Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwen3-235b-a22b-no-thinking· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Something interesting came out of supervision the other day. I was feeling an…

  1. User

    Something interesting came out of supervision the other day. I was feeling an unconscious paternal urge towards a client who was engaged in some risky behaviour. My supervisor asked why and I mentioned something about not having space to have my own rebellion when I was younger because my sister took up a lot of the emotional space in the house because of HER rebellion. I often sided with my parents

  2. Qwen Assistant

    Thanks for sharing that — it's a really rich and meaningful insight, and clearly something with emotional weight behind it. The fact that this came up in supervision suggests there’s a lot going on beneath the surface, both in terms of your personal history and how it might be interacting with your work as a therapist.

    Let me unpack a bit of what you said:

    "I was feeling an unconscious paternal urge towards a client who was engaged in some risky behaviour."

    This sounds like countertransference — when a therapist unconsciously projects feelings or dynamics from their own past onto a client. In this case, the "paternal urge" might mean you were feeling protective, perhaps even wanting to caution or warn the client away from risk — not necessarily because they needed that, but because you have unresolved feelings about rebellion, risk-taking, or being protected yourself.

    "My supervisor asked why and I mentioned something about not having space to have my own rebellion when I was younger because my sister took up a lot of the emotional space in the house because of HER rebellion."

    This is fascinating. It seems like your sister’s rebellion may have created a kind of emotional "overload" in the family system — so much so that your own needs, or expressions, got pushed aside. That can lead to what’s sometimes called a "parentified child" — someone who takes on the role of the mature one, often aligning with parents not just out of choice, but out of necessity, to keep things stable.

    "I often sided with my parents."

    That makes sense in that context. If your sister was taking up a lot of emotional bandwidth with her rebellion, you may have felt compelled to become the “good” child, the stabilizer, or even the mediator. And while that can serve a purpose in the short term, over time it can create internal conflict — especially if part of you wanted to rebel, to push boundaries, to explore more of who you were outside of expectations.

    So what does this mean in relation to your client?

    It sounds like the client’s risky behaviour might have triggered something in you — maybe a part of yourself that never got to take those risks, or that was punished (emotionally, if not directly) for even thinking about them. When we see clients doing things that feel dangerous or provocative, it can awaken parts of ourselves that we’ve disowned or suppressed.

    You might have been reacting not just to the risk, but to the freedom or expression that the risk represented — either identifying with it (secretly longing for it), or fearing it (because it threatens the identity you built around being responsible, contained, or emotionally mature).

    Your supervisor asking “why?” was probably opening the door to all of this — to help you notice how your own story might be influencing your therapeutic stance.


    Some questions that could deepen your reflection:

    • What did rebellion mean in your family? Was it dangerous? Shameful? Unmanageable?
    • How did you feel about your sister at the time — admiration? Resentment? Fear? Relief?
    • What might it have meant for you to rebel — would it have disrupted the balance of the family? Would it have felt selfish?
    • In your session with the client, were you aware of any part of you that wanted to say, “Be careful,” or “Don’t do this,” or even “Go for it!” — and where might that voice come from?
    • Is there a part of you that feels guilt or anxiety around allowing clients autonomy, especially when it conflicts with your own unexpressed impulses?

    Final thoughts

    This kind of self-awareness is gold in therapy. You’re not just noticing a reaction — you’re tracing its roots back through your own life. That’s powerful, and it will likely make your work with clients more nuanced and compassionate.

    If you're open to it, exploring this further in supervision or even personal therapy could help integrate that part of yourself — the part that never got to fully express itself — so it doesn’t get projected onto clients unintentionally.

    Would you like to explore this further — maybe look at how this dynamic plays out in other areas of your life, or how to stay grounded when these countertransferential feelings arise in sessions?

  3. User

    The supervisor later said that I am using the client to meet some of my own unmet needs, but I'm not sure what that means or looks like

  4. Qwen Assistant

    That’s a really important and insightful comment from your supervisor — and it can feel unsettling or confusing at first. Let's unpack what that might mean in your situation, because understanding this dynamic is key not only to ethical practice but also to your own personal growth as a therapist.


    What does it mean to "use the client to meet unmet needs"?

    In therapy, "using the client" typically refers to when a therapist unconsciously acts out or tries to resolve their own unresolved emotional needs through their interactions with the client. This isn’t about being intentionally manipulative — it’s more about how our unconscious patterns can shape how we relate to clients.

