Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-pro-preview-05-06· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Please add humanintheloop after checkweather in the following code:import operator from…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.5-pro’s answer.
  1. User

    Please add human_in_the_loop after check_weather in the following code:import operator from typing import TypedDict from typing_extensions import Annotated from langgraph.graph import StateGraph, END

    Define our state class State(TypedDict): messages: Annotated[list, operator.add] location: str weather: str

    Create our graph workflow = StateGraph(State)

    Define our nodes def greet(state): print("state:",state) return {"messages": [("ai", "Hello! I'm your weather assistant. Where are you located?")]}

    def get_location(state): print("state:",state) return {"location": state["messages"][-1][1]}

    def check_weather(state): print("state:",state)

    In a real app, we'd call a weather API here

    weather = "sunny" if "new york" in state["location"].lower() else "rainy" return {"weather": weather}

    def report_weather(state): print("state:",state) return {"messages": [ ("ai", f"The weather in {state['location']} is {state['weather']}. Can I help you with anything else?")]}

    Add nodes to our graph workflow.add_node("greet", greet) workflow.add_node("get_location", get_location) workflow.add_node("check_weather", check_weather) workflow.add_node("report_weather", report_weather)

    Connect our nodes workflow.set_entry_point("greet") workflow.add_edge("greet", "get_location") workflow.add_edge("get_location", "check_weather") workflow.add_edge("check_weather", "report_weather") workflow.add_edge("report_weather", END)

    Compile our graph app = workflow.compile()

    Run our app inputs = {"messages": [("human", "Hi, I'd like to check the weather.")]} for output in app.stream(inputs): for key, value in output.items(): print(f"{key}: {value}")

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, to add a human-in-the-loop (HITL) step after check_weather, we'll use LangGraph's built-in interruption mechanism. This requires a checkpointer. We'll use a simple in-memory checkpointer for this example.

    Here's how we'll modify the code:

    1. Import MemorySaver: This is needed for the interruption to work, as the graph needs to persist its state when interrupted.
    2. Instantiate MemorySaver: Create an instance of it.
    3. Compile with interrupt_after: When compiling the graph, we'll specify interrupt_after=["check_weather"] and pass the checkpointer.
    4. Modify the execution loop:
      • The first run of app.stream() will execute nodes up to and including check_weather, then pause.
      • We'll then explicitly get the current state using app.get_state(config).
      • Present the information (e.g., the determined weather) to the "human".
      • Get input from the human.
      • Optionally, update the state based on human input using app.update_state(config, {"key_to_update": new_value}).
      • Resume the graph by calling app.stream(None, config=config). The None tells LangGraph to continue from the interrupted state.

    Here's the updated code:

    import operator
    from typing import TypedDict
    from typing_extensions import Annotated
    from langgraph.graph import StateGraph, END
    from langgraph.checkpoint.memory import MemorySaver # Import MemorySaver
    
    # Define our state
    class State(TypedDict):
        messages: Annotated[list, operator.add]
        location: str
        weather: str
    
    # Create our graph
    workflow = StateGraph(State)
    
    # Define our nodes
    def greet(state):
        print("state (greet):", state)
        return {"messages": [("ai", "Hello! I'm your weather assistant. Where are you located?")]}
    
    def get_location(state):
        print("state (get_location):", state)
        # Assuming the last human message contains the location
        human_messages = [msg[1] for msg in state["messages"] if msg[0] == "human"]
        if human_messages:
            return {"location": human_messages[-1]} # Get the content of the last human message
        return {"location": "Unknown"} # Fallback if no human message found (shouldn't happen in this flow)
    
    
    def check_weather(state):
        print("state (check_weather):", state)
        # In a real app, we'd call a weather API here
        weather = "sunny" if "new york" in state["location"].lower() else "rainy"
        print(f"AI determined weather for {state['location']} as: {weather}")
        return {"weather": weather}
    
    # This is our new human-in-the-loop step.
    # In this specific setup with interrupt_after, this node isn't strictly necessary
    # as the interruption happens *after* check_weather and *before* report_weather.
    # The HITL logic will be in the main execution block.
    # However, if you wanted a dedicated node for HITL, you'd define it here.
    # For now, we'll handle HITL outside the graph nodes using the interrupt.
    
    def report_weather(state):
        print("state (report_weather):", state)
        return {"messages": [
            ("ai", f"The weather in {state['location']} is {state['weather']}. Can I help you with anything else?")]}
    
    # Add nodes to our graph
    workflow.add_node("greet", greet)
    workflow.add_node("get_location", get_location)
    workflow.add_node("check_weather", check_weather)
    workflow.add_node("report_weather", report_weather)
    
