Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Metallama-3.3-70b-instruct· MetaHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Act as an old-school ES5 web developer. Given a function named onMIDIMessage() that runs…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with o4-mini-2025-04-16’s answer.
  1. User

    Act as an old-school ES5 web developer. Given a function named onMIDIMessage() that runs every time a user inputs a key on their MIDI device, create a function called playPianoNote() that plays the correct note on the piano via the web browser. Import any libraries necessary.

  2. Meta Assistant

    Introduction to Playing Piano Notes with MIDI Input

    To play piano notes in the browser, we'll use the Web Audio API. We'll create a function playPianoNote() that takes the MIDI note number as an argument and plays the corresponding piano note.

    Code

    // Create an Audio Context
    var audioContext = new AudioContext();
    
    // Define the frequencies for piano notes
    var noteFrequencies = {
      21: 27.5, // A0
      22: 29.14, // A#0/Bb0
      23: 30.87, // B0
      24: 32.7, // C1
      25: 34.65, // C#1/Db1
      26: 36.71, // D1
      27: 38.89, // D#1/Eb1
      28: 41.2, // E1
      29: 43.65, // F1
      30: 46.25, // F#1/Gb1
      31: 49, // G1
      32: 51.91, // G#1/Ab1
      33: 55, // A1
      34: 58.27, // A#1/Bb1
      35: 61.74, // B1
      36: 65.41, // C2
      37: 69.3, // C#2/Db2
      38: 73.42, // D2
      39: 77.78, // D#2/Eb2
      40: 82.41, // E2
      41: 87.31, // F2
      42: 92.5, // F#2/Gb2
      43: 98, // G2
      44: 103.83, // G#2/Ab2
      45: 110, // A2
      46: 116.54, // A#2/Bb2
      47: 123.47, // B2
      48: 130.81, // C3
      49: 138.59, // C#3/Db3
      50: 146.83, // D3
      51: 155.56, // D#3/Eb3
      52: 164.81, // E3
      53: 174.61, // F3
      54: 185, // F#3/Gb3
      55: 196, // G3
      56: 207.65, // G#3/Ab3
      57: 220, // A3
      58: 233.08, // A#3/Bb3
      59: 246.94, // B3
      60: 261.63, // C4
      61: 277.18, // C#4/Db4
      62: 293.66, // D4
      63: 311.13, // D#4/Eb4
      64: 329.63, // E4
      65: 349.23, // F4
      66: 369.99, // F#4/Gb4
      67: 392, // G4
      68: 415.3, // G#4/Ab4
      69: 440, // A4
      70: 466.16, // A#4/Bb4
      71: 493.88, // B4
      72: 523.25, // C5
      73: 554.37, // C#5/Db5
      74: 587.33, // D5
      75: 622.25, // D#5/Eb5
      76: 659.26, // E5
      77: 698.46, // F5
      78: 739.99, // F#5/Gb5
      79: 783.99, // G5
      80: 830.61, // G#5/Ab5
      81: 880, // A5
      82: 932.33, // A#5/Bb5
      83: 987.77, // B5
      84: 1046.5, // C6
      85: 1108.73, // C#6/Db6
      86: 1174.66, // D6
      87: 1244.51, // D#6/Eb6
      88: 1318.51, // E6
      89: 1396.91, // F6
      90: 1479.98, // F#6/Gb6
      91: 1567.98, // G6
      92: 1661.22, // G#6/Ab6
      93: 1760, // A6
      94: 1864.66, // A#6/Bb6
      95: 1975.53, // B6
      96: 2093, // C7
      97: 2217.46, // C#7/Db7
      98: 2349.32, // D7
      99: 2489, // D#7/Eb7
      100: 2637.02, // E7
      101: 2793.83, // F7
      102: 2959.96, // F#7/Gb7
      103: 3135.96, // G7
      104: 3322.44, // G#7/Ab7
      105: 3520, // A7
      106: 3729.31, // A#7/Bb7
      107: 3951.07, // B7
      108: 4186, // C8
    };
    
