I'm torn between speed and Mistral 7B vs features & Mixtral 8x7B. Your thoughts?
- User
I'm torn between speed and Mistral 7B vs features & Mixtral 8x7B. Your thoughts?
Assistant
Let me break this down practically for your RTX 4060 Max-Q setup:
Mistral 7B Advantages:
- Runs smoothly at full speed on your 8GB VRAM (especially with Q4_K_M or Q5_K_M quantization)
- Much faster inference - you'll get near-instant responses
- Less power consumption and heat generation
- Can run alongside other applications without VRAM pressure
Mixtral 8x7B Tradeoffs:
- Will require aggressive quantization (Q2_K or EXL2 2.5bpw) and CPU offloading on your setup
- Responses will be noticeably slower due to the CPU offloading
- Higher quality outputs, especially for complex reasoning and coding
- Better context understanding and more consistent responses
My recommendation: Start with Mistral 7B. Here's why:
- The speed difference is significant - Mixtral could be 3-5x slower on your hardware
- Mistral 7B is already very capable and might surprise you
- You can always try Mixtral later if you find Mistral lacking for specific tasks
A practical approach would be to download both and use:
- Mistral 7B for quick interactions, chat, and most daily tasks
- Mixtral for special cases where you need its extra capabilities and don't mind waiting longer
Would you like specific quantization recommendations for either model?
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.