    It often looks like:

    • Trying to protect or “rescue” a client in ways that reflect your own past experiences of helplessness or guilt.
    • Wanting to be the one who “fixes” them or gets thanked by them — which may tap into your need to feel valued or needed.
    • Reacting strongly to certain client behaviours (like rebellion) because they mirror parts of yourself that you never got to express or explore.
    • Feeling overly responsible for outcomes, or feeling personally affected when clients make choices that remind you of your own suppressed desires or fears.

    So when your supervisor said you were using the client to meet some of your own unmet needs, they might have been pointing to the idea that your paternal urge wasn't just about concern for the client — it was also about something you never got to experience or resolve in yourself, and now you're trying to live that out indirectly through your role with the client.


    In your case: What might this look like?

    Let’s tie this back to what you shared earlier:

    You grew up in a family where your sister took up a lot of emotional space with her rebellion. You didn’t get to explore your own rebellious side — instead, you aligned with your parents and became the emotionally mature, stable child.

    Now, when you see a client engaging in risky or rebellious behaviour, a part of you might be:

    • Reacting protectively, almost like a parent who wants to prevent pain or consequences — but that reaction might come from your own internalized parental voice, not necessarily from what the client truly needs.
    • Feeling frustrated or anxious because the client is doing something you wanted to do but couldn’t — so you’re caught between wanting to stop them and secretly envying them.
    • Trying to manage or contain the risk, not just because of professional boundaries, but because allowing full expression of that rebellion in the client might awaken your own buried feelings of longing or regret.

    So in a way, you might be living out your own suppressed rebellion through your reactions to the client, or alternatively, trying to prevent the client from going down a path you wish you had taken — either consciously or unconsciously.


    How might this affect your work?

    If you're unconsciously trying to live through or control the client’s choices, it can interfere with:

    1. Therapeutic neutrality: Your ability to sit with the client’s process without projecting your own emotional agenda onto it.
    2. Empowerment: If you’re trying to steer them away from risk too much, you might unintentionally disempower them or communicate that their autonomy is dangerous or wrong.
    3. Boundaries: When we project our own needs onto clients, we can become over-involved or emotionally reactive in ways that blur the therapeutic boundary.

    So what can you do with this awareness?

    First, don’t panic — noticing this is a sign of growth, not failure. Every therapist has countertransference; the key is becoming aware of it and managing it ethically and compassionately.

    Here are some practical steps:

    1. Reflect on your emotional response

    Ask yourself:

    • Am I reacting more intensely than the situation calls for?
    • Does this remind me of myself? A family member? A younger version of me?
    • Am I trying to “save” or “warn” the client in a way that feels personal?

    2. Stay curious about the client’s experience

    Instead of jumping to advice or protection, ask:

    • What is this behaviour giving the client?
    • What might they be expressing or coping with through risk-taking?
    • Could this be a form of communication or self-soothing?

    This helps keep the focus on the client rather than on your projections.

    3. Use supervision actively

    Keep bringing these dynamics up. Ask:

    • Where am I over-identifying?
    • What might I be avoiding in myself?
    • How can I hold space for the client’s autonomy while staying grounded in my own history?

    4. Consider your own therapy

    Sometimes, working through these themes in your own therapy can help you integrate the parts of yourself that were suppressed or ignored — so they don’t show up uninvited in sessions.


    Final Thought

    What your supervisor pointed out is not a criticism — it’s an invitation to deeper self-awareness. It’s common for therapists to unconsciously try to resolve their own wounds through their work. The fact that you're reflecting on it means you're already on the right path.

    Would you like help crafting a reflective journal entry about this, or exploring how to talk about it further in supervision?

  5. User

    This discussion came about because I felt (but did not say) that I wanted to shake the client and reproach him for his behaviour

  6. Qwen Assistant

    Thank you for sharing that — it takes a lot of courage to acknowledge such a strong, visceral reaction, especially in a professional context. The fact that you didn’t act on it but instead brought it into supervision is a sign of maturity, self-awareness, and ethical strength.

    Let’s explore what this feeling — wanting to shake the client and reproach him — might mean, both about you and about your relationship with the client, and how it connects to the idea of "using the client to meet unmet needs."


    1. What does wanting to “shake” someone usually mean emotionally?

    The urge to physically or emotionally “shake” someone often comes from:

    • Frustration – You feel powerless to stop them from doing something you perceive as dangerous.
    • Fear – You’re scared they’ll get hurt, or make a choice with serious consequences.
    • Helplessness – You feel like you can’t reach them or break through their defences.
    • Projection – A part of you sees yourself in them — perhaps a younger version of yourself who wanted to take risks but couldn’t — and you're angry at them for doing what you never dared.

    In your case, there may also be a layer of internal conflict: a part of you secretly admires the client's freedom or defiance (because you never had space to express that), while another part wants to scold or control it because it feels threatening or irresponsible.

