I need to write a grant proposal (under horizon-infra work programme). I can give an…
- User
I need to write a grant proposal (under horizon-infra work programme). I can give an ensemble of contextual files to generate few documents to start with :
- Summary document
- Pitch document
- Pitch presentation (quarto reveals)
- Call for interests/ideas/use cases.
What I need is :
- Provide the right prompt to get the best results
- Compare all existing LLM models (mai 2025) and their adequacy to the task
Assistant
Prompt for Generating Grant Proposal Documents
To get the best results for generating the required documents, you should provide a detailed and specific prompt. Here’s a structured prompt you can use:
Prompt for Generating Grant Proposal Documents:
Context:
- Program: Horizon-Infra Work Programme
- Objective: To secure funding for a research project focused on [specific research area, e.g., sustainable energy solutions, advanced materials, etc.]
- Target Audience: Grant reviewers and potential collaborators
Documents Required:
-
Summary Document:
- Brief overview of the project
- Key objectives and expected outcomes
- Significance and impact of the research
- Budget summary
-
Pitch Document:
- Detailed description of the project
- Background and rationale
- Methodology and approach
- Timeline and milestones
- Team qualifications and roles
- Expected outcomes and deliverables
- Potential risks and mitigation strategies
-
Pitch Presentation (Quarto Reveals):
- Slide deck format
- Key points from the pitch document
- Visual aids (charts, graphs, images)
- Engaging narrative flow
-
Call for Interests/Ideas/Use Cases:
- Introduction to the project and its goals
- Invitation for collaboration and contribution
- Specific areas where input is needed (e.g., use cases, technological integrations)
- Contact information and submission guidelines
Tone:
- Professional, persuasive, and collaborative
Style:
- Clear and concise
- Academic yet accessible
Additional Notes:
- Include relevant data, statistics, and references where applicable
- Highlight innovative aspects and unique selling points of the project
Comparison of Existing LLM Models (as of May 2025)
Here’s a comparison of some of the leading LLM models available as of May 2025, evaluating their adequacy for the task of generating grant proposal documents:
-
OpenAssistant (2025 version)
- Strengths:
- Highly customizable and adaptable to specific tasks
- Strong in generating coherent and contextually relevant text
- Excellent for creating detailed and structured documents
- Weaknesses:
- May require fine-tuning for optimal performance in niche areas
- Adequacy:
- Very suitable for generating all required documents with proper guidance and prompts
- Strengths:
-
Google Gemini Ultra
- Strengths:
- Advanced natural language understanding and generation
- Strong in creative and technical writing
- Excellent for producing high-quality, professional documents
- Weaknesses:
- Can be resource-intensive
- Adequacy:
- Highly adequate for creating polished and professional grant proposal documents
- Strengths:
-
Microsoft Azure OpenAI Service
- Strengths:
- Integration with enterprise tools and services
- Strong in generating business and technical documents
- Good for collaborative environments
- Weaknesses:
- May have higher costs associated with usage
- Adequacy:
- Suitable for generating comprehensive and enterprise-grade proposal documents
- Strengths:
-
Anthropic Claude 3
- Strengths:
- Focuses on safety and alignment with human values
- Strong in generating ethical and compliant text
- Good for detailed and nuanced writing
- Weaknesses:
- May be more conservative in creative aspects
- Adequacy:
- Adequate for generating ethical and compliant grant proposal documents
- Strengths:
-
Meta LLaMA 3
- Strengths:
- Open-source and highly customizable
- Strong in generating diverse types of text
- Good for experimental and innovative projects
- Weaknesses:
- May require significant fine-tuning for specific tasks
- Adequacy:
- Suitable for generating innovative and experimental grant proposal documents
- Strengths:
Recommendation
For the best results, OpenAssistant (2025 version) and Google Gemini Ultra are highly recommended due to their strong capabilities in generating detailed, professional, and contextually relevant text. These models can effectively handle the complexity and specificity required for grant proposal documents.
- User
compare the following for the task : TheBloke/Open_Gpt4_8x7B-GGUF, TheBloke/Open_Gpt4_8x7B_v0.2-GGUF, GPT4All-Community/Meta-Llama-3.1-8B-Instruct-128k-CGUF, maddes8cht/nomic-ai-gpt4all-falcon-gguf, TheBloke/airoboros-I2-13B-gpt4-1.4.1-GGUF, ChaoticNeutrals/mlm-filter-llava-llama-3-8B-gpt4v-mmproj-outdated, GPT4All-Community/DeepSeek-R1-Sistill-Llama-8B-GGUF,
Assistant
Certainly! Let's compare these models for the task of generating grant proposal documents. We'll evaluate them based on several criteria: model size, performance, customization, community support, and specific strengths.
