Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
grok-3-mini-beta· xAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Provide a list of all available Indian stock brokers and their intraday charges in a…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.5-pro’s answer.
  1. User

    Provide a list of all available Indian stock brokers and their intraday charges in a table from zero fee to higher

  2. Assistant

    I appreciate your query regarding Indian stock brokers and their intraday charges. However, I must clarify a few important points before providing the information:

    • Not an exhaustive list: There are over 100 SEBI-registered stock brokers in India, and listing "all available" ones is impractical due to the vast number and constant changes in their offerings. I'll focus on the major and popular brokers based on publicly available data as of my last knowledge update (mid-2023). Fees can vary based on factors like trading volume, account type, and specific plans, so I recommend verifying the latest details directly from the brokers' websites or through official sources.

    • Intraday charges breakdown: Intraday trading charges typically include:

      • Brokerage fee: The core fee charged by the broker (this is what I'll focus on).
      • Other costs: Exchange transaction fees (e.g., NSE/BSE charges), GST (18% on brokerage and other fees), SEBI turnover fee, stamp duty, and DP charges. These can add up, but I'll highlight the brokerage fee as the primary variable.
    • Zero to higher ordering: I've sorted the brokers based on their base intraday brokerage fees, starting from those offering zero or near-zero fees. Note that "zero brokerage" often applies to specific segments (e.g., equity intraday) and may have conditions like minimum trade values or exclusions for certain instruments.

    • Data source and disclaimer: This information is based on general knowledge from reliable sources like broker websites, NSE, and SEBI guidelines. Fees are subject to change, and this is for informational purposes only. Always consult the broker for the most accurate and up-to-date rates.

    Below is a table summarizing the intraday brokerage fees for selected major Indian stock brokers, sorted from lowest to higher brokerage fees. I've included only the brokerage component for simplicity, but actual costs will be higher due to other charges.

    Table: Indian Stock Brokers and Their Intraday Brokerage Fees

    Rank (by fee)Broker NameIntraday Brokerage Fee (Equity)Key Notes
    1Shoonya (by Finvasia)₹0 per orderTruly zero brokerage for intraday trades in equity, F&O, and currency. No hidden charges, but other statutory fees apply.
    2Groww₹0 per orderZero brokerage for intraday equity trades; applies to cash and F&O segments. Other charges like exchange fees still apply.
    3Alice Blue₹0 per orderZero brokerage for intraday equity and F&O; may have conditions for high-volume traders. Popular for low-cost trading.
    4SAMCO Securities₹0 per orderZero brokerage for intraday equity; offers free trading in some segments, but additional tools may incur costs.
    5SAS Online₹0 per orderZero brokerage for intraday trades; aimed at high-frequency traders with no account opening fees.
    6Fyers₹0 for equity intraday (up to certain limits)Free for equity intraday; may charge for other segments. They have a flat-fee model for advanced users.
    7Zerodha₹20 per executed order or 0.03% of trade value (whichever is lower)One of the most popular; effective fee is often around ₹20 for most trades. No delivery charges for equity.
    8Upstox₹20 per executed order or 0.05% of trade value (whichever is lower)Similar to Zerodha; offers priority plans with additional features for a fee.
    95paisa₹20 per orderFlat fee structure; beginner-friendly with additional charges for premium services.
    10Angel One₹20 per order or 0.25% (whichever is lower)Flat fee for most users; they offer various plans based on trading volume.
    11IIFL (India Infoline)₹20 per order or 0.03%Competitive for intraday; may vary by account type.
    12Motilal Oswal0.025% of trade value (minimum ₹30)Slightly higher than flat-fee brokers; includes research tools.
    13HDFC Securities0.05% of trade value (minimum ₹25)Percentage-based; can be higher for larger trades.
    14ICICI Direct0.03% of trade value (minimum ₹29 per order)One of the traditional brokers; fees are higher compared to discount brokers.
    15Kotak Securities0.049% of trade value (minimum ₹21)Full-service broker with additional advisory; intraday fees are on the higher side.
    16Sharekhan0.03% of trade value (minimum ₹20)Offers various plans; can be customized but generally higher for intraday.
    17SBI Securities0.05% of trade value (minimum ₹30)Government-backed; fees are straightforward but not the lowest.
    18Axis Direct0.05% of trade value (minimum ₹20)Bank-linked broker; includes banking integration but higher costs.

    Additional Notes:

    • How fees are calculated: For percentage-based fees, it's applied to the trade value (e.g., 0.03% of ₹1,00,000 = ₹30). Flat fees like ₹20 per order are straightforward but may not apply to all segments (e.g., F&O might have different rates).

    • Other charges to consider:

      • Exchange fees: NSE charges about 0.00325% for equity intraday; BSE is lower.
      • GST: 18% on brokerage and transaction fees.
      • SEBI fee: ₹10 per crore of turnover.
      • Stamp duty: Varies by state (e.g., 0.01% in Maharashtra).
      • Total intraday cost for a ₹1,00,000 trade could range from ₹50–200+ depending on the broker.
    • Why not all brokers?: Brokers like Paytm Money, Bajaj Broking, or smaller ones like Geojit or Karvy aren't included here for brevity, but they often have fees similar to the ones listed (e.g., Paytm Money offers zero brokerage for intraday).

    • Recommendations:

      • For zero-fee trading, consider Shoonya, Groww, or Alice Blue if you're a beginner or high-volume trader.
      • Always check for hidden costs, platform usability, and customer support.
      • This data is approximate and based on standard plans; brokers may offer promotional zero-fee periods or customized plans.

    If you need details on a specific broker or want me to expand on any part, let me know! Remember, investing involves risks, and it's wise to consult a financial advisor.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.