Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o3-2025-04-16· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

In the United States what is the breakdown of what wage bracket pays for taxes % wise

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Metallama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct’s answer.
  1. User

    In the United States what is the breakdown of what wage bracket pays for taxes % wise

  2. Assistant

    Below is a quick “cheat-sheet” that shows (A) how much of their own income different wage brackets actually pay in federal taxes (“effective tax rate”), and (B) how much of the total federal income-tax pot each bracket chips in (“share of taxes paid”). All numbers are the most recent that the government has published (2020-2021 data) and are rounded for readability.


    A. Effective Federal Tax Rates
    (average % of household income that ends up going to ALL federal taxes: income, payroll, corporate, excise)

    Income group (household, 2021 CBO)Cash income range*Avg. federal tax rate
    Bottom 20 %<$31 k–0.3 % (net refund)
    2nd 20 %31k–31 k – 61 k8.3 %
    Middle 20 %61k–61 k – 98 k13.0 %
    4th 20 %98k–98 k – 173 k17.7 %
    Top 20 %>$173 k25.5 %
    … of which Top 1 %>$1.0 M31.6 %

    *“Cash income” is CBO’s broad measure that includes wages, business income, capital income, retirement benefits, etc.

    Key take-away: on average a middle-class household paid ~13 ¢ of every $1 to the federal government in 2021; a top-1 % household paid about 32 ¢.


    B. Share of Federal Income-Tax Liability
    (2020 IRS Statistics of Income, latest available)

    Adjusted-Gross-Income (AGI) slice% of all U.S. AGI% of all federal income-tax paidAverage individual income-tax rate
    Top 1 % (>$548 k)22.2 %42.3 %26.0 %
    Top 5 % (>$219 k)38.1 %62.7 %23.5 %
    Top 10 % (>$152 k)49.5 %73.7 %20.0 %
    Top 25 % (>$85 k)70.9 %88.1 %17.1 %
    Top 50 % (>$43 k)88.0 %97.7 %14.1 %
    Bottom 50 % (<$43 k)12.0 %2.3 %3.3 %

    Key take-away: the top half of earners supply ~98 % of federal income-tax revenue; the bottom half supply ~2 %, largely because many low-income filers receive refundable credits that wipe out (or exceed) their tax liability.


    C. Current Marginal Federal Income-Tax Brackets (2024, single filer)

    Taxable incomeMarginal rate
    0–0 – 11,60010 %
    11,601–11,601 – 47,15012 %
    47,151–47,151 – 100,52522 %
    100,526–100,526 – 191,95024 %
    191,951–191,951 – 243,72532 %
    243,726–243,726 – 609,35035 %
    $609,351 +37 %

    (Remember: marginal ≠ average. Only the dollars in each slice get that slice’s rate.)


    Why the two tables don’t match perfectly

    • Table A includes payroll taxes (Social Security & Medicare), excise taxes, and the corporate-tax burden that economists assign to households.
    • Table B isolates only the individual income tax.


    Sources

    1. Congressional Budget Office, “The Distribution of Household Income, 2021” (published November 2023).
    2. IRS, Statistics of Income (SOI) Table 3.3, Individual Income Tax Shares, Tax Year 2020.
    3. Internal Revenue Code §1(j) as adjusted for inflation, Rev. Proc. 2023-34 (for 2024 brackets).

    If you need a deeper dive (e.g., state & local taxes, payroll-tax caps, or historical trends) just let me know!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.