Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-flash· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

in firefox, i want to have three windows constantly open. work a, work b, and personal.…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Hunyuanhunyuan-turbos-20250416’s answer.
  1. User

    in firefox, i want to have three windows constantly open. work a, work b, and personal. can i do that?

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Yes, you absolutely can do this in Firefox! There are two main approaches, each with its own advantages:

    1. Using Multiple Firefox Profiles (Recommended for true separation)
    2. Using Multi-Account Containers (Good for less strict separation within one profile)

    Let's break down how to set up each.


    Method 1: Using Multiple Firefox Profiles (Recommended)

    This is the most robust way to achieve true separation. Each profile has its own:

    • Bookmarks
    • History
    • Cookies and cached data (meaning separate logins for the same site)
    • Extensions and their settings
    • Browser settings (theme, homepage, etc.)

    This is perfect for "Work A," "Work B," and "Personal" because your logins, browsing history, and even extensions for one won't interfere with the others.

    Steps:

    A. Create Your Profiles

    1. Close all open Firefox windows.
    2. Open the Firefox Profile Manager:
      • Windows: Press Win + R, type firefox.exe -P (note the capital P), and press Enter.
      • macOS: Open Terminal (Applications/Utilities/Terminal.app), type /Applications/Firefox.app/Contents/MacOS/firefox -P, and press Enter.
      • Linux: Open Terminal, type firefox -P, and press Enter.
      • (If you're having trouble, you can also access it by typing about:profiles in the address bar of a regular Firefox window, then clicking "Restart normally..." and selecting "Manage Profiles...")
    3. In the "Choose User Profile" window:
      • Click "Create Profile...".
      • Click "Next".
      • Give your new profile a descriptive name (e.g., Work A, Work B, Personal). Click "Finish".
      • Repeat this for all three profiles you want.
    4. Do NOT launch a profile yet. Just close the "Choose User Profile" window.

    B. Create Desktop Shortcuts for Each Profile

    This is the key to easily launching specific windows.

    For Windows:

    1. Right-click on your Desktop and choose New > Shortcut.
    2. In the "Type the location of the item" field, enter the path to your Firefox executable followed by -P "Profile Name".
      • Example: C:\Program Files\Mozilla Firefox\firefox.exe -P "Work A"
      • (Adjust the path if your Firefox is installed elsewhere. Keep the quotes around the profile name if it has spaces.)
    3. Click Next.
    4. Give the shortcut a name (e.g., Firefox Work A). Click Finish.
    5. Repeat these steps for your "Work B" and "Personal" profiles.
    6. Bonus Tip: You can right-click each shortcut, go to Properties > Change Icon... to pick a distinct icon for each, making them easy to differentiate. You can also right-click the shortcut and "Pin to Taskbar" for quick access.

    For macOS:

    1. Open Finder.
    2. Navigate to Applications.
    3. Find Firefox.app. Right-click (or Control-click) it and select Show Package Contents.
    4. Go into Contents > MacOS.
    5. You'll see an executable named firefox. This is what you'll use.
    6. Open Automator (from Applications/Utilities).
    7. Choose File > New and select Application.
    8. Drag the "Run Shell Script" action from the left pane to the workflow area.
    9. In the "Run Shell Script" box, change "Shell" to /bin/bash (or just leave it) and "Pass input" to as arguments.
    10. In the text area, type: /Applications/Firefox.app/Contents/MacOS/firefox -P "Work A" (again, adjust path if needed, use quotes if profile name has spaces).
    11. Click File > Save and save it as an application (e.g., Firefox Work A.app).
    12. Repeat for Work B and Personal.
    13. Bonus Tip: You can change the icon for these apps. Right-click the saved app, select Get Info, then drag an image (like a downloaded icon or a color-block image) onto the small icon in the top-left of the Get Info window.

    For Linux:

    1. Open your file manager or desktop environment's menu editor.
    2. Create a new launcher/shortcut.
    3. For the command, use: firefox -P "Work A" (adjust if your firefox executable is not in your PATH).
    4. Give it a name and an icon.
    5. Repeat for your other profiles.

    C. Configure Each Profile

    1. Launch each of your new Firefox windows using its respective shortcut.
    2. In each window:
      • Set a unique homepage/startup pages: Go to Settings > Home and set specific URLs for Work A, Work B, and Personal.
      • Install necessary extensions: Extensions are per-profile, so install what you need for each context.
      • Log in to accounts: Your logins will be separate for each window.
      • Consider a unique theme/color scheme: This makes it super easy to tell which window is which at a glance. Go to Settings > Extensions & Themes > Themes.

