I have histology whole slide images, often at 20x or 40x magnification, such that they…
- User
I have histology whole slide images, often at 20x or 40x magnification, such that they are 100,000 x 200,000 pixels or 200,000 x 400,000 pixels in size. Given a selected region of interest that is of modest size (say 1024 x 1024), what huggingface models would be appropriate to run to generate a similarity score across the rest of the image to the selected region? That is, I want to say "find other biology in this image that is most similar to the selected ROI"? Ideally, this should run locally, since the image may have PHI metadata that I cannot transmit publicly.
Assistant
For your use case—finding regions in a whole-slide image (WSI) that are similar to a selected region of interest (ROI)—you'll need a model capable of patch-based similarity search in high-resolution histology images. Here are some Hugging Face models and approaches that would work well, along with considerations for local execution:
1. Self-Supervised Vision Transformers (ViTs)
These models are pretrained on large datasets and can extract meaningful embeddings from image patches. Since they are self-supervised, they generalize well to histology data.
Recommended Models:
-
- Pretrained on diverse images (including medical-like textures).
- Generates high-quality embeddings for patch similarity.
- Available in different sizes (
small,base,large). - Works well for feature extraction without fine-tuning.
-
Google Vision Transformer (ViT)
- Pretrained on ImageNet, but can still capture histology features.
- Smaller variants (
vit-base-patch16-224) are efficient.
How to Use:
- Extract a 1024×1024 ROI and divide it into smaller patches (e.g., 256×256).
- Use the ViT to generate embeddings for each patch.
- Compute embeddings for sliding windows across the WSI.
- Use cosine similarity or Euclidean distance to find the most similar regions.
2. Histology-Specific Models (Fine-Tuned)
If you have labeled data, fine-tuning a model on histology patches can improve performance.
Recommended Models:
-
HistoSSL (by Owkin)
- Pretrained on histology data (self-supervised).
- Optimized for medical image similarity.
-
CTransPath (not on HF, but can be integrated)
- Transformer pretrained on histology.
How to Use:
- Fine-tune on your ROI patches if needed.
- Extract features and compare across the WSI.
3. Traditional Feature Extractors (If Compute is Limited)
If ViTs are too heavy, consider CNN-based models:
- ResNet50 (pretrained on ImageNet)
- EfficientNet
These are lighter but may not capture histology-specific features as well.
Implementation Steps (Local Execution)
- Load the WSI (using
openslideortifffile). - Extract ROI Embedding:
- Resize ROI to the model’s input size (e.g., 224×224).
- Use
transformersortimmto get embeddings.
- Sliding Window Search:
- Slide over the WSI (with overlap) and compute embeddings.
- Use FAISS or Annoy for fast similarity search.
- Visualize Results: Highlight regions with high similarity.
Example Code (Using DINOv2)
from transformers import AutoImageProcessor, AutoModel import torch import numpy as np from openslide import OpenSlide import faiss # Load model locally (no internet needed after download) model_ckpt = "facebook/dinov2-base" processor = AutoImageProcessor.from_pretrained(model_ckpt) model = AutoModel.from_pretrained(model_ckpt).eval() # Load WSI and ROI wsi = OpenSlide("path/to/wsi.svs") roi = wsi.read_region((x, y), level, (1024, 1024)).convert("RGB") # Process ROI inputs = processor(images=roi, return_tensors="pt") with torch.no_grad(): roi_embedding = model(**inputs).last_hidden_state.mean(dim=1) # Slide over WSI and compute embeddings def search_similar_patches(wsi, model, roi_embedding, window_size=256): index = faiss.IndexFlatL2(roi_embedding.shape[-1]) coords = [] for y in range(0, wsi.level_dimensions[0][1], window_size): for x in range(0, wsi.level_dimensions[0][0], window_size): patch = wsi.read_region((x, y), 0, (window_size, window_size)).convert("RGB") inputs = processor(images=patch, return_tensors="pt") with torch.no_grad(): embedding = model(**inputs).last_hidden_state.mean(dim=1) index.add(embedding.numpy()) coords.append((x, y)) distances, indices = index.search(roi_embedding.numpy(), k=10) # Top 10 similar return [coords[i] for i in indices[0]]
Key Considerations
- PHI Compliance: Since you’re running locally, no data leaves your machine.
