Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwq-32b· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Can I get the probability of the output tokens by OpenAI API? If yes, can I get it by a…

  1. User

    Can I get the probability of the output tokens by OpenAI API? If yes, can I get it by a http API call? If yes, can I specify the output and get the probability?

  2. Qwen Assistant

    Yes, you can obtain the probabilities of output tokens using the OpenAI API via an HTTP API call. Here's a detailed breakdown:


    1. Can You Get Output Token Probabilities?

    Yes, the Completion API allows retrieving log probabilities for tokens. Specifically:

    • Use the logprobs parameter in the API request to get the log probabilities of the top tokens at each position in the generated text.
    • The API returns log probabilities (natural logarithm) for tokens, not raw probabilities. You can convert them back to probabilities using ( \text{probability} = e^{\text{log_prob}} ).

    2. How to Do This via an HTTP API Call?

    Yes, you can achieve this with a standard HTTP POST request to the Completions API endpoint.

    Example Request:

    POST https://api.openai.com/v1/engines/{model}/completions
    Content-Type: application/json
    Authorization: Bearer YOUR_API_KEY
    
    {
      "prompt": "Once upon a time",
      "max_tokens": 5,
      "logprobs": 5  // Returns top 5 log probabilities for each token
    }
    

    Example Response:

    {
      "choices": [
        {
          "text": " there were three bears.",
          "logprobs": {
            "tokens": [" there", " once", " then", " so", " but"],
            "token_logprobs": [-0.1, -0.5, -0.8, -1.2, -1.5],
            ...
          }
        }
      ]
    }
    

    3. Can You Specify an Output Token and Get Its Probability?

    • Yes, indirectly: If the token is among the top N tokens returned by logprobs=N, its log probability will be included in the response.
    • No, directly: The API does not allow querying the probability of an arbitrary token outside the top N results. If your desired token is not in the top N, you must increase logprobs (up to a max of 100) or use a different approach.

    Key Notes

    • Limitations:
      • The maximum value for logprobs is 100 (per OpenAI's documentation).
      • Log probabilities are only available for tokens in the generated output, not for arbitrary text you specify.
    • Calculating Sequence Probability:
      • For a sequence of tokens, multiply their probabilities (or sum their log probabilities).
      • Example: If tokens "a" (log_prob=-0.1) and "b" (log_prob=-0.2) are consecutive, the combined log probability is (-0.3), and the probability is (e^{-0.3}).

    Summary

    QuestionAnswer
    Can I get output token probabilities?Yes, via the logprobs parameter in the Completion API.
    Can I do this via HTTP?Yes, using a POST request to /v1/engines/{model}/completions.
    Can I specify a token and get its probability?Yes, if it is among the top N tokens returned by logprobs=N.

    For more details, see the OpenAI Completion API documentation.

  3. User

    Can I limit the result to a number (1-12) and compute the probability of different numbers?

  4. Qwen Assistant

    Yes, you can indirectly compute the probability distribution over numbers 1–12 by leveraging the OpenAI API's log probability outputs, but there are limitations and caveats. Here's how to approach it:


    Approach: Using Log Probabilities for Tokens 1–12

    1. Force the Model to Output a Number Between 1–12:

      • Use a stop sequence to ensure the model stops after generating the first token (the number).
      • Structure your prompt to strongly encourage the model to output a number between 1–12 (e.g., "What is your guess? The answer is:").
      POST https://api.openai.com/v1/engines/{model}/completions
      Content-Type: application/json
      Authorization: Bearer YOUR_API_KEY
      
      {
        "prompt": "Guess a number between 1 and 12. The answer is:",
        "max_tokens": 1,          // Generate only one token (the number)
        "stop": "\n",             // Stop after the first token to enforce a single number
        "logprobs": 12            // Return top 12 log probabilities
      }
      
    2. Extract Probabilities for Numbers 1–12:

      • The API returns the top 12 tokens and their log probabilities. If the tokens "1" to "12" are among them, you can:
        1. Collect their log probabilities.
        2. Convert log probabilities to probabilities (( \text{prob} = e^{\text{log_prob}} )).
        3. Normalize them so they sum to 1 (if needed).