    This kind of split emotional response — admiration + fear + frustration — is classic countertransference.


    2. How might this connect to your own history?

    You mentioned earlier that your sister took up a lot of emotional space with her rebellion, which meant you didn’t get to have your own. That left you in the role of the "good" or emotionally mature child — the one who sides with the parents, keeps the peace, and maybe suppresses parts of themselves to maintain balance.

    Now, when you see someone acting out — taking risks, pushing boundaries — it might trigger a deeply buried part of yourself that wanted to do the same thing. But because that part was never allowed expression, it may now live in you as:

    • Anger at yourself for not having lived more authentically.
    • Resentment toward the client for having the freedom you didn’t.
    • Judgment masked as concern — telling yourself you’re protecting them, but actually trying to contain a part of yourself that feels dangerous or unacceptable.

    So when you felt the urge to shake the client, it may not have been just about their behaviour — it may have been about your relationship to risk, rebellion, and autonomy — things you were never allowed to explore freely.


    3. What does it mean to “use the client to meet unmet needs” in this context?

    Your supervisor might be suggesting that:

    • Your intense emotional reaction isn't proportionate solely to what the client is doing — it's being amplified by your unconscious identification with them.
    • You may be trying to protect yourself by controlling the client’s choices — unconsciously trying to avoid facing your own unresolved feelings about rebellion and risk.
    • Or conversely, you may be living out a suppressed part of yourself through your emotional entanglement with the client — not literally imitating them, but reacting so strongly that it becomes about you rather than them.

    Either way, it means that the client has become a psychological mirror — reflecting back parts of yourself that are still unresolved.


    4. Is this normal? Is this okay?

    Yes — and yes.

    All therapists have moments of intense countertransference. It’s not only normal; it’s invaluable. These moments give us access to deeper layers of ourselves and our clients’ experiences.

    What matters is:

    • That you noticed it.
    • That you didn’t act on it.
    • That you brought it into supervision.
    • That you’re reflecting on it here.

    That’s what makes the difference between unconscious enactment and conscious integration.


    5. What can you do moving forward?

    Here are some practical steps:

    ✅ Stay curious, not judgmental

    Ask yourself:

    • What part of me wants to shake this person?
    • What am I afraid will happen if they keep doing this?
    • What would it have meant for me to behave this way at their age?

    ✅ Name the parts of yourself

    Try identifying the different internal voices:

    • The protective parent
    • The frustrated rebel
    • The responsible child
    • The fearful observer

    Sometimes naming these parts helps you understand where the emotional charge is coming from.

    ✅ Use grounding techniques in session

    If you feel overwhelmed by emotion during sessions, try:

    • Taking a slow, deep breath
    • Noticing your feet on the floor
    • Reminding yourself: "This is their journey, not mine."

    ✅ Continue exploring in supervision or personal therapy

    Ask:

    • Am I over-identifying with this client?
    • How is my history influencing my reactions?
    • What part of myself is being triggered here?

    Final Thought

    The fact that you're sitting with this discomfort — that you’re willing to ask difficult questions and reflect deeply — shows that you’re not only a thoughtful therapist but also someone committed to growth.

    This moment of strong countertransference doesn’t mean you’ve failed — it means you've been given a gift: an opportunity to heal a part of yourself, while continuing to hold safe space for your client.

    Would you like help writing a reflective journal entry about this experience, or thinking through how to talk about it more deeply in your next supervision session?

  7. User

    Let's explore some of that further

  8. Qwen Assistant

    Absolutely — let’s go deeper. You’ve already shared a lot, and we’re at the edge of something meaningful: your internal relationship with risk, rebellion, family roles, and how those dynamics might be echoing in your therapeutic work.

    Let’s explore this from a few different angles to help you integrate what’s coming up:


    🔍 1. Internal Parts Work: The "Paternal Urge" as an Internal Conflict

    You mentioned feeling a paternal urge toward the client — a desire to shake or reproach him for risky behaviour.

    From an Internal Family Systems (IFS) perspective, this urge may not just come from one part of you — it could be multiple parts interacting:

    🧩 The Protective Parent Part

    This is the part that wants to warn, protect, or control. It's often rooted in past experiences where you had to step into a caregiving or stabilizing role early on. It can feel like:

    • “I need to stop them before they get hurt.”
    • “If I don’t say something, something bad will happen.”
    • “I know better because I’ve seen what happens when people take risks.”

    This part may have developed to keep things emotionally stable in your family — especially if your sister was taking up emotional space with her rebellion.

