Skip to content
The Chat Archive
o3-2025-04-16· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

which is the best llm to use when I want to use the ipa to train agents in a game to…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Metallama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct’s answer.
  1. User

    which is the best llm to use when I want to use the ipa to train agents in a game to collabarate between them?

  2. Assistant

    Short answer up-front
    There’s no single “best” LLM for multi-agent collaboration; the choice depends on (1) where you want to run it, (2) how much latency you can tolerate, (3) your budget, and (4) how deep you want to customize / fine-tune.

    ▶️ Quick rule of thumb
    • If you can afford API calls and want the strongest zero-shot reasoning today → GPT-4(o) or Claude 3 (Opus / Sonnet)
    • If you need an open-weight model you can fine-tune or run on-prem → Meta Llama 3-70B or Mixtral 8×7B
    • If you need something lightweight for near-real-time game ticks → Mistral 7B-v0.2 or Phi-3-mini (4.2B)

    Below is a deeper breakdown plus some tips for wiring an LLM into a multi-agent training loop (“IPA”, I presume, is your in-game interaction/physics API).

    ────────────────────────────────────────

    1. Decision matrix
    RequirementBest fit modelsWhy / trade-offs
    Raw reasoning, long context, minimal engineeringGPT-4(o), Claude 3 OpusBest few-shot reasoning, largest context (128k), no infra, but $$$ and rate-limited.
    Open weights, high quality, big GPU budget (2×A100 or better)Llama 3-70B-InstructTop open-source QA & coding scores; easy to fine-tune (LoRA/QLoRA).
    Open weights, MoE efficiency, 1×80 GB or 2×40 GB cardsMixtral 8×7B (45B dense equiv)Good reasoning, 8 experts but only 2 active → fast.
    Low-latency, can run on laptop/edge, still coherentMistral 7B, Phi-3-mini5-15 ms/token on single RTX 4090; good for per-tick decisions.
    Free (totally offline), smallest memory footprintTinyLlama-1.1B or Phi-2Works on CPU, good for prototyping but limited reasoning depth.

    ──────────────────────────────────────── 2. Integration pattern for multi-agent games

    Assume you have an in-game “IPA” (Interaction / Physics API) that agents can call.

    Step 1. Define agent personas
    • “Scout”, “Builder”, “Strategist” … give each agent a system prompt that describes its role, capabilities, and the function schema it may call in the IPA (JSON schema or function‐calling spec).
    • Optionally give each agent a memory buffer or vector store so they can recall past turns.

    Step 2. Use a coordinator (or let them free-chat)
    Approaches:
    a) Central Orchestrator: One LLM (“Game Master”) decides when to wake which agent.
    b) Decentralised Chat: Put all agents in a group-chat (Autogen, CrewAI style) and let them send messages to each other, with a turn-based cap to avoid loops.

    Step 3. Ground the model via tool calls
    Expose IPA methods as structured function calls (OpenAI function-calling / Anthropic tool use / LM Studio tools). The LLM outputs a JSON payload; your game engine executes it and feeds back the result.

    Step 4. (Optional) Reinforcement-learn or fine-tune
    Record <state, message, action, reward> tuples. You can:
    • Behaviour-clone: fine-tune a smaller open model on successful trajectories.
    • RLAIF / DPO: teach the model to prefer high-reward collaborations.
    This lets you distil expensive GPT-4 traces into a smaller local model for live play.

    ──────────────────────────────────────── 3. Choosing between closed vs open models

    Closed APIs (GPT-4(o), Claude 3, Gemini 1.5 Pro)
    ✔ Best out-of-the-box reasoning, huge context (good for entire game history)
    ✔ Fastest to prototype (no GPUs)
    ✖ Variable latency, rate limits
    ✖ Pay per token (expensive for long sessions)
    ✖ Cannot self-host → harder for shipping in a commercial game without exposing keys

    Open weights (Llama 3, Mixtral, Mistral, Phi-3)
    ✔ Full control, no rate limits, modifiable, can embed directly in game client/server
    ✔ Fine-tune on your domain, style, slang
    ✔ Cheaper at scale (one-off GPU cap-ex)
    ✖ Need MLOps & GPU VRAM (≈ 40–80 GB for 70B, 16 GB OK for 7B)
    ✖ Slightly weaker zero-shot; may need prompt engineering or light fine-tune

    ──────────────────────────────────────── 4. Practical recommendations

    Budget no object → Use GPT-4(o) as “teacher” during training, distil into Llama 3-8B or Phi-3-mini for runtime.

    Indie / academic budget, 1× GPU (24 GB) → Start with Mixtral 8×7B (load at 4-bit), or Mistral 7B if memory-tight. Add QLoRA fine-tune on collaborative trajectories.

    Edge deployment (mobile / VR) → Phi-3-mini or Mistral-7B-int4; serve via gguf through llama.cpp.

    ──────────────────────────────────────── Questions that will narrow it down

    1. How much context do your agents need to keep (entire match log vs last 20 turns)?
    2. Real-time constraints: Do you need sub-100 ms responses every game tick?
    3. Do you have GPUs in production, or must everything be an API call?
    4. Are you allowed to ship closed-source weights inside the game build?

    Feel free to drop a bit more detail on those and I can give you a more prescriptive pick-list (exact model file, quantisation type, and sample code). Good luck with the agent squad!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.