Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-pro-preview-05-06· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Why does people in Hong Kong cannot use certain AI such as ChatGPT and Gemini? Explain…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with o4-mini-2025-04-16’s answer.
  1. User

    Why does people in Hong Kong cannot use certain AI such as ChatGPT and Gemini? Explain in detail

  2. Gemini Assistant

    The situation regarding access to AI models like ChatGPT and Gemini in Hong Kong is nuanced and has been evolving. Here's a detailed breakdown:

    ChatGPT (developed by OpenAI):

    As of my last update, OpenAI does not officially offer ChatGPT services directly in Hong Kong. This means:

    1. Geo-blocking: When you try to access the ChatGPT website or sign up for an account from a Hong Kong IP address, you're often blocked or told the service isn't available in your region.
    2. Phone Number Verification: OpenAI requires phone number verification for account creation. Hong Kong (+852) phone numbers are typically not accepted for this verification process.

    Why OpenAI restricts access in Hong Kong (and some other regions):

    While OpenAI hasn't given explicit, detailed public statements specifically for Hong Kong for every decision, the reasons generally fall into these categories:

    1. Regulatory Uncertainty and Compliance:

      • Evolving AI Regulations: AI is a rapidly developing field, and governments worldwide are still figuring out how to regulate it. Companies like OpenAI may adopt a cautious approach, rolling out services gradually to regions where the regulatory landscape is clearer or where they have established compliance frameworks.
      • Data Privacy Laws: Hong Kong has its own data privacy ordinance (PDPO). OpenAI needs to ensure its data handling practices comply with local laws in every jurisdiction it operates. This can be complex, especially for a service that processes vast amounts of user data.
      • Content Moderation and Misuse: AI models can generate problematic content (misinformation, hate speech, etc.). Companies are responsible for mitigating these risks. The legal and social expectations for content moderation can vary significantly by region, and ensuring compliance can be resource-intensive.
      • Hong Kong's Unique Position: While Hong Kong has its own legal system ("One Country, Two Systems"), its increasing integration with mainland China's regulatory environment, particularly concerning data and internet governance, might lead to caution from international tech companies. They may want to avoid potential complexities or future regulatory shifts.
    2. Phased Rollout and Resource Allocation:

      • Strategic Prioritization: Companies often prioritize larger markets or markets with specific strategic importance for initial rollouts.
      • Infrastructure and Support: Launching in a new region requires investment in local infrastructure (potentially servers), customer support in local languages, and legal/compliance teams familiar with local laws. OpenAI might be scaling these operations gradually.
    3. Risk Management:

      • Companies may limit access in regions where they perceive higher risks related to misuse of the technology, intellectual property concerns, or potential legal liabilities.

    Gemini (developed by Google):

    The situation with Gemini is slightly different:

    • Bard (now often referred to as Gemini): Google's conversational AI service, Bard, which is powered by Gemini models, is generally accessible in Hong Kong. Users in Hong Kong can typically access and use Bard through their Google accounts.
    • Gemini Advanced / Paid Tiers: Specific advanced features or paid tiers of Gemini (e.g., through Google One AI Premium) might have a more limited rollout initially, and their availability could vary.
    • API Access: Access to Gemini models via APIs for developers might also have its own regional availability list and terms of service.

    Why Google might have wider availability for Bard/Gemini in Hong Kong (compared to ChatGPT):

    1. Existing Infrastructure and Presence: Google has a long-standing, significant presence in Hong Kong, including local teams, data infrastructure, and experience navigating the local regulatory environment for its other services (Search, Gmail, YouTube, etc.). This makes it easier to extend new AI services.
    2. Different Risk Assessment/Rollout Strategy: Google might have a different risk tolerance or a more aggressive global rollout strategy for its consumer-facing AI products.
    3. Integration with Existing Products: Gemini is deeply integrated into Google's existing ecosystem, which is already widely used in Hong Kong.

    How people in Hong Kong sometimes access restricted services (like ChatGPT):

    Despite official restrictions, some individuals in Hong Kong might access services like ChatGPT through:

    • VPNs (Virtual Private Networks): To mask their IP address and appear as if they are accessing from a supported country.
    • International Phone Numbers: Using phone numbers from supported countries (e.g., via friends, family abroad, or online services) for verification.
    • Third-party Platforms: Some third-party applications or websites might offer access to underlying models like GPT via APIs, though these come with their own terms, costs, and potential risks.

    In Summary:

    • ChatGPT: Not officially available in Hong Kong primarily due to OpenAI's cautious, phased rollout strategy, which considers regulatory complexities, compliance requirements, and risk management.
    • Gemini/Bard: Generally available in Hong Kong, likely due to Google's established presence and infrastructure in the region, allowing for easier compliance and service delivery.

    It's important to note that the AI landscape is dynamic. Company policies and service availability can change, so the situation might evolve.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.