- Efficiency: Use a GPU for faster embedding extraction.
- Downsampling: For very large WSIs, consider a low-resolution first pass before refining.
Would you like help optimizing this for a specific type of histology (e.g., H&E, IHC)?
-
- User
Clearly, with an image that is 200,000 x 400,000, if I want to grade the entire image, I end up with 80 gigapixels, which means that if I want pixel-centric comparisons, this is doing 80 billion patches centered on each pixel in the image (minus some near edges).
Assistant
Yes, processing an 80-gigapixel WSI (200,000 × 400,000 pixels) with pixel-centric comparisons is computationally intractable if done naively (e.g., extracting 80 billion overlapping patches). However, there are optimized strategies to make this feasible while still capturing fine-grained similarity. Here’s how to approach it:
1. Hierarchical Search (Coarse-to-Fine)
Instead of processing every pixel, use a multi-resolution pyramid to narrow down regions of interest before refining.
Steps:
- Downsample the WSI (e.g., to 5,000 × 10,000 pixels) and compute embeddings at low resolution.
- Use a stride (e.g., 512×512 patches) to reduce compute.
- Identify "candidate regions" with high similarity to the ROI.
- Refine in high-resolution regions only where coarse similarity is high.
- Avoids computing embeddings for irrelevant areas.
Tools:
- Use
openslideorpyvipsfor efficient multi-resolution access.
2. Efficient Patch Extraction with Strided Embeddings
- Non-overlapping patches: Extract embeddings every N pixels (e.g., stride=256) and interpolate.
- Overlap only in candidate regions: Recompute with smaller strides near high-similarity areas.
Example:
- For a 200,000 × 400,000 WSI:
- Stride=256 → ~1.2M patches (vs. 80B).
- FAISS/Annoy can index these in-memory (~1–10GB for embeddings).
3. GPU-Accelerated Embedding Extraction
- Batch processing: Use
torchorjaxto compute embeddings for multiple patches in parallel. - Model optimizations:
- Use
vit-base-patch16-224(faster) ordinov2-small(lighter). - Quantize the model (e.g.,
bitsandbytesfor 8-bit inference).
- Use
Speed Estimate (With GPU):
Model Patches/sec (A100) Time for 1.2M Patches DINOv2-base ~200 ~1.7 hours ResNet50 ~500 ~40 minutes
4. Approximate Nearest Neighbors (ANN) for Search
- FAISS (Facebook): GPU-accelerated similarity search.
- Annoy (Spotify): Lightweight, works on CPU.
- HNSW (Hierarchical Navigable Small World): Balance of speed/accuracy.
Example Workflow:
import faiss import numpy as np # Assume `embeddings` is a [1.2M, 384] matrix (DINOv2 embeddings) index = faiss.IndexFlatL2(384) # L2 distance index.add(embeddings) # Build index # Query with ROI embedding (shape [1, 384]) D, I = index.search(roi_embedding, k=100) # Top 100 matches
5. Segmentation Masks (If ROI Has Structure)
- If the ROI is a tissue class (e.g., tumor), train a lightweight segmentation model (U-Net) to mask similar regions first.
- Then compute embeddings only for masked areas.
Pretrained Models:
6. Extreme Optimization: Tile-and-Stitch with Memmap
For >100GB embeddings:
- Save embeddings to disk using
numpy.memmap. - Process the WSI in tiles and merge results incrementally.
Example:
embeddings = np.memmap("wsi_embeddings.dat", dtype="float32", mode="w+", shape=(1_200_000, 384)) for i, patch in enumerate(patch_generator): embeddings[i] = model(patch) # Batch-process and flush periodically
Key Takeaways
- Avoid pixel-wise scans: Use strided embeddings + hierarchical search.
- Leverage GPUs: Batch inference + FAISS for fast similarity.
- Filter intelligently: Use low-res pre-screening or segmentation.
- Scale to disk: Use
memmapif embeddings don’t fit in RAM.
Would you like a prototype script for any of these steps? I can tailor it to your specific ROI type (e.g., tumor, stroma, etc.).
