Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-flash· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

i need an STRUCURED TEXT PLC Lagugae function block that uses an 2d look up table to…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Metallama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct’s answer.
  1. User

    i need an STRUCURED TEXT PLC Lagugae function block that uses an 2d look up table to controll 1 output . i has 3 inputs , 1 for x , 1 for y and one for the 2d array. and 1 output for the interpolatet value

  2. Gemini Assistant

    This is a common and very useful function block in industrial automation. We'll implement a bilinear interpolation algorithm, which is the standard for 2D linear interpolation.

    First, we need to define a User Defined Type (UDT) for our 2D lookup table. This UDT will hold the X-axis points, Y-axis points, and the corresponding Z-values (the actual output values). Since arrays in Structured Text often require fixed dimensions, we'll define a maximum size and then use NumXPoints and NumYPoints to specify the actual number of active points in the table.


    1. Define the User Defined Type (UDT)

    Let's call this UDT ST_2D_LookupTable. You would define this in your PLC's "Data Types" or "UDTs" section.

    TYPE ST_2D_LookupTable :
    STRUCT
        // Max dimensions for the table. Adjust these based on your largest expected table size.
        // Ensure these are sufficiently large.
        // For example, if your largest table is 50x50, set MAX_X_POINTS to 50 and MAX_Y_POINTS to 50.
        // We use 0-indexing for easier array access.
        X_Points    : ARRAY[0..99] OF REAL; // X-axis values (must be monotonically increasing)
        Y_Points    : ARRAY[0..99] OF REAL; // Y-axis values (must be monotonically increasing)
        Z_Values    : ARRAY[0..99, 0..99] OF REAL; // Z-values at [Y_index, X_index]
    
        // Actual number of points used in the table.
        // Must be at least 2 for interpolation.
        NumXPoints  : INT;
        NumYPoints  : INT;
    END_STRUCT
    END_TYPE
    

    Important Notes for the UDT:

    • MAX_X_POINTS and MAX_Y_POINTS: Set these according to the maximum size of any lookup table you expect to use. If you need larger tables, increase these values.
    • Monotonically Increasing: The X_Points and Y_Points arrays must contain values that are strictly increasing (e.g., X_Points[0] < X_Points[1] < ...). The function block will check this to some extent, but good data entry is crucial.
    • 0-Indexing: The arrays are defined with 0-indexing (0..MAX-1). This is common in programming and often simpler.

    2. The Structured Text (ST) Function Block

    Now, here's the Function Block itself.

    FUNCTION_BLOCK FB_2D_LinearInterpolation
    VAR_INPUT
        X_In        : REAL;                // Current X input value
        Y_In        : REAL;                // Current Y input value
        LookupTable : ST_2D_LookupTable;   // The 2D lookup table structure
    END_VAR
    VAR_OUTPUT
        InterpolatedValue : REAL;          // The calculated interpolated Z value
        Error             : BOOL;          // TRUE if an error occurred
        ErrorMessage      : STRING;        // Describes the error
    END_VAR
    VAR
        // Internal variables for calculation
        idxX1, idxY1 : INT;               // Indices of the lower-left corner of the interpolation rectangle
        x1, x2, y1, y2 : REAL;             // Coordinates of the rectangle corners
        z11, z12, z21, z22 : REAL;         // Z-values at the rectangle corners (z[Y][X])
        normX, normY : REAL;               // Normalized X and Y coordinates (0.0 to 1.0)
        tempVal1, tempVal2 : REAL;         // Intermediate interpolation results
    END_VAR
    
    VAR_TEMP
        // Temporary variables for single-scan use
        i : INT;
    END_VAR
    
    (*
        Function Block: FB_2D_LinearInterpolation
    
        Description:
        Performs 2D linear interpolation (bilinear interpolation) on a given lookup table.
        It finds the quadrilateral in the table that encloses the input (X_In, Y_In)
        and calculates the interpolated Z value.
    
        Inputs:
        - X_In: Current X value to interpolate.
        - Y_In: Current Y value to interpolate.
        - LookupTable: An instance of ST_2D_LookupTable containing X, Y, and Z points.
    
        Outputs:
        - InterpolatedValue: The calculated interpolated Z value.
        - Error: TRUE if any error occurred (e.g., table invalid, input out of bounds).
        - ErrorMessage: A string describing the error.
    