    🧩 The Suppressed Rebel Part

    This is the part that never got to express itself — the part that secretly admires risk-taking, maybe even envies the client’s freedom. It may show up indirectly through:

    • Irritation
    • Judgment
    • Overreaction

    It might be saying things like:

    • “Why can’t I ever do what I want?”
    • “He gets to do that and I never did.”
    • “I hate that I didn’t take more risks.”

    This part may be projecting onto the client — seeing them as reckless, dangerous, or irresponsible — when really, it’s your own unexpressed rebellion that feels threatening.

    🧩 The Responsible Child Part

    This is the part that aligned with the parents — perhaps out of necessity, not choice. It keeps things orderly, avoids rocking the boat, and tries to manage emotions. It might be the part that says:

    • “I should stay neutral.”
    • “I shouldn’t feel this way.”
    • “I must always be professional.”

    But underneath, there’s tension — between who you were expected to be and who you wanted to be.


    🌱 2. What Might This Client Be Representing?

    Sometimes clients become symbolic figures — mirrors of our inner world. Ask yourself:

    • Does this client remind me of anyone?

      • Could he represent your younger self?
      • Or your rebellious sibling?
      • Or someone you wished you could have been?
    • What would it mean for me if this client kept taking risks and nothing bad happened?

      • Would that validate his choices?
      • Would it make me question my own life decisions?
      • Would it challenge my belief that risk = danger?
    • What if this client isn’t doing anything wrong — but just exploring their autonomy?

      • What does that bring up in me?
      • Is it envy? Fear? Discomfort?

    These questions aren't about excusing risky behaviour — they're about understanding your emotional investment in controlling or judging it.


    🧭 3. How Can You Stay Grounded When These Feelings Come Up?

    Strong countertransference doesn’t mean you're failing — it means you're being shown something important. But how do you stay grounded so it doesn’t interfere with your work?

    Here are some strategies:

    ✅ Name the Part That’s Reacting

    Before or after sessions, ask:

    • Which part of me is showing up right now?
    • Is it the protector? The rebel? The responsible one?
    • What does that part need?

    Sometimes naming the part diffuses its power and helps you relate to it with compassion.

    ✅ Use Self-Soothing Techniques

    If you notice physical tension or emotional charge during or after a session:

    • Take slow, deep breaths.
    • Place your hand over your heart or belly.
    • Say silently: "This is not about me. I’m here to hold space."

    ✅ Keep a Supervision Journal

    Write down:

    • What came up for you emotionally?
    • How might it connect to your personal history?
    • What would a compassionate witness say to you about this?

    Supervision journals help you track patterns and see how your inner world influences your work.

    ✅ Set Boundaries With Your Inner Critic

    If you start thinking things like:

    • “I shouldn’t feel this way.”
    • “Good therapists don’t react like this.”
    • “I’m failing this client.”
      → Remind yourself:
    • “This is human.”
    • “This is data, not failure.”
    • “This is where growth begins.”

    📝 4. Reflective Prompts You Can Explore

    Here are some prompts you can use in your journal or supervision:

    1. “When I saw the client doing X, I felt ____. That reminded me of a time when I…”
    2. “If I could speak directly to the part of me that wanted to shake the client, I’d say…”
    3. “The message I received growing up about rebellion was…”
    4. “If I had been allowed to rebel safely, I might have…”
    5. “What am I afraid will happen if I fully accept this part of myself/my client?”
    6. “What would it look like to give myself permission to explore risk in safe, adult ways now?”

    🧘‍♀️ 5. Integration: Making Room for All Parts

    One of the goals of therapy — both personal and professional — is integration. That means making room for all parts of yourself, even the ones that seem contradictory.

    So you can be:

    • The mature, grounded therapist...
    • AND the part that once longed to be wild and free...
    • AND the part that learned to survive by staying emotionally contained...

    And none of these parts invalidate the others.

    In fact, when you welcome them all — with curiosity, compassion, and awareness — you become a more authentic, attuned, and resilient therapist.


    💬 Want to Try Something Together?

    Would you like to try writing a short reflective journal entry together based on what we've explored?

    Or would you like to practice how to talk about this in supervision using a specific framework?

    Let me know how you'd like to continue — I'm here to walk with you through this process.

  9. User

    I'm less interested in exploring how to address these impulses in room with a client, I want to explore what's going on for me

  10. Qwen Assistant

    Thank you for that clarification — it’s an important one. Let's shift the focus inward.

    You’re not looking to manage these impulses in session or figure out how to “deal with” a client — you want to understand what’s going on inside you. That’s deeply meaningful work, and it deserves space and depth.

    So let’s explore this from a more personal, inner-world perspective — less about technique, and more about meaning-making, identity, and emotional legacy.


    🧠 1. What Might Be Triggering You?