      Example response snippet:

      "logprobs": {
        "tokens": ["6", "3", "9", "2", "12", ...],
        "token_logprobs": [-0.2, -0.5, -0.8, ...]
      }
      
    3. Handle Missing Numbers:

      • If a number (e.g., "7") isn’t in the top 12 tokens, its probability will be zero in your computed distribution (or very low, requiring a larger logprobs value).
      • To capture all numbers 1–12, you might need to increase logprobs (up to 100, the API maximum).

    Steps to Compute Probabilities

    1. Make the API Call:

      • Use the parameters above to get log probabilities for the top tokens.
    2. Extract and Normalize:

      • Create a dictionary for numbers 1–12, initialized to 0.
      • For each token in the API response:
        • If the token is a number between 1–12 (as a string, e.g., "7"), add its probability to the dictionary.
      • Normalize the probabilities so they sum to 1: [ P(n) = \frac{e^{\text{log_prob}(n)}}{\sum_{k=1}^{12} e^{\text{log_prob}(k)}} ]

    Example Calculation

    Suppose the API returns the following log probabilities for tokens:

    • "6": log_prob = -0.2
    • "3": log_prob = -0.5
    • "9": log_prob = -0.8
    • "2": log_prob = -1.0
    • Others (non-1–12 tokens) are ignored.

    Step 1: Convert to probabilities:

    • ( P(6) = e^{-0.2} \approx 0.819 )
    • ( P(3) = e^{-0.5} \approx 0.607 )
    • ( P(9) = e^{-0.8} \approx 0.449 )
    • ( P(2) = e^{-1.0} \approx 0.368 )

    Step 2: Normalize (sum = 0.819 + 0.607 + 0.449 + 0.368 ≈ 2.243):

    • ( P_{\text{norm}}(6) = 0.819 / 2.243 ≈ 0.365 )
    • ( P_{\text{norm}}(3) = 0.607 / 2.243 ≈ 0.271 )
    • ( P_{\text{norm}}(9) = 0.449 / 2.243 ≈ 0.200 )
    • ( P_{\text{norm}}(2) = 0.368 / 2.243 ≈ 0.164 )

    The remaining numbers (1, 4, 5, 7, 8, 10, 11, 12) would have ( P_{\text{norm}} = 0 ) if they weren’t in the top 12 tokens.


    Limitations

    1. Token Coverage:

      • The API only returns the top logprobs tokens. If a number (e.g., "12") isn’t in this list, its probability is treated as 0.
      • To include all 12 numbers, you might need to set logprobs to at least 12 (or higher if other tokens are more probable).
    2. Model Bias:

      • The model may favor certain numbers based on its training data or the prompt’s phrasing.
    3. Stop Sequence:

      • Using stop ensures only one token is generated, but it might sometimes fail if the model outputs multiple tokens before the stop sequence.

    Alternative Approach: Manual Probability Calculation

    If you need precise probabilities for all numbers 1–12:

    1. Generate Each Number Individually:

      • For each number ( n ) in 1–12, make an API call with the prompt:
        {
          "prompt": "Guess a number between 1 and 12. The answer is: " + n,
          "echo": true,
          "logprobs": 1
        }
        
      • The response will include the log probability of the token ( n ).
    2. Compute Probabilities:

      • Collect all log probabilities for numbers 1–12 and normalize them.

    Final Answer

    QuestionAnswer
    Can I limit outputs to 1–12?Yes, using stop and prompt engineering.
    Can I compute probabilities for each number?Yes, but indirectly via log probabilities. You must post-process the API response to extract and normalize probabilities for numbers 1–12.
    Can I specify a number and get its probability directly?Not directly, but you can calculate it by querying each number individually (inefficient) or relying on the top tokens in logprobs.

    For code examples and further details, see the OpenAI Completion API documentation.