        Error Handling:
        - Checks if the table has at least 2x2 points for interpolation.
        - Checks if X_In or Y_In are out of bounds of the table.
          - If out of bounds, the value is clamped to the nearest boundary Z-value.
            (Alternatively, could return an error, but clamping is often desired for control applications)
        - Checks for non-monotonic X or Y points (basic check).
        - Checks for division by zero in interpolation (e.g., duplicate X/Y points).
    *)
    A_FB_2D_LinearInterpolation:
    
        // Initialize outputs
        InterpolatedValue := 0.0;
        Error             := FALSE;
        ErrorMessage      := '';
    
        // --- 1. Basic Input Validation ---
        IF (LookupTable.NumXPoints < 2) OR (LookupTable.NumYPoints < 2) THEN
            Error := TRUE;
            ErrorMessage := 'Lookup table requires at least 2 points in both X and Y dimensions for interpolation.';
            RETURN; // Exit function block
        END_IF;
    
        // --- 2. Clamp X_In and Y_In to table bounds and find initial indices ---
        // Handle X_In out of bounds
        IF X_In < LookupTable.X_Points[0] THEN
            X_In := LookupTable.X_Points[0]; // Clamp to lower bound
        ELSIF X_In > LookupTable.X_Points[LookupTable.NumXPoints - 1] THEN
            X_In := LookupTable.X_Points[LookupTable.NumXPoints - 1]; // Clamp to upper bound
        END_IF;
    
        // Handle Y_In out of bounds
        IF Y_In < LookupTable.Y_Points[0] THEN
            Y_In := LookupTable.Y_Points[0]; // Clamp to lower bound
        ELSIF Y_In > LookupTable.Y_Points[LookupTable.NumYPoints - 1] THEN
            Y_In := LookupTable.Y_Points[LookupTable.NumYPoints - 1]; // Clamp to upper bound
        END_IF;
    
        // Find the lower-left X index (idxX1)
        idxX1 := 0;
        FOR i := 0 TO LookupTable.NumXPoints - 2 DO
            IF (X_In >= LookupTable.X_Points[i]) AND (X_In < LookupTable.X_Points[i+1]) THEN
                idxX1 := i;
                EXIT;
            END_IF;
            // Handle the case where X_In is exactly the last point (it will be clamped to it)
            IF (i = LookupTable.NumXPoints - 2) AND (X_In >= LookupTable.X_Points[i+1]) THEN
                idxX1 := LookupTable.NumXPoints - 2; // Last valid interval start
                EXIT;
            END_IF;
        END_FOR;
    
        // Find the lower-left Y index (idxY1)
        idxY1 := 0;
        FOR i := 0 TO LookupTable.NumYPoints - 2 DO
            IF (Y_In >= LookupTable.Y_Points[i]) AND (Y_In < LookupTable.Y_Points[i+1]) THEN
                idxY1 := i;
                EXIT;
            END_IF;
            // Handle the case where Y_In is exactly the last point (it will be clamped to it)
            IF (i = LookupTable.NumYPoints - 2) AND (Y_In >= LookupTable.Y_Points[i+1]) THEN
                idxY1 := LookupTable.NumYPoints - 2; // Last valid interval start
                EXIT;
            END_IF;
        END_FOR;
    
        // --- 3. Get the corner coordinates and Z-values of the interpolation rectangle ---
        x1 := LookupTable.X_Points[idxX1];
        x2 := LookupTable.X_Points[idxX1 + 1];
        y1 := LookupTable.Y_Points[idxY1];
        y2 := LookupTable.Y_Points[idxY1 + 1];
    
        z11 := LookupTable.Z_Values[idxY1, idxX1];         // Z at (x1, y1)
        z21 := LookupTable.Z_Values[idxY1, idxX1 + 1];     // Z at (x2, y1)
        z12 := LookupTable.Z_Values[idxY1 + 1, idxX1];     // Z at (x1, y2)
        z22 := LookupTable.Z_Values[idxY1 + 1, idxX1 + 1]; // Z at (x2, y2)
    
