So I (23M) moved across the country in January to start grad school. I grew up with a…
- User
So I (23M) moved across the country in January to start grad school. I grew up with a single dad and four brothers—all athletes—so our house was very casual. Think shirts optional, lounging in boxers, locker room energy 24/7.
My roommate (also 23M) and I met through a school Facebook group. We seemed like a good fit—morning people, into fitness, both social, etc. When we moved in, I didn’t think twice about hanging out in my boxers that first night while we played video games. He didn’t say anything then, but the next day he asked if I could be more covered up since he wasn’t used to that kind of living setup.
Fair enough—I adjusted. No more boxers-only lounging, and I’ve kept it respectful when we’re both around. But over the months, he’s started adding more and more “rules” about what I can wear at home, and it’s starting to get to me. Some examples:
He has earlier classes, so sometimes I wait in the living room in my underwear while he finishes up in the bathroom. I’m there maybe 30 seconds, and I don’t see the big deal. I run shirtless in 2 inch running shorts. Afterward, I usually eat quickly before showering. He told me it’s not about sweat—he just doesn’t want to “see all that.” Again, I don’t think it’s excessive. I sometimes work out in my underwear in the living room when he’s not home. If he unexpectedly gets back early, I don’t stop mid-set, which he’s complained about. Occasionally I’ll pop out of my room briefly to grab something while not fully dressed. He says it “breaks the rule,” but I’m in and out in under a minute. Once, I came out quickly to grab food not realizing he had two friends over. I ended up talking to them for a bit, still not fully dressed. No one else seemed to care, but he was really upset after.When we hang out together in the living room, I always wear at least shorts and an undershirt. I’ve made compromises. But recently he told me I need to “respect the rules” more. That’s when I finally told him I’ve tried, but this isn’t a dictatorship. I’m not being reckless—I just don’t think I need to be fully dressed every second at home.
Now he’s venting to our mutual friends and making it seem like I’m wildly inappropriate. I feel like I’ve made a real effort to meet him halfway, and I’m not going to live under a dress code in my own apartment.
Girlfriend told me to clarify that the underwear I've been wearing is a mixture of boxers/boxer briefs/the occasional tighty whities.
Do you think I'm the asshole in this situation?
- Assistant
This is a classic case of mismatched expectations and communication styles in a shared living situation, and it’s great that you’re reflecting on it and seeking outside perspectives. Let’s break this down to determine if you’re the asshole (or not) and how to move forward.
The Context
You grew up in a very casual, male-dominated household where boundaries around clothing were minimal. That’s shaped your comfort level and norms. Your roommate, on the other hand, clearly has a different background and comfort zone, likely one where more formal boundaries around clothing were the norm. Neither of you is inherently “wrong” for your preferences, but living together means finding a middle ground that works for both of you.
Analyzing the Situation
-
Initial Compromise
You started off on the right foot by adjusting your behavior when he first expressed discomfort with you lounging in boxers. That shows you’re willing to be considerate, which is important in a shared living space. Kudos for that. -
The “Rules” Escalation
Over time, your roommate has added more specific requests (or “rules,” as you put it) about what you can wear and when. Some of these—like not wanting you to linger in the living room in your underwear while he’s getting ready—seem reasonable, especially if he feels awkward or caught off guard. Others—like complaining about you finishing a workout in your underwear when he comes home early—feel more like overreach, especially if you’re not parading around for an extended period. -
Your Perspective
You feel like you’ve already compromised by dressing more modestly when you’re hanging out together, and you don’t want to feel policed in your own home. That’s valid—home is supposed to be a place where you can relax and be yourself, within reason. You also seem to view brief moments of being underdressed (e.g., grabbing something quickly) as no big deal, especially since you’re not lingering or being intentionally disrespectful. -
His Perspective
Your roommate likely feels uncomfortable with what he perceives as a lack of boundaries, especially if he’s not used to seeing people in their underwear outside of very specific contexts (like a locker room). The incident with his friends might have been particularly embarrassing for him, as it could have felt like a reflection on him as a host. He may also feel like his repeated requests are being ignored, which could explain why he’s escalating the issue by venting to mutual friends. -
The Underwear Clarification
Your girlfriend’s note about the type of underwear is relevant. Boxers and boxer briefs are generally seen as more “casual” and less revealing, while tighty whities can feel more intimate or exposing to some people. If you’re wearing tighty whities in shared spaces, that might amplify your roommate’s discomfort, even if it’s not your intention.
