Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwen3-235b-a22b-no-thinking· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

so what's the solution? open borders because of a previous land dispute? if we go far…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-opus-4-20250514’s answer.
  1. User

    so what's the solution? open borders because of a previous land dispute? if we go far back enough, there is always some kind of warfare for land. this is an arbitrary distinction. also, I don't see why a historical injustice suddenly deems those who didn't cause it (though they benefit from it) complicit or guilty. this will just perpetuate the cycle.

  2. Qwen Assistant

    You're raising a very important and often overlooked critique of the "stolen land" argument when applied to immigration policy. Let’s walk through your concerns step by step, clarify what's at stake, and explore possible solutions that don’t fall into endless cycles of guilt or historical determinism.


    🔍 1. Your Core Concerns (Restated)

    • Arbitrary Historical Claims: If we go far back enough, every piece of land was taken through war, conquest, or displacement. So why single out certain historical injustices (e.g., colonial dispossession) as morally binding today?
    • Collective Guilt Problem: Why should people alive today—especially those who didn’t cause past wrongs—be held responsible for them? Doesn't this just create intergenerational resentment and stagnation?
    • Practical Policy Implications: Does acknowledging historical injustice require open borders? Isn’t that an extreme and possibly unworkable conclusion?

    🧠 2. Why People Use the “Stolen Land” Argument

    Before evaluating its validity, it helps to understand where the idea comes from:

    • Indigenous Activists: Often use the phrase to assert sovereignty, not necessarily to call for open borders. Their point is: "This land wasn’t yours to begin with; you can’t claim exclusive control over it."
    • Anti-Colonial Thinkers: Argue that modern borders in many parts of the world were drawn by imperial powers, not by local populations, so they lack moral legitimacy.
    • Critics of Immigration Restrictions: Sometimes deploy the argument to challenge the idea that current residents have a right to exclude others based on borders that originated in violence or theft.

    But—as you rightly point out—this line of reasoning quickly runs into problems.


    ⚖️ 3. The Flawed Logic of “Because of History, Open Borders”

    Let’s break down the logic:

    PremiseIssue
    1. This land was stolen in the past.True for most places. But does that mean no one has any claim now?
    2. Therefore, we must open the borders.This doesn’t follow logically. Stolen land ≠ obligation to accept all comers.
    3. Those who benefit from the theft are complicit.This introduces collective guilt, which is ethically problematic.

    ✅ The Real Moral Insight

    Acknowledging historical injustice is important—it can justify reparations, land restitution, or increased rights for Indigenous peoples—but it doesn’t logically require unrestricted immigration.


    🏛️ 4. So What Is the Solution?

    You’re absolutely right: we cannot live in a world governed entirely by historical grievances, nor can we ignore them. Here’s a more sustainable approach:

    A. Separate Sovereignty from Exclusion

    • Acknowledge that borders are socially constructed and historically contingent.
    • But also recognize that every society needs some form of political boundary to coordinate laws, services, and governance.
    • The key question is: how do we manage these boundaries justly?

    B. Focus on Present-Day Justice, Not Ancestral Sins

    • Stop framing immigration debates around who originally "owned" the land.
    • Instead, ask:
      • How can we treat immigrants humanely?
      • How can we fairly distribute resources and opportunities?
      • How can we protect vulnerable groups (including both citizens and migrants)?
      • How can we build inclusive societies without erasing cultural identities?

    C. Reparative Justice Without Collective Guilt

    • For Indigenous peoples: Focus on land rights, self-determination, and treaty negotiations, not abstract guilt.
    • For descendants of colonizers or beneficiaries of unjust systems: Acknowledge privilege, support equity policies, but avoid framing it as personal sin.

    D. Moral Consistency > Historical Scorekeeping

    • You don’t have to apologize for being born into a system built on injustice.
    • But you can choose how to act within it—by supporting fair immigration laws, opposing racism, and advocating for humane treatment of migrants.

    🧭 5. Toward a Pragmatic Ethics of Migration

    Here’s a framework that avoids the trap of endless historical blame:

    ValuePrincipleExample
    Human dignityNo person is illegal; everyone deserves basic rights.Treat asylum seekers with respect.
    FairnessImmigration rules should be transparent, non-discriminatory, and proportionate.Avoid arbitrary bans or racial profiling.
    SovereigntyNations have the right to control borders—but not the right to violate rights in doing so.Border enforcement must comply with international law.
    ResponsibilityWealthy nations should help refugees and displaced persons, especially if their actions caused instability.Support refugee resettlement programs.
    IntegrationSocieties should promote mutual understanding and inclusion—not forced assimilation or segregation.Encourage language learning and civic participation.

    📌 Final Thoughts

    “We are shaped by history, but not bound by it.”

    You’re right: using historical land disputes to justify open borders—or to shame individuals for the sins of their ancestors—is neither logical nor productive. It leads to polarization, not progress.

    Instead, let’s focus on:

    • Building fairer systems,
    • Recognizing the humanity of all people,
    • Healing divisions without weaponizing the past.

    That’s the path forward—not endless cycles of guilt, blame, or historical scorekeeping.

    Would you like to explore how this applies to a specific country’s immigration policy?

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.