Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o4-mini-2025-04-16· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

I used GNU parallel in the command below. How would I use it with ncrcat to combine…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with o3-2025-04-16’s answer.
  1. User

    I used GNU parallel in the command below. How would I use it with ncrcat to combine files without screwing up the ordering of the files?

    find . -maxdepth 1 -type f -name "*_seed_*.eam.h2.000[34567]-*.nc" |
      parallel -j 64 extract_precip {}
    
  2. Assistant

    Here are a couple of patterns you can follow to make sure your NetCDF files get concatenated in the correct lexical order.


    1) Don’t parallelize the ncrcat step—just sort & cat in one go

    Once all your extract_precip jobs have finished you’ll have a directory full of
    *_seed_*.eam.h2.000[34567]-*.nc files. Now just do:

    # 1) build a sorted list of files
    files=$(find . -maxdepth 1 \
                -type f \
                -name "*_seed_*.eam.h2.000[34567]-*.nc" \
              | sort)
    
    # 2) feed them all to one ncrcat invocation
    ncrcat -O $files combined_precip.nc
    

    Or even more compact with xargs:

    find . -maxdepth 1 \
      -type f \
      -name "*_seed_*.eam.h2.000[34567]-*.nc" \
    | sort \
    | xargs ncrcat -O - combined_precip.nc
    

    This guarantees that ncrcat sees the files in sorted order (0003, 0004, 0005, …).


    2) If you really want to parallelize chunks of ncrcat

    You can split your sorted file‐list into chunks (say 10 files per chunk), run several ncrcats in parallel, then stitch those together at the end. Example:

    # 1) make a sorted list
    find . -maxdepth 1 \
      -type f \
      -name "*_seed_*.eam.h2.000[34567]-*.nc" \
    | sort \
    > filelist.txt
    
    # 2) run ncrcat on chunks of 10 files each
    parallel -a filelist.txt -N10 -j4 --keep-order \
             ncrcat -O {=1..} chunk_{#}.nc
    
    # 3) merge all the chunks into your final file
    ncrcat -O chunk_*.nc combined_precip.nc
    

    Here:

    • -a filelist.txt reads the sorted file‐list
    • -N10 takes 10 filenames per job
    • -j4 runs 4 ncrcat jobs at once
    • --keep-order hands chunks to jobs in the same order they appear in filelist.txt
    • finally you merge the chunk_*.nc in lexical order again

    3) A purely GNU‐parallel one-liner (sort + single ncrcat)

    If you’re addicted to one-liners, you can also:

    find . -maxdepth 1 -type f -name "*_seed_*.eam.h2.000[34567]-*.nc" \
      | sort \
      | parallel --keep-order echo {} \
      | xargs ncrcat -O - combined_precip.nc
    

    Here we use parallel --keep-order as a glorified cat (you could just do cat, but sometimes you want GNU parallel’s throttling). The output list is then fed into ncrcat.


    TL;DR

    • Sort your filenames before feeding them to ncrcat.
    • Don’t try to parallelize a single ncrcat call: it won’t split the I/O for you.
    • If you must parallel-chunk, use --keep-order so that your sub-concatenations respect the global order, then re-concatenate the chunks.

    Hope that helps! 😊

  3. User

    Ok you are right. I shouldn't use parallel with ncrcat, from what I can tell. The issue with using ncrcat on its own is that there are many, many files.

  4. Assistant

    If you have so many files that a single

    ncrcat -O file1 file2 file3 … fileN final.nc
    

    will blow out your argument‐list or just grind too long, the trick is to “divide and conquer”:

    1. Create a sorted list of all your inputs.
    2. Split that list into manageable chunks (say 500–1000 files per chunk).
    3. Run ncrcat on each chunk (in serial or even in parallel).
    4. Finally, ncrcat the resulting chunk-files together—only a handful of them now.

    Here’s a minimal working example:

    # 1) Make a sorted list of all your .nc files
    find . -maxdepth 1 -type f \
         -name "*_seed_*.eam.h2.000[34567]-*.nc" \
      | sort \
      > all_precip.txt
    
    # 2) Split into chunks of, say, 500 filenames each
    #    This produces files named chunk_aa, chunk_ab, chunk_ac, …
    split -d -l 500 all_precip.txt chunk_
    
    # 3) ncrcat each chunk into its own intermediate file
    i=0
    for chunk in chunk_*; do
      printf -v idx "%03d" "$i"        # zero-pad your index
      ncrcat -O $(<"$chunk") chunk_${idx}.nc
      ((i++))
    done
    
    # You’ll now have chunk_000.nc, chunk_001.nc, … chunk_00M.nc
    
    # 4) Finally, stitch all those chunk_*.nc together (they’re few enough now!)
    ncrcat -O chunk_*.nc combined_precip.nc
    
    # 5) (Optional) clean up
    rm chunk_*.nc chunk_*
    

    — if you want to run step 3 in parallel (e.g. on 8 cores), you can:

    ls chunk_* | parallel -j8 '
      idx={#}; printf -v i "%03d" "$idx";
      ncrcat -O $(<{}) chunk_${i}.nc
    '
    

    That way you never pass more than 500 filenames at once to any single ncrcat call, but you still end up with one perfectly ordered, fully concatenated combined_precip.nc at the end. 🚀

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.