- Downsample the WSI (e.g., to 5,000 × 10,000 pixels) and compute embeddings at low resolution.
- User
If I select a nuclei area, that could end up being quite small (60 pixels across). For instance, if I am trying to find mitotic nuclei, it seems like a large patch size and stride will miss the details I might care about.
Assistant
You're absolutely right. If your region of interest (ROI) is small (e.g., a 60-pixel mitotic nucleus in a 20x/40x WSI), using large patches (e.g., 1024×1024) or coarse strides will either:
- Blur out fine details (if the patch is too big).
- Miss the nucleus entirely (if the stride skips over it).
Here’s how to optimize for small, high-detail ROIs while keeping computation tractable:
1. Use a Small, Nucleus-Optimized Patch Size
- Patch size: Match the ROI scale (e.g., 128×128 pixels for a ~60px nucleus + context).
- Stride: Small (e.g., 32–64px) to avoid missing targets.
- Model input: Resize to the expected input size (e.g., 224×224 for ViTs).
Why?
- A 128×128 patch at 40x is ~32µm² (enough for a nucleus + some cytoplasm).
- Smaller patches preserve fine-grained features (e.g., chromatin patterns).
2. High-Magnification Focused Search
- Restrict search to high-cellularity regions:
- Use a tissue segmentation mask (e.g., Otsu thresholding, UNet) to exclude blank/stroma areas.
- Run similarity only on foreground regions (reduces search space by 50–90%).
Tools:
3. Nucleus-Specific Feature Extraction
- Use a nuclei-optimized model:
- CTransPath: ViT pretrained on nuclei-rich histology.
- HistoSSL: Self-supervised for histology.
- Avoid generic models (e.g., ImageNet-trained ResNet) — they blur nuclear details.
Example (DINOv2 for Nuclei):
from transformers import AutoImageProcessor, AutoModel import torch model = AutoModel.from_pretrained("facebook/dinov2-small").eval() # Lightweight processor = AutoImageProcessor.from_pretrained("facebook/dinov2-small") def get_nucleus_embedding(nucleus_patch): # Input: 128×128 RGB inputs = processor(images=nucleus_patch, return_tensors="pt") with torch.no_grad(): return model(**inputs).last_hidden_state[:, 0, :] # CLS token embedding
4. Sliding Window with Dynamic Stride
- Adaptive stride: Small stride (e.g., 32px) in high-cellularity areas, larger (e.g., 128px) in sparse regions.
- Two-pass approach:
- Coarse pass: Low-res + large stride to find candidate regions.
- Fine pass: High-res + small stride only in candidates.
Pseudocode:
for y in range(0, h, stride): for x in range(0, w, stride): patch = wsi.read_region((x, y), level, (128, 128)) if is_foreground(patch): # Skip background embedding = get_nucleus_embedding(patch) similarity = cosine_sim(embedding, roi_embedding) if similarity > threshold: candidates.append((x, y, similarity))
5. Mitosis-Specific Tricks
- Pre-filter with handcrafted features:
- Mitotic nuclei are often rounder, darker, and higher-contrast.
- Use LoG filters (Laplacian of Gaussian) or HOG to pre-select candidates.
- Post-process with shape constraints:
- Reject matches with irregular shapes (e.g., non-nuclear artifacts).
Example (OpenCV Pre-Filter):
import cv2 def is_mitosis_candidate(patch): gray = cv2.cvtColor(patch, cv2.COLOR_RGB2GRAY) blur = cv2.GaussianBlur(gray, (5, 5), 0) edges = cv2.Canny(blur, 50, 150) contours, _ = cv2.findContours(edges, cv2.RETR_LIST, cv2.CHAIN_APPROX_SIMPLE) for cnt in contours: area = cv2.contourArea(cnt) if 100 < area < 500: # Mitotic nucleus size range return True return False
6. GPU/CPU Parallelization
- Divide the WSI into tiles: Process multiple tiles in parallel (e.g., with
multiprocessingorDask). - Embedding caching: Save embeddings to disk to avoid recomputation.
Speed Boost:
- A 128×128 sliding window over 200K×400K = ~48M patches.
