Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Mistralmistral-small-2506· Mistral AIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

If pokemon were real, which species would you see being sold in pet shops? Only up to…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with grok-3-mini-high’s answer.
  1. User

    If pokemon were real, which species would you see being sold in pet shops? Only up to gen IV

  2. Mistral Assistant

    If Pokémon were real and sold in pet shops up to Generation IV, the species would likely be chosen based on their size, temperament, and ease of care—similar to how real-world pets like dogs, cats, and small reptiles are selected. Here are some likely candidates:

    Common Pet Pokémon (Gen I-IV):

    1. Pidgey/Pidgeotto/Pidgeot – Small, bird-like, and relatively easy to care for. Could be a popular "starter" pet.
    2. Rattata/Raticate – Small, rodent-like, and adaptable. Might be sold as a "starter" pet for kids.
    3. Sentret/Furret – Playful, weasel-like Pokémon that would be fun for families.
    4. Hoppip/Skiploom/Jumpluff – Small, floating, and gentle, making them good for kids.
    5. Zigzagoon/Linoone – Energetic but friendly, similar to real-world raccoons.
    6. Bidoof/Bibarel – Cute, water-loving rodents that could be sold as aquatic pets.
    7. Starly/Staravia/Staraptor – Small, bird-like, and trainable, similar to falcons or parrots.
    8. Shinx/Luxio/Luxray – Small, cat-like, and electric, making them unique but manageable.
    9. Buneary/Lopunny – Rabbit-like and gentle, perfect for families.
    10. Patrat/Watchog – Small, intelligent, and alert, like a pet squirrel or raccoon.
    11. Pachirisu – Small, chubby, and electric, similar to a hamster or squirrel.
    12. Bonsly/Sudowoodo – Small, plant-like, and stationary, making them low-maintenance.
    13. Chingling/Chimecho – Small, floating, and musical, like a pet bell.
    14. Budew/Roselia/Roserade – Small, plant-like, and decorative, similar to a potted plant.
    15. Combee/Vespiquen – Small, bee-like, and social, possibly sold in groups.

    Less Common but Possible Pet Pokémon:

    • Meowth/Persian – Cat-like and independent, but might be sold as exotic pets.
    • Growlithe/Arcanine – Loyal and dog-like, but larger, so more for experienced owners.
    • Eevee & Evolutions – Popular but might be expensive due to their versatility.
    • Togepi/Togetic/Togekiss – Small, friendly, and angelic, but Togekiss might be too large.
    • Munchlax/Snorlax – Cute but very large, so more for wealthy owners.
    • Drifloon/Drifblim – Floating and ghostly, but might be considered "creepy" by some.

    Unlikely to Be Sold in Pet Shops:

    • Legendaries/Mythicals (e.g., Mew, Lugia, Dialga) – Too rare and powerful.
    • Extremely Large Pokémon (e.g., Gyarados, Wailord, Slaking) – Not practical for homes.
    • Dangerous Pokémon (e.g., Garchomp, Tyranitar, Houndoom) – Too aggressive or hard to control.

    Final Thoughts:

    Pet shops would likely focus on small, docile, and visually appealing Pokémon that are easy to care for. Larger or more aggressive species would be sold by specialized breeders or trainers.

    Would you adopt any of these? 😊

  3. User

    Okay, I agree with most of what you said, however I don't think most pokemons that are direct counterparts to animals that are not common pets would be sold like pidgeys (pidgeons), bidoofs (beaver), zigzagoon (racoon), rattata (rat) and so on, I don't think regular pet shops would sell larger ones either like growlith or vulpix, instead those would be sold at specialized breeds. So I think the most sold would probably be eevee, then nidorans, sentrets, maybe hoothoots, magikarps, skitty, snubul. These sorts... nothing too fancy or dangerous.

  4. Mistral Assistant

    You're absolutely right! If we're thinking about typical pet shops (like the ones that sell dogs, cats, hamsters, and fish), they'd likely avoid Pokémon that are too wild, too large, or too closely resemble pests (like rats, pigeons, or raccoons). Instead, they'd focus on cute, small, and non-threatening Pokémon that appeal to casual buyers.

    Most Likely Pet Shop Pokémon (Gen I-IV):

    1. Eevee – The ultimate "starter pet" due to its cuteness and potential to evolve into different forms.
    2. Nidoran♀/Nidoran♂ – Small, rodent-like, and relatively docile (though males might be seen as slightly more aggressive).
    3. Sentret/Furret – Playful, weasel-like, and energetic—similar to ferrets in real life.
    4. Hoothoot/Noctowl – Owl-like and intelligent, but not too large (unlike Noctowl, which might be for experienced owners).
    5. Magikarp – Cheap, low-maintenance, and sold in bulk (like goldfish).
    6. Skitty/Delcatty – Cat-like and fluffy, perfect for people who want a "real" cat but with Pokémon traits.
    7. Snubbull/Granbull – Small, dog-like, and friendly (though Granbull might be for more experienced owners).
    8. Porygon – A digital pet, sold as a "high-tech" option (like a Tamagotchi).
    9. Togepi/Togetic – Small, angelic, and easy to care for.
    10. Chingling/Chimecho – Tiny, floating, and musical—great for decoration.
    11. Budew/Roselia – Plant-like and low-maintenance (like a potted plant).
    12. Buneary/Lopunny – Rabbit-like and gentle, similar to real bunnies.
    13. Munchlax – Chubby and lazy, sold as a "low-energy" pet.
    14. Pachirisu – Small, electric, and squirrel-like—cute and manageable.
    15. Combee/Vespiquen – Sold in groups (like bees in a hive).