    To have them "constantly open":

    • Windows: Drag the shortcuts into your Startup folder. (Type shell:startup in the Run dialog to open it).
    • macOS: Go to System Settings > General > Login Items and add your created apps.
    • Linux: Add the commands to your desktop environment's startup applications settings.

    Method 2: Using Multi-Account Containers (Within one profile)

    This method keeps everything under one main Firefox profile but isolates cookies and site data within special "container" tabs. It's less isolated than profiles (history, bookmarks, extensions are shared), but it's simpler to set up and very effective for separating logins.

    Steps:

    1. Install the Extension:
      • Go to Menu (three lines) > Add-ons and themes.
      • Search for "Firefox Multi-Account Containers".
      • Click + Add to Firefox and then Add.
    2. Create Your Containers:
      • Click the Containers icon in your toolbar (it looks like four squares or a small box).
      • Select "Manage Containers".
      • Click the + New Container button.
      • Name them Work A, Work B, and Personal. You can also pick a color and an icon for each.
      • Click OK.
    3. Start Using Containers:
      • Open a new container tab: Click the Containers icon and choose "Work A", "Work B", or "Personal".
      • Open a new window in a container: This is key for your request.
        • Right-click on the Containers icon in the toolbar.
        • Hover over "New Container Tab", then hover over "Open in New Window", and select your desired container (e.g., "Work A").
        • Repeat for "Work B" and "Personal."
      • Assign websites to containers: When you're on a website (e.g., your work email), click the Containers icon in the address bar. Check "Always open in [Container Name]" to make that site always open in that specific container.
      • Pin Tabs: Once you have your desired sites open in each container window, right-click their tabs and choose "Pin Tab." They will always be there when you open that container window.
      • Set a specific startup page for each container: This isn't built-in like profiles. A workaround is to use an extension like "Containerise" or "Auto Tab Discard" which can help manage this, or simply rely on pinned tabs.

    Advantages of Containers:

    • Easier setup.
    • All your extensions are available in all windows (though some might need to be configured for container-awareness).
    • Shared history and bookmarks (could be a pro or con depending on your needs).
    • One Firefox application instance (less RAM than multiple profiles).

    Disadvantages of Containers:

    • Less strict isolation (history, extensions, and some settings are shared).
    • No separate themes or full browser settings per "window."
    • Managing startup pages for specific container windows is less straightforward than with profiles.

    Which method is best for you?

    • If you need complete isolation between your work and personal browsing (separate cookies, history, extensions, etc.), Multiple Firefox Profiles is the way to go.
    • If you primarily need to keep logins separate and don't mind sharing history, bookmarks, or extensions across your "Work A," "Work B," and "Personal" contexts, then Multi-Account Containers are a simpler and very effective solution.

    Both methods allow you to have your three distinct windows open constantly. Choose the one that best fits your workflow and privacy needs!

  3. User

    sorry, when did i say i want to create accounts or profiles? i just want to keep these windows open, have a clear way to distinguish them in windows, and actually prevent me from opening any new windows.

  4. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, my apologies! You are absolutely right. I overshot your request by assuming the need for isolation, which often goes hand-in-hand with distinct workspaces. My mistake.

    You want three separate windows of the same Firefox installation/profile, each easily identifiable, and you want to prevent any new windows from being opened. This is entirely doable, though "preventing new windows" requires a bit of a trick.

    Here's how to achieve exactly what you're asking for:


    The Solution: Distinct Windows of a Single Firefox Profile + An Extension

    This method uses your existing Firefox profile, but leverages themes and startup commands to give you three persistent, distinct windows.

    Goal Breakdown:

    1. Three Windows Constantly Open: We'll use custom shortcuts launched at startup.
    2. Clear Way to Distinguish Them: We'll apply different themes to each window.
    3. Prevent Opening Any New Windows: This requires a specific Firefox extension.

    Step-by-Step Guide:


    Part 1: Prepare Your Firefox Windows (Theming & Pinned Tabs)

    The key here is that Firefox themes are applied per-window. If you have multiple windows open, changing the theme in one window only affects that window.

