Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o3-mini· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Which regions in the world want independence or autonomy the most?

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with grok-4-0709’s answer.
  1. User

    Which regions in the world want independence or autonomy the most?

  2. Assistant

    Determining which regions “want independence or autonomy the most” is complex. Movements for greater self-governance, autonomy, or outright independence tend to emerge from long histories of cultural, linguistic, economic, or political differences with the controlling state. In addition, levels of support can fluctuate over time depending on current political, economic, and security conditions. That said, several regions are frequently mentioned in public discourse and research as having particularly strong—and sometimes longstanding—movements for increased autonomy or independence. Here are some notable examples, along with a brief explanation of their contexts:


    1. Catalonia (Spain)

    • Context:

      • Catalonia has a distinct language and culture, and many Catalans argue that they contribute more economically to Spain than they receive in return.
      • Movements for independence have led to organized referenda (most of which have not been legally recognized by the Spanish government) and widespread protests.
    • Key Point:

      • The movement has mobilized large segments of the population, with significant public debates and considerable political activism centered around the issue.

    2. Scotland (United Kingdom)

    • Context:

      • Scotland has its own legal and education systems and a long history of distinct national identity.
      • A 2014 referendum on independence showed a sizeable minority supporting separation, and debates have continued over issues like the impact of Brexit.
    • Key Point:

      • The Scottish National Party (SNP) has used the issue of independence as a major part of its political agenda, maintaining independence as an important debate in Scottish and British politics.

    3. Kurdistan (Across parts of Turkey, Iraq, Syria, and Iran)

    • Context:

      • The Kurdish people are spread over several nation-states, and in many places they have faced cultural and political suppression.
      • In Iraq, the autonomous Kurdistan Regional Government has achieved a degree of self-governance and has even held referenda that overwhelmingly favored independence.
      • In Turkey, Syria, and Iran, Kurdish movements continue to struggle for recognition and rights.
    • Key Point:

      • The quest for an independent Kurdish state is one of the longest-running ethnic and national movements in the region, though it takes on very different forms in each country.

    4. Quebec (Canada)

    • Context:

      • Quebecers have a distinct French-speaking culture and legal system.
      • The province has seen several referenda in the past, and while votes have not led to secession, the debate over Quebec’s status remains vibrant in Canadian politics.
    • Key Point:

      • Deep-rooted historical, cultural, and political differences have kept the question of Quebec sovereignty alive for decades.

    5. Basque Country (Spain and France)

    • Context:

      • Like Catalonia, the Basque Country has its own language and a strong cultural identity.
      • There have been both political and, historically, militant efforts (e.g., by ETA in Spain) aimed at achieving either full independence or greater autonomy.
    • Key Point:

      • After decades of conflict in Spain, the movement has largely taken on a political and administrative character, with significant portions of the Basque population still valuing self-determination.

    6. Other Notable Cases

    • Taiwan:

      • Context: Taiwan operates like an independent country in many practical ways (its own government, military, and economy) despite the People’s Republic of China’s claims over it.
      • Key Point: The island’s status remains one of the most sensitive geopolitical issues in East Asia.
    • Western Sahara:

      • Context: The Sahrawi people, led by the Polisario Front, seek independence from Morocco.
      • Key Point: The region’s political status is disputed, and it remains one of the longest-standing unresolved territorial issues post-colonialism.
    • Palestinian Territories:

      • Context: The Palestinian quest for an independent state has been at the heart of the Israeli–Palestinian conflict for decades.
      • Key Point: International diplomacy, negotiations, and conflict dynamics complicate the prospects for achieving full independence or recognized statehood.
    • Other Regions:

      • Areas like Flanders in Belgium, certain groups in India (e.g., in Kashmir), and parts of Tibet in China also have movements that call for greater autonomy or independence. These cases are highly context-specific and involve sensitive issues related to cultural identity, historical grievances, and political rights.

    A Few Important Considerations

    • Subjectivity and Dynamism:

      • Assessing “wanting independence the most” can vary based on the criteria you use: public opinion polls, historical context, or the intensity of political mobilization.
      • Political moods and economic conditions can change, meaning the strength and character of these movements can also shift over time.
    • Legal and International Recognition:

      • The extent to which independence is seen as legitimate (in the eyes of the central government or the international community) also affects the dynamics of these movements.
    • Diverse Approaches:

      • Some regions push for full independence, while others seek expanded autonomy within a federal or decentralized state structure. The goals can vary widely even within the same country.

    Conclusion

    While regions like Catalonia, Scotland, and the Kurdish areas (across multiple countries) are among the most frequently cited in discussions about self-determination, many other regions around the world also harbor strong feelings for independence or increased autonomy. The dynamics are inherently political, evolving, and deeply tied to a region’s unique history and socio-economic context.

    Because the intensity of such movements is a matter of ongoing debate and shifts with circumstances, any list should be seen as an illustration of prominent examples rather than a definitive ranking.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.