1. TheBloke/Open_Gpt4_8x7B-GGUF
- Model Size: 8x7B parameters
- Performance: High performance in generating coherent and contextually relevant text
- Customization: Good level of customization through fine-tuning
- Community Support: Moderate, depending on TheBloke's community engagement
- Strengths: Strong in generating detailed and structured documents
2. TheBloke/Open_Gpt4_8x7B_v0.2-GGUF
- Model Size: 8x7B parameters
- Performance: Similar to the previous version with potential improvements
- Customization: Good level of customization
- Community Support: Moderate
- Strengths: Incremental improvements over the previous version
3. GPT4All-Community/Meta-Llama-3.1-8B-Instruct-128k-CGUF
- Model Size: 8B parameters
- Performance: High performance with a large context window (128k tokens)
- Customization: Good level of customization
- Community Support: Strong, backed by the GPT4All community
- Strengths: Excellent for long-form documents and detailed proposals
4. maddes8cht/nomic-ai-gpt4all-falcon-gguf
- Model Size: Varies (typically large)
- Performance: High performance, especially in technical and creative writing
- Customization: High level of customization
- Community Support: Moderate
- Strengths: Strong in generating innovative and creative text
5. TheBloke/airoboros-I2-13B-gpt4-1.4.1-GGUF
- Model Size: 13B parameters
- Performance: Very high performance in generating complex and detailed text
- Customization: Excellent level of customization
- Community Support: Moderate
- Strengths: Suitable for highly detailed and comprehensive grant proposals
6. ChaoticNeutrals/mlm-filter-llava-llama-3-8B-gpt4v-mmproj-outdated
- Model Size: 8B parameters
- Performance: High performance, though marked as outdated
- Customization: Good level of customization
- Community Support: Low, due to being outdated
- Strengths: Still capable of generating good quality text, but may not be the best choice for current tasks
7. GPT4All-Community/DeepSeek-R1-Sistill-Llama-8B-GGUF
- Model Size: 8B parameters
- Performance: High performance in generating professional and technical text
- Customization: Good level of customization
- Community Support: Strong, backed by the GPT4All community
- Strengths: Excellent for generating professional and enterprise-grade documents
Recommendation
For the task of generating grant proposal documents, the following models are particularly strong candidates:
- TheBloke/airoboros-I2-13B-gpt4-1.4.1-GGUF: Offers the highest parameter count and excellent customization, making it ideal for highly detailed proposals.
- GPT4All-Community/Meta-Llama-3.1-8B-Instruct-128k-CGUF: Provides a large context window and strong community support, suitable for long-form and detailed documents.
- GPT4All-Community/DeepSeek-R1-Sistill-Llama-8B-GGUF: Excellent for generating professional and enterprise-grade documents with strong community support.
These models offer a balance of performance, customization, and community support, making them well-suited for the task at hand.
- User
yes, for Meta-LLaMA 3.1’s 128k and for GPT4 style prompt
Assistant
Great! Let's focus on using the Meta-LLaMA 3.1 model with its 128k context window and craft a GPT-4 style prompt for generating the grant proposal documents.
GPT-4 Style Prompt for Meta-LLaMA 3.1
Context:
- Program: Horizon-Infra Work Programme
- Objective: To secure funding for a research project focused on [specific research area, e.g., sustainable energy solutions, advanced materials, etc.]
- Target Audience: Grant reviewers and potential collaborators
Documents Required:
-
Summary Document:
- Brief overview of the project
- Key objectives and expected outcomes
- Significance and impact of the research
- Budget summary
-
Pitch Document:
- Detailed description of the project
- Background and rationale
- Methodology and approach
- Timeline and milestones
- Team qualifications and roles
- Expected outcomes and deliverables
- Potential risks and mitigation strategies
-
Pitch Presentation (Quarto Reveals):
- Slide deck format
- Key points from the pitch document
- Visual aids (charts, graphs, images)
- Engaging narrative flow
-
Call for Interests/Ideas/Use Cases:
- Introduction to the project and its goals
- Invitation for collaboration and contribution
- Specific areas where input is needed (e.g., use cases, technological integrations)
- Contact information and submission guidelines
Tone:
- Professional, persuasive, and collaborative
Style:
- Clear and concise
- Academic yet accessible
Additional Notes:
- Include relevant data, statistics, and references where applicable
- Highlight innovative aspects and unique selling points of the project
Example Prompt for Meta-LLaMA 3.1
Prompt:
Generate the following grant proposal documents for a research project focused on sustainable energy solutions under the Horizon-Infra Work Programme:
-
Summary Document:
- Provide a brief overview of the project.
- Outline the key objectives and expected outcomes.
- Discuss the significance and impact of the research.
- Include a budget summary.
-
Pitch Document:
- Offer a detailed description of the project.
- Explain the background and rationale behind the research.
- Describe the methodology and approach to be used.
- Present a timeline with milestones.
- Detail the team qualifications and roles.
- List the expected outcomes and deliverables.
- Identify potential risks and propose mitigation strategies.
-
Pitch Presentation (Quarto Reveals):
- Create a slide deck in Quarto Reveals format.
- Include key points from the pitch document.
- Incorporate visual aids such as charts, graphs, and images.
- Ensure an engaging narrative flow throughout the presentation.
-
Call for Interests/Ideas/Use Cases:
- Introduce the project and its goals.
- Invite collaboration and contribution from potential partners.
- Specify areas where input is needed, such as use cases and technological integrations.
- Provide contact information and submission guidelines for interested parties.
Tone: Professional, persuasive, and collaborative
Style: Clear and concise, academic yet accessible
Additional Notes: Include relevant data, statistics, and references where applicable. Highlight innovative aspects and unique selling points of the project.
This prompt leverages the 128k context window of Meta-LLaMA 3.1 to ensure that all details are captured and maintained throughout the generation process.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.