    1. Start with a Fresh State: Close all Firefox windows.
    2. Open your first "Work A" window:
      • Launch Firefox normally.
      • Go to Settings > Home and set your preferred "Work A" startup pages (e.g., your work email, calendar, etc.)
      • Go to Settings > Extensions & Themes > Themes. Choose a distinct theme for this window (e.g., a dark theme, a specific color theme). Select "Enable" for it.
      • Open any tabs you want to always have in this "Work A" window. Right-click each tab and select "Pin Tab". Pinned tabs are small, persistent, and load automatically.
      • Keep this window open.
    3. Open your second "Work B" window:
      • From your first Firefox window (Work A), go to File > New Window (or Ctrl+N/Cmd+N).
      • In this new window (Work B):
        • Go to Settings > Home and set your preferred "Work B" startup pages.
        • Go to Settings > Extensions & Themes > Themes. Choose a different distinct theme for this window. Select "Enable".
        • Open and pin any "Work B" specific tabs.
      • Keep this window open.
    4. Open your third "Personal" window:
      • From either of your existing Firefox windows, go to File > New Window.
      • In this new window (Personal):
        • Go to Settings > Home and set your preferred "Personal" startup pages.
        • Go to Settings > Extensions & Themes > Themes. Choose a third distinct theme for this window. Select "Enable".
        • Open and pin any "Personal" specific tabs.
      • Keep all three windows open for now.

    Part 2: Create Custom Launchers/Shortcuts

    To make these specific windows open consistently, we'll create shortcuts that launch Firefox with a specific starting URL for each "workspace."

    Important Note: The themes and pinned tabs you set in Part 1 will persist for these windows, as they are part of your single Firefox profile. The startup URL just dictates what page opens first.

    For Windows:

    1. Right-click on your Desktop and choose New > Shortcut.
    2. In the "Type the location of the item" field, enter the path to your Firefox executable followed by -new-window and the initial URL for that window.
      • For Work A: "C:\Program Files\Mozilla Firefox\firefox.exe" -new-window https://mail.google.com/a/yourworkdomain.com (Replace with your actual work email/landing page)
      • For Work B: "C:\Program Files\Mozilla Firefox\firefox.exe" -new-window https://yourworkapp.com (Replace with your specific Work B app/page)
      • For Personal: "C:\Program Files\Mozilla Firefox\firefox.exe" -new-window https://www.reddit.com (Replace with your preferred personal start page)
      • (Adjust C:\Program Files\Mozilla Firefox\firefox.exe if your Firefox is installed elsewhere. The quotes around the path are important if it contains spaces.)
    3. Click Next.
    4. Give the shortcut a descriptive name (e.g., Firefox - Work A, Firefox - Work B, Firefox - Personal). Click Finish.
    5. Repeat these steps for all three windows.
    6. Optional: Right-click each shortcut, go to Properties > Change Icon... to pick a distinct icon for each (though the themes will do most of the work).

    For macOS:

    1. Open Automator (from Applications/Utilities).
    2. Choose File > New and select Application.
    3. Drag the "Run Shell Script" action from the left pane to the workflow area.
    4. In the "Run Shell Script" box, ensure "Shell" is /bin/bash (or just leave it) and "Pass input" is as arguments.
    5. In the text area, type:
      • For Work A: /Applications/Firefox.app/Contents/MacOS/firefox -new-window https://mail.google.com/a/yourworkdomain.com
      • For Work B: /Applications/Firefox.app/Contents/MacOS/firefox -new-window https://yourworkapp.com
      • For Personal: /Applications/Firefox.app/Contents/MacOS/firefox -new-window https://www.reddit.com
      • (Adjust /Applications/Firefox.app/Contents/MacOS/firefox if your Firefox is installed elsewhere.)
    6. Click File > Save and save it as an application (e.g., Firefox Work A.app).
    7. Repeat for your other two windows.
    8. Optional: Change the icon for these apps. Right-click the saved app, select Get Info, then drag an image onto the small icon in the top-left of the Get Info window.

    For Linux:

    1. Open your desktop environment's menu editor or create a .desktop file manually.
    2. Create a new launcher/shortcut.
    3. For the Command field, use:
      • For Work A: firefox -new-window https://mail.google.com/a/yourworkdomain.com
      • For Work B: firefox -new-window https://yourworkapp.com
      • For Personal: firefox -new-window https://www.reddit.com
      • (Adjust firefox if the executable is not in your PATH).
    4. Give it a name and an icon.
    5. Repeat for your other two windows.

    Part 3: Auto-Open at Startup

    Now, configure your operating system to launch these three shortcuts automatically when you log in.

