Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-pro-preview-05-06· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

using AAA = abova<CommonResultType, sizeP> template<typename T> void nucdfgsfdg()…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with grok-3-preview-02-24’s answer.
  1. User

    using AAA = abova<CommonResultType, sizeP>

    template void nucdfgsfdg() requires { T is AAA } C++20 AAA is template<typename, size_t>

    I would want use same_as

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, let's break this down.

    Your using AAA = abova<CommonResultType, sizeP>; line declares AAA as a specific type alias. It's not an alias template itself. abova is the class template.

    So, AAA refers to one specific instantiation of abova (e.g., abova<int, 10> if CommonResultType is int and sizeP is 10).

    To constrain T to be exactly this type AAA, you can use std::same_as directly.

    Here's how it would look:

    #include <concepts> // For std::same_as
    #include <cstddef>  // For size_t
    #include <iostream> // For demonstration
    
    // 0. Define CommonResultType and sizeP (so AAA can be defined)
    //    These must be known at the point AAA is defined.
    using CommonResultType = int;
    constexpr size_t sizeP = 5;
    
    // 1. Define the class template 'abova'
    template<typename ResType, size_t P>
    struct abova {
        ResType data[P];
        // Example member function
        void print_info() const {
            std::cout << "Instance of abova<";
            // A bit tricky to print template arguments' types nicely without RTTI or more TMP
            if constexpr (std::is_same_v<ResType, int>) std::cout << "int";
            else if constexpr (std::is_same_v<ResType, double>) std::cout << "double";
            else std::cout << "SomeType";
            std::cout << ", " << P << ">\n";
        }
    };
    
    // 2. Define the type alias 'AAA'
    //    AAA is now a concrete type, e.g., abova<int, 5>
    using AAA = abova<CommonResultType, sizeP>;
    
    // 3. Define the constrained function using std::same_as
    template<typename T>
    void nucdfgsfdg() requires std::same_as<T, AAA>
    {
        std::cout << "nucdfgsfdg called with T that is same_as AAA." << std::endl;
        T instance; // We can create an instance of T
        instance.print_info();
    }
    
    // Alternative C++20 concept syntax (more verbose for this simple case)
    template<typename T>
    concept IsExactlyAAA = std::same_as<T, AAA>;
    
    template<typename T>
    void nucdfgsfdg_v2() requires IsExactlyAAA<T> // or just IsExactlyAAA
    {
        std::cout << "nucdfgsfdg_v2 called with T that is IsExactlyAAA." << std::endl;
        T instance;
        instance.print_info();
    }
    
    
    int main() {
        // This will compile because AAA is indeed abova<CommonResultType, sizeP>
        nucdfgsfdg<AAA>();
        nucdfgsfdg_v2<AAA>();
    
        // This will also compile because abova<int, 5> is the same type as AAA (given our definitions)
        nucdfgsfdg<abova<int, 5>>();
        nucdfgsfdg_v2<abova<int, 5>>();
    
    
        // These would fail to compile (if uncommented) because T is not AAA:
        // using OtherType = abova<double, sizeP>;
        // nucdfgsfdg<OtherType>(); // Error: OtherType is not AAA (abova<double, 5> vs abova<int, 5>)
    
        // using AnotherType = abova<CommonResultType, sizeP + 1>;
        // nucdfgsfdg<AnotherType>(); // Error: AnotherType is not AAA (abova<int, 6> vs abova<int, 5>)
    
        // nucdfgsfdg<int>(); // Error: int is not AAA
    
        return 0;
    }
    

    Explanation:

    1. CommonResultType and sizeP: These must be defined before using AAA = ... for AAA to become a valid type alias. I've provided example definitions.
    2. abova: This is your class template.
    3. using AAA = abova<CommonResultType, sizeP>;:
      • This creates AAA as an alias for a specific instantiation of abova.
      • If CommonResultType is int and sizeP is 5, then AAA is simply another name for the type abova<int, 5>.
    4. requires std::same_as<T, AAA>:
      • This C++20 constraint checks if the template argument T is the exact same type as AAA.
      • std::same_as<Type1, Type2> is true if Type1 and Type2 are the same type (ignoring cv-qualifiers at the top level, but AAA has none here, and T is usually deduced without them unless specified).

    Important Distinction: Alias for a specific type vs. Alias template

    What you have: using AAA = abova<CommonResultType, sizeP>; This makes AAA a type alias. AAA is a specific type.

    If you wanted AAA to be an alias template (which it seems your description "AAA is template<typename, size_t>" might have been aiming for, though your using statement doesn't do that), it would be:

    template<typename U, size_t S>
    using AAATemplate = abova<U, S>;
    

    In this case, AAATemplate is not a type itself, but a "recipe" to make types. AAATemplate<int, 10> would be a type.

    If you wanted to check if T is any specialization of abova, you'd need a different kind of concept:

    // Concept to check if T is any specialization of abova
    template<typename T>
    struct is_specialization_of_abova : std::false_type {};
    
    template<typename ResType, size_t P>
    struct is_specialization_of_abova<abova<ResType, P>> : std::true_type {};
    
    template<typename T>
    concept IsAbova = is_specialization_of_abova<T>::value;
    
    template<typename T>
    void some_func() requires IsAbova<T> { /* T is some abova<_,_> */ }
    
    // Test
    // some_func<abova<int, 10>>(); // OK
    // some_func<abova<double, 20>>(); // OK
    // some_func<int>(); // Error
    

    But your initial request T is AAA where AAA is abova<CommonResultType, sizeP> strongly points to std::same_as<T, AAA> being the correct interpretation.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.