    # Connect our nodes
    workflow.set_entry_point("greet")
    workflow.add_edge("greet", "get_location")
    workflow.add_edge("get_location", "check_weather")
    # The graph will interrupt AFTER check_weather.
    # If resumed, it will then go to report_weather.
    workflow.add_edge("check_weather", "report_weather")
    workflow.add_edge("report_weather", END)
    
    # Compile our graph with interruption
    memory_saver = MemorySaver()
    app = workflow.compile(
        checkpointer=memory_saver,
        interrupt_after=["check_weather"] # Interrupt after check_weather node completes
    )
    
    # Run our app
    # We need a configurable thread_id for the checkpointer to work with interruptions
    thread_id = "my-weather-thread-1"
    config = {"configurable": {"thread_id": thread_id}}
    
    print("--- Starting Weather Assistant ---")
    inputs = {"messages": [("human", "Hi, I'd like to check the weather for New York.")]} # Provide location directly
    
    # Initial run - will execute up to the interruption point
    print("\n--- Running graph until interruption ---")
    for output in app.stream(inputs, config=config):
        for key, value in output.items():
            print(f"Output from node '{key}':")
            if isinstance(value, dict) and 'messages' in value and isinstance(value['messages'], list):
                for role, msg_content in value['messages']:
                     print(f"  {role}: {msg_content}")
            else:
                print(f"  {value}")
            print("---")
    
    print("\n--- Graph execution paused for Human-in-the-Loop ---")
    
    # Get the state at the point of interruption
    current_state = app.get_state(config)
    print(f"Current state before HITL: {current_state.values}")
    determined_weather = current_state.values.get("weather", "unknown")
    current_location = current_state.values.get("location", "unknown")
    
    print(f"\nThe AI has determined the weather for '{current_location}' is: {determined_weather}")
    human_approval = input("Is this correct? (yes/no/override <new_weather>): ").strip().lower()
    
    if human_approval == "yes":
        print("Proceeding with the determined weather.")
        # No state update needed, just resume
    elif human_approval.startswith("override "):
        try:
            new_weather = human_approval.split(" ", 1)[1]
            print(f"Overriding weather to: {new_weather}")
            app.update_state(config, {"weather": new_weather})
        except IndexError:
            print("Invalid override format. Proceeding with original weather.")
    else: # "no" or anything else not "yes" or "override"
        print("Human intervention indicated an issue or chose not to proceed with reporting.")
        print("Stopping the process here as per human input.")
        # To stop, we simply don't resume the stream.
        # If you wanted to route to a different part of the graph,
        # you'd need more complex conditional edges and state updates.
        # For now, we'll just end.
        import sys
        sys.exit()
    
    
    print("\n--- Resuming graph execution ---")
    # Resume the graph from the interruption point
    # Pass None as the first argument to stream to indicate resumption
    for output in app.stream(None, config=config):
        for key, value in output.items():
            print(f"Output from node '{key}':")
            if isinstance(value, dict) and 'messages' in value and isinstance(value['messages'], list):
                for role, msg_content in value['messages']:
                     print(f"  {role}: {msg_content}")
            else:
                print(f"  {value}")
            print("---")
    
    print("\n--- Weather Assistant Finished ---")
    
    # You can inspect the final state
    final_state = app.get_state(config)
    print(f"\nFinal state: {final_state.values}")
    

    Explanation of Changes:

    1. MemorySaver: Essential for interrupt_after to function. It allows LangGraph to save the state of the graph when it's paused.
    2. app = workflow.compile(checkpointer=memory_saver, interrupt_after=["check_weather"]): This tells LangGraph to pause execution right after the check_weather node has finished.
    3. config = {"configurable": {"thread_id": thread_id}}: A unique thread_id is required when using a checkpointer so that LangGraph can manage different conversation states.
    4. First app.stream(inputs, config=config): This runs the graph. It will execute greet, then get_location, then check_weather. After check_weather finishes, the stream will end because of the interrupt_after instruction.
    5. app.get_state(config): Retrieves the current state of the graph for the given thread_id. This state will include the weather determined by check_weather.
    6. Human Interaction (input(...)): This is where you prompt the human.
    7. app.update_state(config, {"weather": new_weather}): If the human provides a correction, this function updates the graph's state for the current thread_id.
    8. Second app.stream(None, config=config):
      • Passing None as the first argument tells app.stream to resume execution from the last interruption point for the given config (which contains the thread_id).
      • The graph will then proceed to the next node connected to check_weather, which is report_weather.
    9. get_location fix: I've slightly adjusted get_location to correctly extract the location from the last human message in the messages list. I also updated the initial input to provide the location directly for simplicity in this example, as the HITL is focused on weather verification.

    This setup provides a clear point for human intervention after the weather has been checked but before it's reported.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.