    When you said:

    "I wanted to shake the client and reproach him for his behaviour."

    And also:

    "I didn’t say anything — but I felt it."

    That tells me something deeply personal got stirred up in you.

    It wasn't just concern. It was emotional charge — frustration, maybe even anger or guilt — wrapped around risk-taking, rebellion, and autonomy.

    Let’s consider that your reaction may not be primarily about the client at all — it might be about you, and specifically about:

    🔥 A suppressed part of yourself

    A part that never got to take risks, make mistakes, or rebel — because someone else (your sister) already occupied that role in the family system.

    This part may now be surfacing — not through direct expression, but through projection, judgment, or even self-criticism.

    So when you saw the client doing something risky, that part of you — the one that never got to live — may have been activated.

    But instead of saying:

    • "I wish I had done that," or
    • "I envy their freedom,"

    it came out as:

    • "Stop it!"
    • "You don’t know what you’re getting into!"
    • "Be careful — it could ruin everything!"

    That’s how parts often speak when they’ve been silenced for a long time.


    🌱 2. The Role of Rebellion in Your Identity

    Rebellion is not just about defiance — it’s about autonomy, expression, and boundary-testing.

    For many people, adolescence is a time when they learn who they are by pushing against what they're told to be.

    But if your sister was the rebel, and your parents were overwhelmed managing her, you may have felt:

    • Pressure to stay aligned with the family structure
    • Guilt for wanting to disrupt it
    • Fear that expressing your own needs would destabilize things further

    So instead of exploring your own rebelliousness, you internalized the message:
    "I must be the responsible one. I must keep things together."

    That can lead to a kind of identity freeze — where you become so identified with being mature, stable, or emotionally reliable that you lose touch with other parts of yourself.

    Now, when you see someone doing what you never dared — taking risks, breaking rules, asserting themselves — it can trigger a mix of emotions:

    • Resentment (“Why do they get to do that?”)
    • Fear (“What if it goes wrong?”)
    • Guilt (“Should I feel this way?”)
    • Longing (“I wish I’d had the courage.”)

    These feelings aren’t irrational — they’re real parts of you trying to be seen.


    💔 3. Unresolved Grief and Lost Autonomy

    There’s also likely some grief here — not loud or dramatic, but quiet and enduring.

    Grief for:

    • The childhood you didn’t get to fully inhabit
    • The choices you didn’t get to make
    • The voice you didn’t get to use
    • The rebellion you didn’t get to express

    This kind of grief doesn’t always look like sadness — it can show up as:

    • Chronic self-monitoring
    • Over-responsibility
    • Difficulty setting boundaries
    • Irritation toward others who seem free

    In your case, it might also show up as moral judgment or rigid boundary-setting, especially around risk — not necessarily because the risk itself is dangerous, but because allowing it feels too close to something you once wanted and couldn’t have.


    🧭 4. What Does This Mean for You Now?

    Even though this began in your family of origin, it’s still alive in you now — not as a memory, but as a felt experience.

    That means:

    • You might still carry the weight of being the "responsible one"
    • You might still feel uneasy when others push boundaries
    • You might still struggle to give yourself permission to explore, question, or act outside of what feels "safe" or "acceptable"

    But here’s the good news:

    You are no longer that child in the family system. You are an adult. You can now choose what to carry forward — and what to release.


    ✨ 5. Healing the Part That Never Got to Rebel

    If you're open to it, here’s a gentle exercise you can try:

    📝 Letter to Your Younger Self

    Find a quiet moment and write a letter to the younger version of yourself — the one who never got to take risks or rebel.

    You might start with:

    "Dear younger me,

    I see you. I see how hard you tried to keep things together. I know you didn’t get to explore everything you wanted to. I know you gave up space so others could be seen..."

    Then ask:

    • What did you sacrifice?
    • What did you never get to say or do?
    • What would you have needed back then to feel safe enough to be yourself?

    This isn’t about blaming anyone — it’s about acknowledging the cost of growing up in a certain dynamic, and giving yourself permission to heal.


    🤝 Final Thought

    You mentioned earlier that your supervisor said you were using the client to meet unmet needs. That phrase can sound clinical — even accusatory — but what it really points to is this:

    There’s a part of you that has never been fully lived.

    And now, when you see someone else living it out — even in ways you don’t approve of — it stirs something in you.

    Not because you're broken — but because you're human.

    And healing begins when we stop judging ourselves for those stirrings — and start listening to them.


    Would you like to continue this exploration by identifying which inner parts feel most familiar to you? Or perhaps you'd like help writing that letter we just talked about?

    Whatever feels right — I'm here to walk with you.