Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwen-max-2025-01-25· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

I am looking for lightweight Linux desktop environment that can create workspaces…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Amazon Novaamazon.nova-pro-v1:0’s answer.
  1. User

    I am looking for lightweight Linux desktop environment that can create workspaces stacked vertically (as opposed to usual horizontal multi-workspace), AND can switch workspaces using mouse move to the border of the screen (specifically, top and bottom borders of the screen). I am talking about workspaces (viewports), NOT virtual desktops. Please double-check that desktop environment in your list really provides such functionality

  2. Qwen Assistant

    To address your requirements, let's break down the key points and analyze potential solutions:

    Key Requirements:

    1. Lightweight Linux Desktop Environment: You need a desktop environment that is resource-efficient.
    2. Vertical Workspaces (Viewports): The workspaces should be stacked vertically, not horizontally.
    3. Mouse Border Actions for Workspace Switching: Moving the mouse to the top or bottom border of the screen should trigger workspace switching.

    Clarifications:

    • Workspaces vs. Virtual Desktops: Workspaces (or viewports) are typically a continuous grid where the screen moves to a new "view" within the same desktop. Virtual desktops, on the other hand, are entirely separate desktop environments. Your emphasis is on workspaces.
    • Mouse Triggered Switching: This feature is often referred to as "edge flipping" or "hot corners/edges."

    Analysis of Potential Desktop Environments:

    After reviewing various lightweight desktop environments, here are the most promising options that meet your criteria:


    1. Xfce with Custom Configuration

    • Why Xfce?

      • Xfce is lightweight and highly customizable.
      • It supports workspaces (viewports) and allows vertical stacking through configuration.
    • How to Meet Your Requirements:

      • Vertical Workspaces: By default, Xfce arranges workspaces in a horizontal grid. However, you can configure it to use a vertical layout by modifying the workspace settings (xfwm4 window manager).
      • Mouse Border Actions: Install xfwm4 plugins or use tools like xbindkeys and xdotool to bind mouse movements at the top/bottom borders to workspace-switching commands.
    • Steps:

      1. Open Settings > Window Manager Tweaks > Workspaces.
      2. Set the workspace layout to a single column (e.g., 1x4 for 4 vertical workspaces).
      3. Use xbindkeys to bind mouse movements to wmctrl or xdotool commands for switching workspaces.
    • Limitations:

      • Requires manual setup and scripting for edge-triggered workspace switching.

    2. Openbox with Custom Scripting

    • Why Openbox?

      • Openbox is an extremely lightweight window manager that is highly configurable.
      • It supports workspaces and can be configured for vertical layouts.
    • How to Meet Your Requirements:

      • Vertical Workspaces: Openbox allows you to define workspace layouts in its rc.xml configuration file. You can set up a vertical stack by specifying the number of rows and columns.
      • Mouse Border Actions: Use tools like xbindkeys or wmutils to detect mouse movements at the screen edges and execute workspace-switching commands.
    • Steps:

      1. Edit ~/.config/openbox/rc.xml to define a vertical workspace layout.
      2. Use xbindkeys to bind mouse movements to wmctrl or xdotool commands for switching workspaces.
    • Limitations:

      • Requires significant manual configuration and scripting.

    3. i3wm (Tiling Window Manager)

    • Why i3wm?

      • i3wm is a lightweight tiling window manager that supports workspaces.
      • It is highly customizable and can be configured for vertical workspace switching.
    • How to Meet Your Requirements:

      • Vertical Workspaces: i3wm uses numbered workspaces, which can be arranged conceptually as vertical stacks.
      • Mouse Border Actions: Use tools like i3bar, xbindkeys, or custom scripts to detect mouse movements at the top/bottom borders and switch workspaces.
    • Steps:

      1. Configure ~/.config/i3/config to assign workspaces to specific numbers.
      2. Use xbindkeys or xdotool to bind mouse movements to workspace-switching commands.
    • Limitations:

      • Not a traditional desktop environment; requires familiarity with tiling window managers.

    4. Compiz (with Lightweight Desktop)

    • Why Compiz?

      • Compiz is a compositing window manager that supports advanced workspace features, including vertical layouts.
      • It can be paired with lightweight desktop environments like LXDE or LXQt.
    • How to Meet Your Requirements:

      • Vertical Workspaces: Compiz allows you to configure workspace layouts, including vertical stacking.
      • Mouse Border Actions: Compiz has built-in support for edge flipping, which can be configured to switch workspaces when the mouse reaches the top or bottom border.
    • Steps:

      1. Install Compiz and configure it to use a vertical workspace layout.
      2. Enable edge flipping in the Compiz settings manager.
    • Limitations:

      • Compiz is resource-intensive compared to other lightweight options.

    Recommendation:

    Based on your requirements, Xfce with custom configuration is the most practical solution. It strikes a balance between lightweight performance and ease of customization. While it requires some manual setup for edge-triggered workspace switching, it provides the flexibility to achieve your desired functionality.

    If you are comfortable with more advanced configurations, Openbox or i3wm are excellent alternatives.

    Final Note:

    Before proceeding, ensure that your system supports the necessary tools (xbindkeys, xdotool, etc.) and test the configurations thoroughly to confirm they meet your expectations. If you need detailed instructions for setting up any of these environments, feel free to ask!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.