Create the simplest valid concrete example possible of an election in which instant…
- User
Create the simplest valid concrete example possible of an election in which instant runoff voting fails monotonicity.
Assistant
Here's a simple 9-voter example where IRV fails monotonicity:
Original Election:
- 3 voters: A > B > C
- 3 voters: B > C > A
- 3 voters: C > A > B
IRV Process:
- Round 1: A=3, B=3, C=3 (three-way tie)
- Eliminate C (using alphabetical tiebreaker)
- C>A>B voters transfer to A
- Round 2: A=6, B=3
- A wins
Modified Election (1 voter changes from B>C>A to A>B>C):
- 4 voters: A > B > C
- 2 voters: B > C > A
- 3 voters: C > A > B
IRV Process:
- Round 1: A=4, B=2, C=3
- Eliminate B (fewest votes)
- B>C>A voters transfer to C
- Round 2: A=4, C=5
- C wins
Monotonicity Failure: A won the original election, but when one voter moved A from last place to first place in their ranking, A lost and C won instead. This violates monotonicity because increasing support for the winner caused them to lose.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.