    Why These?

    • No direct real-world pests (unlike Rattata, Zigzagoon, or Bidoof).
    • Small and manageable (unlike Growlithe, Vulpix, or larger Pokémon).
    • Visually appealing (Eevee, Skitty, Togepi, etc. are designed to be cute).
    • Low-maintenance (Magikarp, Budew, Porygon).

    Specialized Breeders Would Handle:

    • Growlithe/Arcanine (too large and loyal, like a guard dog).
    • Vulpix/Ninetales (fox-like, but Ninetales might be too exotic).
    • Eevee’s Evolutions (unless sold as "premium" pets).
    • Legendaries/Mythicals (obviously not in pet shops).

    Final Verdict:

    A typical pet shop would stock Eevee, Nidoran, Sentret, Hoothoot, Magikarp, Skitty, Snubbull, Togepi, and similar Pokémon—nothing too wild, dangerous, or large. The rest would be sold by specialized breeders or trainers.

    Would you adopt any of these? 😊

  5. User

    I can definitely people selling growliths, vulpixes, charmanders, squirtles, ponytas, torchicks, treekos, mudkips, chikoritas, totidiles, ekanses and so on at breeders though, as they would translate to exotic pet counterparts to real life.

  6. Mistral Assistant

    You're absolutely right! While pet shops would stick to small, low-maintenance Pokémon, specialized breeders would absolutely sell more exotic or larger Pokémon as high-end, niche pets—similar to how people buy exotic birds, reptiles, or rare dog breeds.

    Pokémon Likely Sold by Specialized Breeders (Gen I-IV):

    Dog/Cat-Like Pokémon (Exotic Pets)

    • Growlithe/Arcanine – Loyal, dog-like, and majestic (like a German Shepherd or Husky).
    • Vulpix/Ninetales – Fox-like, elegant, and mystical (like a Fennec Fox or Arctic Fox).
    • Meowth/Persian – Cat-like, but more exotic than Skitty.
    • Ponyta/Rapidash – Horse-like, but fire-breathing (like a miniature unicorn).
    • Torchic/Combusken/Blaziken – Chicken-like but fiery (like a rare game bird).
    • Turtwig/Grotle/Torterra – Turtle-like, but plant-based (like a Galápagos tortoise).
    • Charmander/Charmeleon/Charizard – Dragon-like, but Charizard would be for very wealthy owners.
    • Squirtle/Wartortle/Blastoise – Turtle-like, but Blastoise would be a luxury pet.
    • Bulbasaur/Ivysaur/Venusaur – Plant-based, but Venusaur would be too large for most homes.

    Reptile/Amphibian-Like Pokémon

    • Mudkip/Marshtomp/Swampert – Frog-like, but Swampert would be too big for most.
    • Treecko/Grovyle/Sceptile – Lizard-like, but Sceptile would be exotic and fast.
    • Ekans/Arbok – Snake-like, but Arbok would be too large and intimidating.
    • Sandshrew/Sandslash – Armadillo-like, but Sandslash would be spiky and wild.
    • Dratini/Dragonair/Dragonite – Dragon-like, but extremely rare and expensive.

    Bird-Like Pokémon (Exotic Avian Pets)

    • Chikorita/Bayleef/Meganium – Plant-based, but Meganium would be too large.
    • Totodile/Croconaw/Feraligatr – Crocodile-like, but Feraligatr would be dangerous.
    • Hoothoot/Noctowl – Owl-like, but Noctowl would be for experienced owners.
    • Doduo/Dodrio – Flightless bird-like, but Dodrio would be aggressive.
    • Spearow/Fearow – Hawk-like, but Fearow would be too wild.

    Aquatic Pokémon (Exotic Fish/Reptiles)

    • Magikarp/Gyarados – Magikarp is cheap, but Gyarados would be a luxury pet.
    • Feebas/Milotic – Feebas is ugly, but Milotic is beautiful and rare.
    • Corphish/Crawdaunt – Crab-like, but Crawdaunt would be aggressive.
    • Carvanha/Sharpedo – Shark-like, but Sharpedo would be too dangerous.

    Who Would Buy These?

    • Wealthy collectors (Charizard, Dragonite, Milotic).
    • Trainers looking for rare breeds (Ninetales, Arcanine, Feraligatr).
    • Exotic pet enthusiasts (Sceptile, Sandslash, Dodrio).
    • People who want "dragon" pets (Dratini line, Charizard).

    Final Thoughts:

    • Pet shops = Eevee, Skitty, Togepi, Magikarp, etc.
    • Specialized breeders = Growlithe, Vulpix, Charmander, Mudkip, etc.
    • Extremely rare/exotic = Charizard, Dragonite, Milotic, etc.

    Would you adopt any of these exotic Pokémon? 😊

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.