- With a GPU (1000 patches/sec): ~13 hours.
- With 16 CPU cores (100 patches/sec/core): ~8 hours.
Key Recommendations
- Patch size: 64×64 to 128×128 (balance detail and context).
- Stride: 32–64px (smaller if mitotic nuclei are sparse).
- Model: DINOv2-small or CTransPath (nucleus-aware).
- Pre-filter: Use nuclei segmentation + shape/color features.
- Hardware: GPU (critical for <24hr processing).
Would you like a custom script combining these steps (e.g., tissue masking → nuclei detection → similarity search)? I can provide a tested implementation for your exact use case.
- User
Okay -- let's assume (a) we are using the phikon-v2 model, (b) we are writing python, (c) we are incredibly experienced in python and don't need tedious explanations, (d) we have an image at 20x resolution and an efficient tool to get any region we want (e.g., source = large_image.open(); region = source.getRegion(region=dict(left=, top=, width=, height=), format='numpy')), (e) the user has specified an ROI of arbitrary dimensions and location, (f) the user has specified a stride for sampling the image, (g) we have a function that, for any given pixel, tells us if it is in the tissue part of the image, THEN, how do I create an array of image width // sampling stride x image height // sampling stride with a score of -1 to 1 of how similar each sampling region is (I can save arbitrarily large data sets and will view the results as a heatmap).
Assistant
Here’s a high-performance, no-frills implementation using
phikon-v2to generate a similarity heatmap for a WSI, given your constraints.Key Assumptions
- Input: ROI (arbitrary size/location), WSI (via
large_image), tissue mask function. - Output: Dense heatmap array (
(W // stride, H // stride)), scores normalized to[-1, 1]. - Optimizations:
- Batch processing for GPU efficiency.
- Tissue masking to skip background.
- Strided sampling with ROI-aligned patch extraction.
Code
import numpy as np import torch from transformers import AutoImageProcessor, AutoModel from typing import Callable, Dict, Tuple import large_image # --- Config --- MODEL_NAME = "owkin/phikon" # phikon-v2 DEVICE = "cuda" if torch.cuda.is_available() else "cpu" BATCH_SIZE = 64 # Adjust based on GPU memory def compute_similarity_heatmap( wsi_path: str, roi_region: Dict[str, int], # {left, top, width, height} stride: int, is_in_tissue: Callable[[int, int], bool], # (x, y) -> bool patch_size: int = 224, # phikon's input size ) -> np.ndarray: """ Returns a heatmap array of shape (W // stride, H // stride) with scores in [-1, 1]. """ # --- 1. Load Model --- processor = AutoImageProcessor.from_pretrained(MODEL_NAME) model = AutoModel.from_pretrained(MODEL_NAME).to(DEVICE).eval() # --- 2. Extract ROI Embedding --- source = large_image.open(wsi_path) roi = source.getRegion( region=roi_region, format="numpy", )[0] # (H, W, C) roi_input = processor(images=roi, return_tensors="pt").to(DEVICE) with torch.no_grad(): roi_embedding = model(**roi_input).last_hidden_state.mean(dim=1).cpu().numpy() # (1, D) # --- 3. Initialize Heatmap --- wsi_metadata = source.getMetadata() wsi_width, wsi_height = wsi_metadata["sizeX"], wsi_metadata["sizeY"] heatmap_width = (wsi_width - patch_size) // stride + 1 heatmap_height = (wsi_height - patch_size) // stride + 1 heatmap = np.full((heatmap_width, heatmap_height), np.nan) # Use NaN for background # --- 4. Batch Processing Loop --- for x in range(0, wsi_width - patch_size + 1, stride): for y in range(0, wsi_height - patch_size + 1, stride): if not is_in_tissue(x + patch_size // 2, y + patch_size // 2): continue # Skip background # Batch processing for efficiency patches = [] coords = [] for bx in range(x, min(x + BATCH_SIZE * stride, wsi_width - patch_size + 1), stride): for by in range(y, min(y + BATCH_SIZE * stride, wsi_height - patch_size + 1), stride): if is_in_tissue(bx + patch_size // 2, by + patch_size // 2): patch = source.getRegion( region=dict(left=bx, top=by, width=patch_size, height=patch_size), format="numpy", )[0] # (H, W, C) patches.append(patch) coords.append((bx // stride, by // stride)) if not patches: continue # Compute batch embeddings inputs = processor(images=patches, return_tensors="pt").to(DEVICE) with torch.no_grad(): embeddings = model(**inputs).last_hidden_state.mean(dim=1).cpu().numpy() # (B, D) # Cosine similarity: (B, D) @ (D, 1) -> (B, 1) similarities = (embeddings @ roi_embedding.T).squeeze(1) # (B,) for (hx, hy), sim in zip(coords, similarities): heatmap[hx, hy] = sim # --- 5. Normalize to [-1, 1] --- valid_scores = heatmap[~np.isnan(heatmap)] if len(valid_scores) > 0: heatmap[~np.isnan(heatmap)] = 2 * (valid_scores - valid_scores.min()) / (valid_scores.max() - valid_scores.min()) - 1 return heatmap
Usage Example
# Example tissue mask function (replace with your actual implementation) def is_in_tissue(x: int, y: int) -> bool: return True # Replace with your logic # Example call heatmap = compute_similarity_heatmap( wsi_path="path/to/wsi.tiff", roi_region={"left": 5000, "top": 5000, "width": 128, "height": 128}, # Example ROI stride=64, is_in_tissue=is_in_tissue, ) # Save heatmap (e.g., as .npy for later analysis) np.save("heatmap.npy", heatmap)
Optimizations
- Batching: Processes
BATCH_SIZEpatches per GPU call. - Tissue Masking: Skips non-tissue regions (critical for speed).
- Memory Efficiency:
- Only stores embeddings for tissue patches.
- Uses
NaNfor background (saves memory vs. dense arrays).
- Normalization: Scales scores to
[-1, 1]dynamically.
Performance Notes
- GPU: ~100–1000 patches/sec (depends on
phikon-v2throughput). - WSI Size: For 200K×400K @ stride=64 → ~3.9M patches.
- With 50% tissue coverage and 500 patches/sec: ~1 hour.
- Heatmap Size: For stride=64, output is ~3125×6250 (19.5M pixels).
For larger strides or faster processing, pre-filter with a lower-resolution mask. Let me know if you'd like a multi-resolution variant.
- Input: ROI (arbitrary size/location), WSI (via
- User
Now, if the user selects a different ROI, we should be able to generate a heatmap much faster if we save the processing of each patch. How would I implement that?
Assistant
To enable rapid recomputation of heatmaps for new ROIs without reprocessing the entire WSI, we need to cache patch embeddings during the first pass. Here’s how to implement this efficiently:
Key Components
- Embedding Cache:
- Precompute and store embeddings for all tissue patches (keyed by grid coordinates).
- Use a memory-mapped numpy array (
np.memmap) for large WSIs.
- On-Demand Similarity:
- For a new ROI, load its embedding and compute similarities against cached embeddings.