    • Windows:
      1. Press Win + R to open the Run dialog.
      2. Type shell:startup and press Enter. This opens your Startup folder.
      3. Drag your three created Firefox shortcuts into this folder.
    • macOS:
      1. Go to System Settings (or System Preferences on older macOS).
      2. Click General (or Users & Groups).
      3. Click Login Items.
      4. Click the + button and add your three created Firefox Work A.app, Firefox Work B.app, and Firefox Personal.app applications.
    • Linux:
      1. Open your desktop environment's (GNOME, KDE, XFCE, etc.) settings for "Startup Applications," "Autostart," or "Session and Startup."
      2. Add a new entry for each of your three commands (the same commands you used for the shortcuts).

    Part 4: Prevent New Windows (The "Don't Open New Windows" Rule)

    Firefox doesn't have a built-in setting to completely disable the "New Window" function or Ctrl+N. You will need a simple extension for this.

    1. Install the "No New Window" Extension:
      • Open any of your Firefox windows.
      • Go to Menu (three lines) > Add-ons and themes.
      • Search for "No New Window".
      • Click + Add to Firefox and then Add.
      • This extension works by immediately closing any new window that Firefox attempts to open (via Ctrl+N, File > New Window, or even external links trying to force a new window). It's the most effective way to enforce "only these three windows."

    Summary and Caveats:

    • Distinct Windows: You will have three separate Firefox windows.
    • Visual Distinction: Each window will have its own unique theme, making it easy to tell them apart at a glance.
    • Content Distinction: Pinned tabs and the starting URL for each shortcut help define the purpose of each window.
    • Automatic Opening: They will open automatically when you start your computer.
    • Preventing New Windows: The "No New Window" extension will ensure no new Firefox windows can be opened, forcing everything into your existing three.
    • Single Profile: All three windows share the same Firefox profile. This means:
      • Shared History & Bookmarks: Your browsing history and bookmarks will be combined across all three windows.
      • Shared Extensions: All extensions you install will be available in all three windows (except themes, which you set per-window).
      • Shared Logins (Unless you log out): If you log into Gmail in your "Work A" window, you'll be logged into Gmail in your "Work B" or "Personal" windows if you navigate there (unless you specifically log out in one). This is a key difference from using separate profiles. If you need login separation, you would still need to use Firefox Multi-Account Containers within this single profile, but only for the specific sites you need separate logins for.

    This setup should give you exactly what you described: three constantly open, clearly distinguishable Firefox windows, with no ability to accidentally open a fourth.

  5. User

    like, how can i see the labels from the taskbar? isn't that such a simple ask?

  6. Gemini Assistant

    You are absolutely right, and I apologize for overcomplicating it previously! My mistake was assuming your underlying need was data isolation, when your specific request was about visible labels on the taskbar.

    You asked: "how can i see the labels from the taskbar? isn't that such a simple ask?"

    Yes, it sounds simple, but Windows has a default behavior where it groups instances of the same application together on the taskbar and uses the application's name (e.g., "Mozilla Firefox") as the label. To get different labels, you need to make Windows think they are different "applications" or different "tasks."

    The most reliable way to achieve distinct labels on the Windows Taskbar for multiple Firefox windows is by utilizing Firefox Profiles. While I mentioned them before for data isolation, they are also the key to tricking Windows into treating each instance as a separate application for taskbar purposes.


    Why Firefox Profiles Solve Taskbar Labels:

    When you launch Firefox using firefox.exe -P "Profile Name", Windows assigns a unique "Application User Model ID" (AppUserModelID) to that specific profile instance. This is what prevents Windows from grouping it with other Firefox windows that have different AppUserModelIDs, and allows it to show a distinct label if you customize the shortcut correctly.


    The Updated Solution: Distinct Windows, Taskbar Labels, and No New Windows

    Here's how to get exactly what you want on Windows:

    Goal:

    1. Three Distinct Windows: "Work A", "Work B", "Personal".
    2. Visible Labels on Taskbar: "Work A", "Work B", "Personal" visible.
    3. Prevent New Windows: Only these three can be open.

    Step 1: Create Your Firefox Profiles (for Taskbar Labeling & Separation)

    This is the crucial step for distinct taskbar labels. Even if you don't care about the data separation aspect initially, this is the mechanism that allows Windows to differentiate them on the taskbar.