    // Function to play a piano note
    function playPianoNote(note) {
      // Check if the note is valid
      if (noteFrequencies[note]) {
        // Create an Oscillator
        var oscillator = audioContext.createOscillator();
    
        // Set the frequency of the oscillator
        oscillator.type = "sine";
        oscillator.frequency.value = noteFrequencies[note];
    
        // Connect the oscillator to the destination
        oscillator.connect(audioContext.destination);
    
        // Start the oscillator
        oscillator.start();
    
        // Stop the oscillator after 1 second
        oscillator.stop(audioContext.currentTime + 1);
      } else {
        console.log("Invalid note");
      }
    }
    
    // Example usage:
    function onMIDIMessage(event) {
      // Get the MIDI note number from the event
      var note = event.data[1];
    
      // Play the piano note
      playPianoNote(note);
    }
    

    Explanation

    • We first create an AudioContext object, which is the primary object of the Web Audio API.
    • We define a noteFrequencies object that maps MIDI note numbers to their corresponding frequencies.
    • The playPianoNote() function takes a MIDI note number as an argument, creates an oscillator, sets its frequency to the corresponding piano note frequency, and starts the oscillator.
    • The oscillator is stopped after 1 second to prevent it from playing indefinitely.
    • In the onMIDIMessage() function, we get the MIDI note number from the event and pass it to the playPianoNote() function to play the corresponding piano note.

    Note

    • This code assumes that you have already set up a MIDI input device and are receiving MIDI messages in the onMIDIMessage() function.
    • The noteFrequencies object only includes frequencies for notes in the range of A0 to C8. You may need to add more frequencies if you want to support a wider range of notes.
    • This code uses the Web Audio API, which is supported by most modern browsers. However, you may need to use a polyfill or fallback for older browsers.
  3. User

    Excellent! How can I add release damper functionality (when the key is released it damps the note)?

  4. Meta Assistant

    Adding Release Damper Functionality

    To add release damper functionality, we need to keep track of the oscillators that are currently playing and stop them when the corresponding key is released. We can use a Map to store the oscillators, with the MIDI note number as the key.

    Here's an updated version of the code:

    // Create an Audio Context
    var audioContext = new AudioContext();
    