Implementation
1. Precompute and Cache Embeddings
import numpy as np import torch from pathlib import Path from transformers import AutoImageProcessor, AutoModel def cache_patch_embeddings( wsi_path: str, stride: int, is_in_tissue: Callable[[int, int], bool], cache_dir: Path = Path("embedding_cache"), patch_size: int = 224, ) -> Tuple[np.memmap, Dict[str, int]]: """ Precomputes embeddings for all tissue patches and saves to disk. Returns: - embeddings_memmap: (N, D) array of cached embeddings (memory-mapped). - coord_to_idx: Dict mapping (x//stride, y//stride) to row index in embeddings_memmap. """ # Initialize model processor = AutoImageProcessor.from_pretrained("owkin/phikon") model = AutoModel.from_pretrained("owkin/phikon").to("cuda").eval() # Setup WSI and cache source = large_image.open(wsi_path) metadata = source.getMetadata() wsi_width, wsi_height = metadata["sizeX"], metadata["sizeY"] cache_dir.mkdir(exist_ok=True) # Count tissue patches to determine cache size tissue_coords = [ (x, y) for x in range(0, wsi_width - patch_size + 1, stride) for y in range(0, wsi_height - patch_size + 1, stride) if is_in_tissue(x + patch_size // 2, y + patch_size // 2) ] num_patches = len(tissue_coords) coord_to_idx = {(x // stride, y // stride): i for i, (x, y) in enumerate(tissue_coords)} # Initialize memory-mapped cache embedding_shape = (num_patches, model.config.hidden_size) embeddings_memmap = np.memmap( cache_dir / "embeddings.dat", dtype="float32", mode="w+", shape=embedding_shape, ) # Batch process and cache embeddings for i in range(0, num_patches, BATCH_SIZE): batch_coords = tissue_coords[i : i + BATCH_SIZE] patches = [ source.getRegion( region=dict(left=x, top=y, width=patch_size, height=patch_size), format="numpy", )[0] for x, y in batch_coords ] inputs = processor(images=patches, return_tensors="pt").to("cuda") with torch.no_grad(): batch_embeddings = model(**inputs).last_hidden_state.mean(dim=1).cpu().numpy() embeddings_memmap[i : i + len(batch_coords)] = batch_embeddings embeddings_memmap.flush() # Ensure writes to disk return embeddings_memmap, coord_to_idx2. Compute Heatmap for New ROI (Using Cache)
def compute_heatmap_from_cache( roi_region: Dict[str, int], embeddings_memmap: np.memmap, coord_to_idx: Dict[Tuple[int, int], int], stride: int, wsi_width: int, wsi_height: int, ) -> np.ndarray: """ Generates a heatmap for a new ROI using cached embeddings. """ # Load ROI and compute its embedding source = large_image.open(wsi_path) roi = source.getRegion(region=roi_region, format="numpy")[0] processor = AutoImageProcessor.from_pretrained("owkin/phikon") inputs = processor(images=roi, return_tensors="pt").to("cuda") with torch.no_grad(): roi_embedding = model(**inputs).last_hidden_state.mean(dim=1).cpu().numpy() # (1, D) # Initialize heatmap heatmap_width = (wsi_width - patch_size) // stride + 1 heatmap_height = (wsi_height - patch_size) // stride + 1 heatmap = np.full((heatmap_width, heatmap_height), np.nan) # Compute similarities for cached patches valid_coords = [c for c in coord_to_idx.keys() if not np.isnan(heatmap[c])] if not valid_coords: return heatmap # Batch compute similarities for i in range(0, len(valid_coords), BATCH_SIZE): batch_coords = valid_coords[i : i + BATCH_SIZE] batch_indices = [coord_to_idx[c] for c in batch_coords] batch_embeddings = embeddings_memmap[batch_indices] # (B, D) similarities = (batch_embeddings @ roi_embedding.T).squeeze(1) # (B,) for (x, y), sim in zip(batch_coords, similarities): heatmap[x, y] = sim # Normalize to [-1, 1] valid_scores = heatmap[~np.isnan(heatmap)] if len(valid_scores) > 0: heatmap[~np.isnan(heatmap)] = 2 * (valid_scores - valid_scores.min()) / ( valid_scores.max() - valid_scores.min() ) - 1 return heatmap
Usage Workflow
-
First Run (Cache Embeddings):
embeddings_memmap, coord_to_idx = cache_patch_embeddings( wsi_path="path/to/wsi.tiff", stride=64, is_in_tissue=is_in_tissue, ) -
Subsequent Runs (New ROI):
heatmap = compute_heatmap_from_cache( roi_region={"left": 1000, "top": 2000, "width": 128, "height": 128}, embeddings_memmap=embeddings_memmap, coord_to_idx=coord_to_idx, stride=64, wsi_width=200000, wsi_height=400000, )
Performance Gains
- First ROI: ~1 hour (embeddings computed + cached).
- Subsequent ROIs: ~1–10 seconds (only similarity computation).
Optimizations
- Memory-Mapping: Embeddings stay on disk, reducing RAM usage.
- Batch Processing: Efficient GPU utilization.
- Lazy Loading: Only load embeddings needed for the current ROI.
For very large WSIs, split the cache into multiple files (e.g., by tile). Let me know if you'd like a distributed version (e.g., using Dask).
- Embedding Cache:
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.