    1. Close all open Firefox windows.
    2. Open the Firefox Profile Manager:
      • Press Win + R, type firefox.exe -P (note the capital P), and press Enter.
    3. In the "Choose User Profile" window:
      • Click "Create Profile...".
      • Click "Next".
      • Give your new profile a descriptive name (e.g., Work A, Work B, Personal). Click "Finish".
      • Repeat this for all three profiles you want.
      • Do NOT launch a profile yet. Just close the "Choose User Profile" window.

    Step 2: Create Custom Shortcuts (for Launching & Pinning with Labels)

    This is where you define the taskbar labels.

    1. Right-click on your Desktop and choose New > Shortcut.
    2. In the "Type the location of the item" field, enter the full path to your Firefox executable, followed by -P "Profile Name", and then -new-window with your desired starting URL.
      • For "Work A": "C:\Program Files\Mozilla Firefox\firefox.exe" -P "Work A" -new-window https://mail.google.com/a/yourworkdomain.com (Replace with your actual Work A starting page)
      • For "Work B": "C:\Program Files\Mozilla Firefox\firefox.exe" -P "Work B" -new-window https://yourworkapp.com (Replace with your actual Work B starting page)
      • For "Personal": "C:\Program Files\Mozilla Firefox\firefox.exe" -P "Personal" -new-window https://www.reddit.com (Replace with your preferred Personal starting page)
      • (Important: Adjust C:\Program Files\Mozilla Firefox\firefox.exe if your Firefox is installed elsewhere. Keep the quotes around the path if it contains spaces, and around the Profile Name if it has spaces.)
    3. Click Next.
    4. Give the shortcut the exact label you want to see on the taskbar (e.g., Work A, Work B, Personal). This is the key part for taskbar labels! Click Finish.
    5. Repeat these steps for all three profiles.

    Now, launch each shortcut you just created. You should see three separate Firefox windows, and when you hover over their icons on the taskbar (or if they are not grouped), you should see their distinct labels: "Work A", "Work B", "Personal".


    Step 3: Pin to Taskbar (Optional but Recommended)

    Once your three windows are open:

    1. Right-click on each of the running Firefox icons on your taskbar.
    2. Select "Pin to taskbar".

    Now, even if you close the windows, you can simply click the distinct icons on your taskbar to launch them again with their respective labels.


    Step 4: Configure Each Window (Themes & Pinned Tabs)

    Now that you have your distinct windows and taskbar labels, make them visually unique and useful:

    1. For your "Work A" window:
      • Go to Settings > Extensions & Themes > Themes. Choose a distinct theme for this window (e.g., a dark theme). Enable it.
      • Open any tabs you want to always have in this "Work A" window. Right-click each tab and select "Pin Tab".
    2. For your "Work B" window:
      • Go to Settings > Extensions & Themes > Themes. Choose a different distinct theme. Enable it.
      • Open and pin any "Work B" specific tabs.
    3. For your "Personal" window:
      • Go to Settings > Extensions & Themes > Themes. Choose a third distinct theme. Enable it.
      • Open and pin any "Personal" specific tabs.

    Step 5: Prevent New Windows (Using an Extension)

    To prevent any new Firefox windows from opening outside of your designated three:

    1. Open any of your three Firefox windows.
    2. Go to Menu (three lines) > Add-ons and themes.
    3. Search for "No New Window".
    4. Click + Add to Firefox and then Add.
      • This extension will automatically close any new Firefox window that tries to open (e.g., from Ctrl+N, File > New Window, or external links forcing a new window). This ensures only your three profile-specific windows can exist.

    Step 6: Set to Auto-Open at Startup (Optional)

    To have these three windows automatically open when you log into Windows:

    1. Press Win + R to open the Run dialog.
    2. Type shell:startup and press Enter. This opens your Startup folder.
    3. Drag the three custom shortcuts you created in Step 2 into this folder.

    Important Considerations with this approach:

    • Data Separation: As a consequence of using profiles, your browsing history, bookmarks, saved passwords, and extensions will be separate for each window. This is often a desired outcome for work/personal separation, but it's important to be aware of.
    • Shared Extensions (Workaround): If you install an extension in one profile, it won't be in the others. You'll need to install essential extensions (like the "No New Window" one) in each profile you create.
    • Resource Usage: Running three separate Firefox profiles means three separate processes, which will use more RAM and CPU than a single Firefox instance. Modern computers generally handle this fine.

    This setup will give you exactly what you requested: three visually distinct Firefox windows, with their own specific labels visible directly on your Windows taskbar, and the ability to prevent any other Firefox windows from opening.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.