Are You the Asshole?
I don’t think you’re the asshole, but I also don’t think your roommate is entirely in the wrong either. This is more of a “no assholes here” (NAH) situation, with some caveats:
-
Where You’re Reasonable: You’ve made efforts to compromise, like wearing shorts and an undershirt when hanging out together. You’re also correct that home should be a place where you can relax, and expecting you to be fully dressed every second (especially for brief moments like grabbing something from the kitchen) feels excessive.
-
Where You Could Improve: While you don’t intend to make your roommate uncomfortable, some of your actions—like waiting in the living room in your underwear or continuing a workout in your underwear when he comes home—might feel disrespectful to him, especially after he’s expressed discomfort. The incident with his friends is also a misstep; even if they didn’t care, it’s understandable that he felt embarrassed, as it’s his social space too.
-
Where He Could Improve: Your roommate needs to recognize that shared living requires compromise from both sides, not just you. His escalating “rules” and venting to mutual friends (instead of addressing the issue directly with you) are not constructive. He also needs to be realistic—brief moments of you being underdressed (e.g., grabbing something quickly) are part of shared living, especially with only two people in the apartment.
How to Move Forward
To resolve this, you’ll need to have an open, honest conversation and set clear, mutually agreed-upon boundaries. Here’s how to approach it:
-
Initiate a Calm Conversation
Choose a neutral time (not right after an incident) to sit down and talk. Start by acknowledging his perspective and your efforts to compromise, then express your own feelings. For example:
“Hey, I want to talk about how we’re navigating shared spaces. I know you’ve felt uncomfortable with me being underdressed at times, and I’ve tried to adjust by wearing shorts and a shirt when we’re hanging out together. But I also feel like the expectations are getting stricter, and I want to make sure we’re both comfortable in our home. Can we figure out a middle ground?” -
Set Clear Boundaries
Propose specific guidelines that balance both of your needs. For example:- You’ll wear at least shorts (and maybe a shirt) in shared spaces, even for brief moments, unless it’s an emergency.
- If you’re working out in the living room in your underwear, you’ll stop and cover up if he comes home early (or consider working out in your room if he’s likely to return).
- He agrees to be more flexible about brief, incidental moments (e.g., grabbing something quickly) and to communicate directly with you instead of venting to others.
- Agree that if guests are over, you’ll both make an extra effort to be fully dressed in shared spaces.
-
Address the Social Fallout
If he’s been venting to mutual friends, that’s unfair to you, as it paints you in a negative light without context. During your conversation, you could say:
“I’ve heard that you’ve been talking to our friends about this, and I feel like that’s making it seem like I’m being unreasonable. I’d really appreciate it if we can keep this between us and work it out directly.”
If the social damage is already done, you might need to clarify your side to mutual friends (calmly and without blame) to set the record straight. -
Consider Practical Solutions
If certain habits (like waiting in the living room in your underwear) are a sticking point, think about small changes that could help. For example, could you wait in your room until he’s done in the bathroom? Or keep a pair of shorts by the door to slip on quickly? -
Evaluate Long-Term Compatibility
If, after setting boundaries, you still feel policed or he still feels uncomfortable, you might not be compatible as roommates. That’s okay—sometimes people just have different living styles. If that’s the case, consider finding a new living arrangement when your lease is up.
Final Thoughts
You’re not the asshole for wanting to be comfortable in your own home, but you could be more mindful of how your actions affect your roommate, especially given his expressed discomfort. He, in turn, needs to be more flexible and communicate directly rather than escalating the issue socially. With clear communication and compromise, you can likely find a balance that works for both of you. If not, it might be a sign to part ways as roommates—but not as enemies.
Good luck, and remember: shared living is a learning curve, especially in your early 20s. You’ve got this!
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.