What are the main differences between snap and flatpak packages? Are there differences…
- User
What are the main differences between snap and flatpak packages? Are there differences concerning security (sandboxing etc.)?
- Assistant
Snap and Flatpak are both modern packaging systems designed to make software distribution on Linux easier, especially for desktop applications. While they share some goals, they have important differences in design, security, and ecosystem. Here’s a breakdown:
1. Origin and Ecosystem
-
Snap
- Developed by Canonical (the company behind Ubuntu).
- Used by Ubuntu and available on many other distributions.
- Centralized store: Snap Store (controlled by Canonical).
-
Flatpak
- Developed by the FreeDesktop.org community.
- Used by Fedora, GNOME, and many other distributions.
- Decentralized: main repository is Flathub, but anyone can host their own.
2. Packaging and Distribution
-
Snap
- Packages are called snaps.
- All dependencies are bundled, except for a minimal base snap (like
coreorcore20). - Updates are automatic and transactional (atomic).
-
Flatpak
- Packages are called flatpaks.
- Uses runtimes (shared libraries) to reduce duplication.
- Updates are also automatic and atomic.
3. Sandboxing and Security
Sandboxing
-
Snap
- Uses AppArmor for sandboxing (on supported distributions).
- Sandboxes both desktop and server applications.
- Permissions are managed via interfaces (e.g., access to USB, camera, etc.).
- Some interfaces are auto-connected, others require user approval.
-
Flatpak
- Uses Bubblewrap for sandboxing (namespace isolation).
- Sandboxes primarily desktop applications.
- Permissions are managed via portals (for file access, printing, etc.).
- More granular control over filesystem and device access.
Security Differences
-
Snap
- Relies on AppArmor, which is not available or enabled by default on all distributions (best supported on Ubuntu).
- Snapd (the background service) runs as root, which has raised some concerns.
- All snaps are signed and verified.
-
Flatpak
- Uses user namespaces and seccomp for sandboxing, which are more universally available on Linux.
- Flatpak apps run as the user, not as root.
- Flatpak’s portal system is designed to minimize the need for direct access to user files or devices.
4. Integration and User Experience
-
Snap
- Tighter integration with Ubuntu.
- Snap apps may start slower due to compressed filesystem images.
- Snap apps are mounted as squashfs images.
-
Flatpak
- Better integration with GNOME and KDE desktops.
- Flatpak apps generally start faster.
- Flatpak apps use OSTree for efficient storage and updates.
5. Openness and Control
-
Snap
- Snap Store is proprietary and controlled by Canonical.
- All snaps must be published through the Snap Store (with some exceptions).
-
Flatpak
- Flathub is the main repository, but anyone can create and host their own Flatpak repo.
- The infrastructure and tools are open source.
Summary Table
Feature Snap Flatpak Origin Canonical (Ubuntu) FreeDesktop.org (community) Main Store Snap Store (centralized) Flathub (decentralized) Sandboxing AppArmor Bubblewrap, namespaces Security Model AppArmor, interfaces Namespaces, seccomp, portals App Type Desktop & server Primarily desktop Store Control Canonical Community, anyone can host Updates Automatic, atomic Automatic, atomic Root Required snapd runs as root Apps run as user
In Summary
- Snap is more centralized, tightly integrated with Ubuntu, and uses AppArmor for sandboxing (best on Ubuntu).
- Flatpak is more decentralized, desktop-focused, and uses Bubblewrap and portals for sandboxing (works well across distributions).
- Security: Both offer sandboxing, but Flatpak’s model is more distribution-agnostic and arguably more flexible for desktop apps. Snap’s reliance on AppArmor and snapd running as root are sometimes seen as drawbacks.
Which is better?
It depends on your needs, distribution, and preferences for openness and control. For desktop apps on non-Ubuntu systems, Flatpak is often preferred. For server apps or Ubuntu integration, Snap may be better. Both are secure, but with different approaches and trade-offs. -
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.