Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o4-mini-2025-04-16· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

why does my xgboost model is so much bigger than my catboost model ?

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.5-pro’s answer.
  1. User

    why does my xgboost model is so much bigger than my catboost model ?

  2. Assistant

    There are two main reasons why an XGBoost tree-ensemble often ends up much larger on disk than a CatBoost one:

    1. Difference in tree architecture & serialization
      • XGBoost uses “plain” decision trees, and by default stores every node’s metadata (feature name/id, split threshold as a 32-bit float, left/right child pointers, missing-value direction, node statistics, …).
      • CatBoost uses oblivious (symmetric) trees: every level of the tree splits on the same feature–threshold pair. In practice that means you only need to store – per tree –
      – A small array of (feature, threshold) pairs (one per depth level)
      – A flat array of leaf values (size 2^depth)
      Because of the regular structure, CatBoost packs that much more compactly.

    2. Quantization & internal representation
      • CatBoost aggressively bins numeric features (e.g. into 256 bins) and can use 8- or 16-bit types for thresholds & leaf weights under the hood.
      • XGBoost by default keeps everything as 32-bit floats or even 64-bit in some cases, and its “plain” booster binary format can’t leverage the same degree of bit-packing.

    As a result, a 500-tree CatBoost model at depth 6 often fits in a few megabytes, whereas the same configuration in XGBoost can easily blow past 20–50 MB.

    —
    How to shrink your XGBoost model?
    • Use the histogram (“hist”) or GPU (“gpu_hist”) tree_method with a smaller max_bin (e.g. 64 or 128)
    • Quantize/freeze leaf weights or export to JSON and gzip it:

    bst.save_model('model.json')  
    import gzip  
    with gzip.open('model.json.gz','wt') as f:  
        f.write(open('model.json','rt').read())  
    

    • Strip training statistics (with_stats=False) when calling save_model
    • If you pipeline with sklearn, try joblib with compression:

    import joblib  
    joblib.dump(bst, 'xgb.pkl', compress=3)
    

    All of those can cut your on-disk footprint significantly.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.