    // Define the frequencies for piano notes
    var noteFrequencies = {
      21: 27.5, // A0
      22: 29.14, // A#0/Bb0
      23: 30.87, // B0
      24: 32.7, // C1
      25: 34.65, // C#1/Db1
      26: 36.71, // D1
      27: 38.89, // D#1/Eb1
      28: 41.2, // E1
      29: 43.65, // F1
      30: 46.25, // F#1/Gb1
      31: 49, // G1
      32: 51.91, // G#1/Ab1
      33: 55, // A1
      34: 58.27, // A#1/Bb1
      35: 61.74, // B1
      36: 65.41, // C2
      37: 69.3, // C#2/Db2
      38: 73.42, // D2
      39: 77.78, // D#2/Eb2
      40: 82.41, // E2
      41: 87.31, // F2
      42: 92.5, // F#2/Gb2
      43: 98, // G2
      44: 103.83, // G#2/Ab2
      45: 110, // A2
      46: 116.54, // A#2/Bb2
      47: 123.47, // B2
      48: 130.81, // C3
      49: 138.59, // C#3/Db3
      50: 146.83, // D3
      51: 155.56, // D#3/Eb3
      52: 164.81, // E3
      53: 174.61, // F3
      54: 185, // F#3/Gb3
      55: 196, // G3
      56: 207.65, // G#3/Ab3
      57: 220, // A3
      58: 233.08, // A#3/Bb3
      59: 246.94, // B3
      60: 261.63, // C4
      61: 277.18, // C#4/Db4
      62: 293.66, // D4
      63: 311.13, // D#4/Eb4
      64: 329.63, // E4
      65: 349.23, // F4
      66: 369.99, // F#4/Gb4
      67: 392, // G4
      68: 415.3, // G#4/Ab4
      69: 440, // A4
      70: 466.16, // A#4/Bb4
      71: 493.88, // B4
      72: 523.25, // C5
      73: 554.37, // C#5/Db5
      74: 587.33, // D5
      75: 622.25, // D#5/Eb5
      76: 659.26, // E5
      77: 698.46, // F5
      78: 739.99, // F#5/Gb5
      79: 783.99, // G5
      80: 830.61, // G#5/Ab5
      81: 880, // A5
      82: 932.33, // A#5/Bb5
      83: 987.77, // B5
      84: 1046.5, // C6
      85: 1108.73, // C#6/Db6
      86: 1174.66, // D6
      87: 1244.51, // D#6/Eb6
      88: 1318.51, // E6
      89: 1396.91, // F6
      90: 1479.98, // F#6/Gb6
      91: 1567.98, // G6
      92: 1661.22, // G#6/Ab6
      93: 1760, // A6
      94: 1864.66, // A#6/Bb6
      95: 1975.53, // B6
      96: 2093, // C7
      97: 2217.46, // C#7/Db7
      98: 2349.32, // D7
      99: 2489, // D#7/Eb7
      100: 2637.02, // E7
      101: 2793.83, // F7
      102: 2959.96, // F#7/Gb7
      103: 3135.96, // G7
      104: 3322.44, // G#7/Ab7
      105: 3520, // A7
      106: 3729.31, // A#7/Bb7
      107: 3951.07, // B7
      108: 4186, // C8
    };
    
    // Map to store the oscillators
    var oscillators = new Map();
    
    // Function to play a piano note
    function playPianoNote(note) {
      // Check if the note is valid
      if (noteFrequencies[note]) {
        // Create an Oscillator
        var oscillator = audioContext.createOscillator();
    
        // Set the frequency of the oscillator
        oscillator.type = "sine";
        oscillator.frequency.value = noteFrequencies[note];
    
        // Connect the oscillator to the destination
        oscillator.connect(audioContext.destination);
    
        // Start the oscillator
        oscillator.start();
    
        // Store the oscillator in the map
        oscillators.set(note, oscillator);
      } else {
        console.log("Invalid note");
      }
    }
    
    // Function to stop a piano note
    function stopPianoNote(note) {
      // Check if the note is valid
      if (oscillators.has(note)) {
        // Get the oscillator from the map
        var oscillator = oscillators.get(note);
    
        // Stop the oscillator
        oscillator.stop(audioContext.currentTime);
    
        // Remove the oscillator from the map
        oscillators.delete(note);
      } else {
        console.log("Note is not playing");
      }
    }
    
    // Example usage:
    function onMIDIMessage(event) {
      // Get the MIDI note number and velocity from the event
      var note = event.data[1];
      var velocity = event.data[2];
    
      // Check if the key is being pressed or released
      if (velocity > 0) {
        // Play the piano note
        playPianoNote(note);
      } else {
        // Stop the piano note
        stopPianoNote(note);
      }
    }
    

    Explanation

    • We added a Map called oscillators to store the oscillators that are currently playing, with the MIDI note number as the key.
    • In the playPianoNote() function, we store the oscillator in the oscillators map after starting it.
    • We added a stopPianoNote() function that stops the oscillator and removes it from the oscillators map.
    • In the onMIDIMessage() function, we check if the key is being pressed or released based on the velocity value. If the key is being pressed, we play the piano note. If the key is being released, we stop the piano note.

    Note

    • This code assumes that the MIDI velocity value is 0 when the key is released. You may need to adjust this value depending on your MIDI device.
    • This code uses the Web Audio API, which is supported by most modern browsers. However, you may need to use a polyfill or fallback for older browsers.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.