In short:
✅ Yes, conservation of angular momentum implies that when you push the merry-go-round, you create a tiny change in the angular momentum of the Earth, in the opposite direction to the merry-go-round’s spin.However, because the Earth is so massive compared to the merry-go-round, the change in the Earth's rotation is utterly negligible — far too small to measure.
Would you like me to also show a rough calculation of how tiny the effect is? (It’s fun!)
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.