Hmm, okay. Which of these arguments are non-option? save [-p --patch] [-S --staged] [-k…
- User
Hmm, okay. Which of these arguments are non-option? `save [-p|--patch] [-S|--staged] [-k|--[no-]keep-index] [-u|--include-untracked] [-a|--all] [-q|--quiet] []
This option is deprecated in favour of git stash push. It differs from "stash push" in that it cannot take pathspec. Instead, all non-option arguments are concatenated to form the stash message.`
Assistant
Based on the syntax provided:
save [-p|--patch] [-S|--staged] [-k|--[no-]keep-index] [-u|--include-untracked] [-a|--all] [-q|--quiet] [<message>]The only non-option argument is:
<message>
Explanation:
- All the other items (
-p,--patch,-S,--staged, etc.) are clearly marked as options because they start with a single hyphen (-) or a double hyphen (--). <message>does not start with a hyphen and is placed at the end, which is the typical position for positional, non-option arguments.- The description explicitly confirms this: "all non-option arguments are concatenated to form the stash message." This means any words you provide after the
savecommand and its options, that don't begin with a hyphen, will be considered part of the message.
Example:
git save -p "My temporary changes for feature X"Here,"My temporary changes for feature X"is the non-option argument (the message).- User
But since is the only non-option argument then that's all that is being concatenated, the message itself?
Assistant
You've hit on a good point that can be a bit confusing due to the phrasing!
You're correct that, conceptually, the purpose of the non-option arguments in
git saveis to form the message.The phrase "all non-option arguments are concatenated to form the stash message" is necessary because a single logical "message" can actually be composed of multiple separate command-line arguments if it's not quoted.
Let's break it down:
-
[<message>]as shown in the syntax implies a single conceptual unit (the message string). -
"all non-option arguments" refers to the individual strings passed on the command line that don't start with
-or--.
Example:
If you run:
git save My first stash messageMyis a non-option argument.firstis a non-option argument.stashis a non-option argument.messageis a non-option argument.
In this case,
git savewill takeMy,first,stash, andmessage, concatenate them (typically with spaces in between), and the resulting stash message will be:"My first stash message".If you run:
git save "My single quoted stash message""My single quoted stash message"is one single non-option argument (because the quotes make it a single token for the shell).
In this case,
git savewill take that single argument and, technically, "concatenate" it (which simply means using it as is, as there's nothing else to concatenate it with).So, while
<message>is the logical unit that the non-option arguments form, the "concatenation" rule explains how multiple discrete non-option arguments provided on the command line are combined to create that single logical message string.-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.