I'm familiar with how backpropagation works in MLPs. Could you please explain how it…
- User
I'm familiar with how backpropagation works in MLPs. Could you please explain how it works in a transformer, from output to the embbedded vector imputs?
- Assistant
I'll walk through backpropagation in a transformer step by step, starting from the output and working backwards.
- Output Layer to Feed-Forward Network
- Similar to MLPs, we start with the loss gradient at the output
- This flows back through the final linear layer and activation function
- The feed-forward network (FFN) follows standard backprop through its two linear transformations and activation function
- FFN to Multi-Head Attention
- The gradients flow back to the multi-head attention block
- For each attention head:
- Gradients flow through the linear projection back to Q, K, V matrices
- The attention softmax gradient is computed using the chain rule
- Key point: The attention weights act like a dynamic routing mechanism, so gradients flow proportionally to how much each token attended to others
- Through Multiple Transformer Layers
- This process repeats for each transformer block
- Layer normalization gradients are computed for each sub-layer
- Residual connections mean gradients can flow directly backward, helping with the vanishing gradient problem
- Position-wise Operations
- Gradients flow through positional encodings
- If using learned positional embeddings, these get updated
- If using fixed sinusoidal encodings, gradients pass through unchanged
- Back to Input Embeddings
- Finally reaches the token embedding layer
- Gradients accumulate for each occurrence of a token across the sequence
- The embedding matrix is updated based on these accumulated gradients
Would you like me to elaborate on any of these steps? I find the attention mechanism's gradient flow particularly interesting since it's quite different from traditional neural networks.
- User
Could you please explain backpropagation through the attention mechanism of a decoder-only transformer including the mathematical formulation. Explain any differences between backpropagation through Queries and Keys.
- Assistant
I'll walk through the mathematical formulation of backpropagation through the attention mechanism in a decoder-only transformer.
Starting with the forward pass attention formula:
Attention(Q,K,V) = softmax(QK^T/√d_k)VLet's call A = softmax(QK^T/√d_k) for brevity. The gradient needs to flow back through Q, K, and V.
For a given loss L, we first get ∂L/∂A (gradient with respect to attention outputs). Then:
- Gradient with respect to V:
∂L/∂V = A^T * (∂L/∂A)- Gradient with respect to attention scores (pre-softmax):
∂L/∂(QK^T/√d_k) = ∂L/∂A ⊙ [A - A ⊙ A^T]Where ⊙ represents element-wise multiplication.
- Key difference between Q and K gradients:
∂L/∂Q = (∂L/∂(QK^T/√d_k)) * K / √d_k ∂L/∂K = (∂L/∂(QK^T/√d_k))^T * Q / √d_kThe crucial differences between Q and K gradients are:
- K gradient uses the transpose of the attention score gradients
- In decoder-only transformers, K can only attend to previous tokens (causal masking)
- The causal mask means gradients for future positions are zeroed out in K
- Q gradients maintain the original sequence ordering
- The scaling factor √d_k affects both equally
Would you like me to elaborate on how the causal masking specifically affects the gradient computation?
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.