Skip to content
The Chat Archive
o3-2025-04-16· OpenAI LMArena Human Preference 140K

"On April 9, 2025, we were informed by the U.S. government that a license is required…

  1. User

    "On April 9, 2025, we were informed by the U.S. government that a license is required for exports of our H20 products into the China market. As a result of these new requirements, we incurred a 4.5billionchargeinthefirstquarteroffiscal2026associatedwithH20excessinventoryandpurchaseobligationsasthedemandforH20diminished.The4.5 billion charge in the first quarter of fiscal 2026 associated with H20 excess inventory and purchase obligations as the demand for H20 diminished. The 4.5 billion charge was less than what we initially anticipated as we were able to re-use certain materials. Sales of our H20 products were 4.6billionforthefirstquarteroffiscal2026priortothenewexportlicensingrequirements.Wewereunabletoshipanadditional4.6 billion for the first quarter of fiscal 2026 prior to the new export licensing requirements. We were unable to ship an additional 2.5 billion of H20 revenue in the first quarter."

    The previous paragraph is from the CFO commentary released by Nvidia for Q1 2026. Can you notice any discrepancies in the numbers?

  2. Assistant

    Yes—when you lay the three numbers next to one another, they don’t really square:

    1. Revenue that DID get booked
      Sold H20 revenue in Q1-FY26: $4.6 B

    2. Revenue that COULD NOT be shipped because of the license
      “Un-shippable” H20 revenue: $2.5 B

      → Total revenue that was either sold or waiting to be sold = 4.6B+4.6 B + 2.5 B = $7.1 B

    3. Inventory / purchase-obligation charge taken because of the rule change
      Inventory-related charge: $4.5 B

    Why that looks off:

    • Cost vs. revenue mismatch
    – Nvidia’s datacenter gross margin is typically ~70 %.
    – 2.5Bofun−shippedrevenuethereforerepresentsonlyabout2.5 B of un-shipped revenue therefore represents only about 0.75 B of cost (30 % of 2.5B).–Evenifeverysingleunsoldunitbecameworthlessovernight,thatexplains<2.5 B). – Even if every single unsold unit became worthless overnight, that explains < 1 B of the $4.5 B charge.

    • Even if the 4.5Balsocoverspurchaseobligationsforfuturequarters,thequarter’s4.5 B also covers purchase obligations for future quarters, the quarter’s 7.1 B “available” revenue implies Nvidia would have had to pre-build or pre-commit to > 11Bofcost(roughly11 B of cost (roughly 15-20 B of sales value) to justify a $4.5 B write-off—far more than the quarter’s total potential sales.

    • Put differently, the inventory write-off is almost the same size as the entire quarter’s recorded H20 revenue ( 4.5Bvs.4.5 B vs. 4.6 B ), which is unusually high given typical margins and the limited amount of product that actually became un-shippable.

    Bottom line: the 4.5Bchargeappearsdisproportionatelylargerelativeto(a)the4.5 B charge appears disproportionately large relative to (a) the 2.5 B of revenue that couldn’t be shipped and (b) normal cost-of-goods percentages. Either the revenue or charge figures (or what they purport to cover) is misstated or missing additional context.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.