Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-flash-lite-preview-06-17-thinking· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

tension between emergence and scaling laws, which papers have looked at it before

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with o3-2025-04-16’s answer.
  1. User

    tension between emergence and scaling laws, which papers have looked at it before

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, let's break down the tension between "emergence" and "scaling laws" in the context of neural networks, particularly large language models (LLMs), and identify key papers that have explored this.

    1. Scaling Laws:

    • What they are: Scaling laws describe how the performance of a neural network (typically measured by metrics like loss or accuracy on a specific task) improves predictably, often following a power-law relationship, as resources like model size (NN), dataset size (DD), and compute (CC) are increased.
    • Key Idea: Performance improves smoothly and predictably with scale. You can often extrapolate performance at larger scales based on performance at smaller scales.
    • Seminal Papers:
      • Kaplan et al. (OpenAI, 2020) - "Scaling Laws for Neural Language Models": This paper famously showed that the cross-entropy loss of transformer language models decreases as a power law of the model size, dataset size, and compute used for training, provided the other factors are not bottlenecks. It suggested a relatively smooth, predictable improvement curve for fundamental metrics.
      • Hestness et al. (DeepMind, 2017) - "Scalable and Efficient Learning of Embedded Representations": An earlier work that showed power-law scaling for transfer learning performance across various tasks and model sizes.
      • Hoffmann et al. (DeepMind, 2022) - "Chinchilla: A Scaling Laws Approach for Training Compute-Optimal Large Language Models": Refined the understanding of scaling laws by showing that optimal performance requires balancing model size and dataset size more carefully than previously thought. They suggested many prior large models were undertrained relative to their size. This still points towards predictable scaling, but with specific ratios.

    2. Emergent Abilities:

    • What they are: Emergent abilities refer to capabilities or behaviors that are not present or are negligible in smaller models but appear relatively suddenly and sharply once models reach a certain scale threshold. These are often qualitative shifts in performance on specific, complex tasks (e.g., arithmetic, multi-step reasoning, understanding specific linguistic phenomena).
    • Key Idea: Performance on certain tasks doesn't improve smoothly but rather appears "out of nowhere" past a certain scale.
    • Seminal Papers:
      • Wei et al. (Google Brain, 2022) - "Emergent Abilities of Large Language Models": This paper is crucial for popularizing the term and documenting specific examples. They showed tasks like multi-digit arithmetic, understanding figurative language, and performing certain reasoning tasks where performance was near random chance for smaller models but rapidly increased to high accuracy at larger scales (e.g., >100B parameters).
      • Wei et al. (Google Brain, 2022) - "Chain-of-Thought Prompting Elicits Reasoning in Large Language Models": While focused on prompting, this work demonstrated that a specific technique (Chain-of-Thought) dramatically improved performance on reasoning tasks, and this improvement was much more pronounced in larger models, aligning with the idea that the underlying ability emerged first and was then unlocked by the prompting method.

    3. The Tension:

    The core tension lies in the apparent contradiction between the smooth, predictable power-law improvements predicted by scaling laws and the sudden, qualitative leaps associated with emergent abilities.

    • Predictability vs. Surprise: Scaling laws suggest we can predict future capabilities based on current trends. Emergence implies that some capabilities are fundamentally surprising and hard to predict until they manifest.
    • Smoothness vs. Sharpness: Are the "sudden" jumps in emergent abilities truly discontinuous, or are they just the steep part of a curve that, if observed over a much wider range of scales or with different evaluation metrics, would appear smooth?
    • Mechanism: If scaling laws govern fundamental learning dynamics (like loss reduction), how do specific, complex capabilities emerge non-linearly on top of this? Does emergence imply a phase transition in the model's internal representations or computations?

    Papers Exploring or Debating the Tension:

    Several papers have either highlighted this tension or attempted to reconcile the two perspectives:

    1. Min et al. (Meta AI, 2023) - "Emergence is not magic: A meta-analysis of the scaling of language model capabilities": This paper directly challenges the notion of "emergent abilities" as traditionally defined. The authors argue that many claimed emergent abilities might be artifacts of:

      • Evaluation Metrics: Performance jumps might appear sharp simply because the metric used (e.g., accuracy) is insensitive at low performance levels and then rapidly captures improvements. If plotted on a different scale (like log-log) or using different metrics (like loss), the scaling might appear smoother.
      • Task Difficulty Thresholds: Abilities might emerge smoothly, but the task only becomes solvable (performance significantly above random) at a specific scale.
      • Methodological Choices: Different evaluation setups or fine-tuning strategies can influence when an ability appears to manifest. They propose that most capabilities likely follow smoother scaling trends, similar to loss, and the perception of emergence is often due to how we measure and analyze performance.
    2. Chan et al. (Google Research, 2022) - "Beyond the Imitation Game: Quantifying and extrapolating the capabilities of language models": This work analyzed scaling across a vast number of tasks. While finding mostly smooth scaling trends, they did identify certain tasks where performance seemed to plateau and then increase sharply, hinting at emergence, but often concluded that smoother extrapolation was still possible.

    3. Papers analyzing specific tasks: Many papers evaluating LLMs on benchmarks like BIG-Bench or HELM implicitly show scaling trends. Some tasks demonstrate smooth improvement (aligning with scaling laws), while others show sharper jumps (aligning with emergence). The interpretation often depends on the specific task and the analysis methodology.

    4. Theoretical perspectives: While not always directly citing "emergence," work on phase transitions in statistical mechanics and their potential application to neural networks (e.g., relating sharpness of learning or representational changes to scale) provides a theoretical lens through which the tension can be understood. Research into "double descent" also shows non-monotonic scaling behaviors that deviate from simple power laws, potentially creating sharp transitions.

    Summary of the Debate:

    • Scaling Law Camp: Argues that performance, including complex capabilities, improves predictably with scale, often following power laws. "Emergence" is often an artifact of measurement or insufficient data points at smaller scales. (e.g., Kaplan et al., Hoffmann et al., potentially Min et al.).
    • Emergence Camp: Argues that certain qualitatively distinct abilities genuinely appear only after specific scale thresholds are crossed, representing a fundamental shift in the model's learned representations or computational capabilities. (e.g., Wei et al.).
    • Reconciliation/Nuance: Many researchers believe the reality is complex. Scaling laws might describe the general trend, but specific architectural properties, training dynamics, or the nature of certain tasks could lead to periods of more rapid, seemingly emergent, change within those broader trends. Min et al.'s work is a significant attempt to provide a unified, smoother explanation.

    The debate is ongoing and crucial for understanding how to build increasingly capable AI systems efficiently and predictably.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.