this a prompt I made to have ai models act as a writing assistant for me break down some…
- User
this a prompt I made to have ai models act as a writing assistant for me break down some weaknesses in the prompt
AI Prompt: Personal Statement / Supplement Editing (A2C + College Essay Guy-Informed) You're an expert college admissions essay coach trained on the best practices from r/ApplyingToCollege (A2C), the College Essay Guy, and Ivy League admissions offices. I will paste an excerpt of my college essay below.
Your goal is to refine what I’ve already written while:
Preserving my unique voice and personal storytelling style
Editing only where needed for clarity, flow, word economy, and emotional resonance
Making sure my essay avoids "AI tells" (e.g., generic phrases like “this experience taught me,” overly formal language, or fake emotional arcs)
Aligning my writing with top A2C essay principles, like: — "Show, don’t tell" — Specificity over generality — Grounding in anecdote and reflection — Honest, vulnerable, and authentic tone — Intellectual curiosity and character-driven insight
If the essay is for a specific school or platform (like Common App, QuestBridge, or a “Why Us” supplement), subtly align the tone, structure, or content to reflect what that school/platform tends to favor, based on common consensus from students, admissions officers, and writing advisors.
🔍 If my writing doesn't clearly answer the prompt or could better address what the school is asking for, gently revise it to improve relevance without losing my original ideas or style.
❌ Do not add clichés, overexplain, or “sanitize” it into a generic essay.
✅ Keep it real, thoughtful, compelling, and clearly mine — just the best version of what I already wrote.
When ready, I’ll paste in my writing.
Assistant
Looking at your prompt, you've created something quite comprehensive that shows solid understanding of college essay principles. Here are the main weaknesses I see:
Length and cognitive load: The prompt is quite dense with multiple competing priorities. AI models (and humans) can struggle when given too many simultaneous constraints. You might get better results by streamlining to 3-4 core priorities.
Contradictory instructions: You're asking to both "preserve unique voice" and "align with what schools favor," which can pull in opposite directions. There's also tension between "editing only where needed" and the extensive list of improvements requested.
Vague success criteria: Terms like "emotional resonance," "authentic tone," and "best version" are subjective and hard for an AI to operationalize consistently. More concrete guidance would help.
Over-reliance on AI capabilities: The prompt assumes AI can reliably detect "unique voice," identify "AI tells" in human writing, and understand nuanced differences between what different schools prefer. These are sophisticated judgment calls that AI often struggles with.
Missing practical elements: No word count guidance, no upfront context about the specific prompt being addressed, and no examples of what good vs. problematic edits look like.
Potential for over-editing: With so many criteria listed, you risk getting heavy revisions that lose the authentic student voice you want to preserve.
A stronger approach might be to pick 2-3 top priorities, provide concrete examples, and consider breaking complex tasks into multiple rounds rather than trying to accomplish everything at once.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.