Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o4-mini-2025-04-16· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

what are the plants known for the highest calories per acre yields? I am looking for…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-3-5-sonnet-20241022’s answer.
  1. User

    what are the plants known for the highest calories per acre yields? I am looking for records here, so assume ideal locations and soil, etc

  2. Assistant

    Here’s a quick comparison of record (or near‐record) yields for several high–calorie crops, assuming optimal soils, climate and management. Yields are given on a per-hectare and per-acre basis; calories are “edible” metabolisable calories.

    CropRecord Biomass YieldCalorie DensityCalories / haCalories / acreNotes
    Sugarcane275 t cane / ha~140 g sugar/kg154 M kcal62.4 M kcalCane ~14% sugar → 38.5 t sugar / ha × 4 kcal/g
    Sugar Beet180 t beet / ha~180 g sugar/kg130 M kcal52.6 M kcal18% sugar content
    Cassava80 t roots / ha1.60 kcal/g128 M kcal51.8 M kcal160 kcal per 100 g fresh root
    Oil Palm10 t oil / ha9.0 kcal/g90 M kcal36.4 M kcalPalm-fruit → crude palm oil
    Maize (corn)22 t grain / ha3.65 kcal/g80 M kcal32.5 M kcal365 kcal per 100 g dry kernel
    Potato80 t tubers / ha0.77 kcal/g62 M kcal25.1 M kcal77 kcal per 100 g fresh tuber
    Sugar Palm*——~175 M kcal⁺~71 M kcal⁺Date palm sugar yields in oasis cultures
    Sweet Potato56 t roots / ha0.86 kcal/g48 M kcal19.4 M kcal86 kcal per 100 g
    Rice12 t grain / ha3.60 kcal/g43 M kcal17.5 M kcalRefined grain; hulls removed

    ⁺ very site‐specific; sugar-palm sap tapped & concentrated

    Key takeaways

    • Sugarcane (tropics) leads in raw calories/acre thanks to massive sugar yields.
    • Sugar beet (temperate) and cassava come in a close second—even in temperate zones, sugar beet can match tropical roots.
    • If you include pure oils as “calories,” oil palm rivals most starch crops because fats pack ~9 kcal/g.

    Let me know if you’d like more detail on any of these (e.g. starch vs. sugar vs. oil breakdown), or if you want data on more niche or specialty high-yield species!

  3. User

    I once heard nice things about bananas, how does that stack up?

  4. Assistant

    Here’s how bananas stack up under truly “best‐in‐class” commercial yields (ideal climate, fertilization, pest control, etc.):

    CropRecord Fresh YieldCalorie DensityCalories / haCalories / acreNotes
    Banana60 – 80 t fruit / ha~0.89 kcal/g (89 kcal/100 g)53 – 71 M kcal21 – 29 M kcalYields assume ~3–4 harvests/year and intensive management

    Comparison to some starch–root & sugar crops (from earlier data):

    • Sugarcane: 154 M kcal/ha (62 M kcal/acre)
    • Sugar beet: 130 M kcal/ha (53 M kcal/acre)
    • Cassava: 128 M kcal/ha (52 M kcal/acre)
    • Maize grain: 80 M kcal/ha (32 M kcal/acre)
    • Potato: 62 M kcal/ha (25 M kcal/acre)

    Key takeaways:

    • Bananas (21–29 M kcal/acre) fall behind the big sugar‐ and starch‐producers, slotting in around potatoes or sweet potatoes.
    • Their year-round harvest window and minimal post-harvest losses are big pluses, but per-acre calorie output is roughly one-third that of sugarcane.

    Let me know if you’d like more on fruit‐crop yields or other high–calorie alternatives!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.