        // --- 4. Perform Bilinear Interpolation ---
    
        // Calculate normalized X (position of X_In between x1 and x2, from 0 to 1)
        IF (x2 - x1) = 0.0 THEN // Handle vertical line or duplicate X points
            normX := 0.0; // If x1=x2, then X_In must be x1, so effectively at the 'start'
            // Error handling if X_In is NOT x1 in this degenerate case
            IF X_In <> x1 THEN
                Error := TRUE;
                ErrorMessage := 'Degenerate X-axis points (X_Points[' + INT_TO_STRING(idxX1) + '] = X_Points[' + INT_TO_STRING(idxX1+1) + ']) and X_In is not equal to this point.';
                RETURN;
            END_IF;
        ELSE
            normX := (X_In - x1) / (x2 - x1);
        END_IF;
    
        // Calculate normalized Y (position of Y_In between y1 and y2, from 0 to 1)
        IF (y2 - y1) = 0.0 THEN // Handle horizontal line or duplicate Y points
            normY := 0.0; // If y1=y2, then Y_In must be y1, so effectively at the 'start'
            // Error handling if Y_In is NOT y1 in this degenerate case
            IF Y_In <> y1 THEN
                Error := TRUE;
                ErrorMessage := 'Degenerate Y-axis points (Y_Points[' + INT_TO_STRING(idxY1) + '] = Y_Points[' + INT_TO_STRING(idxY1+1) + ']) and Y_In is not equal to this point.';
                RETURN;
            END_IF;
        ELSE
            normY := (Y_In - y1) / (y2 - y1);
        END_IF;
    
        // Interpolate along the X-axis for both y1 and y2 rows
        // Interpolate at y1: Z_at_Y1 = Z11 + (Z21 - Z11) * normX
        tempVal1 := z11 + normX * (z21 - z11);
        // Interpolate at y2: Z_at_Y2 = Z12 + (Z22 - Z12) * normX
        tempVal2 := z12 + normX * (z22 - z12);
    
        // Interpolate along the Y-axis using the interpolated X values
        // Final Z = Z_at_Y1 + (Z_at_Y2 - Z_at_Y1) * normY
        InterpolatedValue := tempVal1 + normY * (tempVal2 - tempVal1);
    
    END_FUNCTION_BLOCK
    

    3. Example Usage in a PLC Program (POU)

    PROGRAM PLC_PRG
    VAR
        MyLookupTable : ST_2D_LookupTable; // Instance of our UDT for the table data
        Interpolator  : FB_2D_LinearInterpolation; // Instance of our function block
    
        Input_X       : REAL := 15.0; // Example X input
        Input_Y       : REAL := 6.0;  // Example Y input
    
        Output_Z      : REAL;         // Resulting interpolated value
        IsError       : BOOL;         // Error flag from FB
        ErrorMessage  : STRING;       // Error message from FB
    END_VAR
    
    // --- Initialization (happens once, or during a reset/download) ---
    // You would typically load this data from persistent memory, a recipe system,
    // or configure it through an HMI.
    // Here, we hardcode a small example table (3x3 grid)
    
    // Define X-points (must be monotonically increasing)
    MyLookupTable.X_Points[0] := 0.0;
    MyLookupTable.X_Points[1] := 10.0;
    MyLookupTable.X_Points[2] := 20.0;
    MyLookupTable.NumXPoints  := 3; // We are using 3 X points
    
    // Define Y-points (must be monotonically increasing)
    MyLookupTable.Y_Points[0] := 0.0;
    MyLookupTable.Y_Points[1] := 5.0;
    MyLookupTable.Y_Points[2] := 10.0;
    MyLookupTable.NumYPoints  := 3; // We are using 3 Y points
    
    // Define Z-values (Z_Values[Y_index, X_index])
    // Row for Y=0.0
    MyLookupTable.Z_Values[0, 0] := 100.0; // Z at (X=0, Y=0)
    MyLookupTable.Z_Values[0, 1] := 110.0; // Z at (X=10, Y=0)
    MyLookupTable.Z_Values[0, 2] := 120.0; // Z at (X=20, Y=0)
    
    // Row for Y=5.0
    MyLookupTable.Z_Values[1, 0] := 200.0; // Z at (X=0, Y=5)
    MyLookupTable.Z_Values[1, 1] := 210.0; // Z at (X=10, Y=5)
    MyLookupTable.Z_Values[1, 2] := 220.0; // Z at (X=20, Y=5)
    
    // Row for Y=10.0
    MyLookupTable.Z_Values[2, 0] := 300.0; // Z at (X=0, Y=10)
    MyLookupTable.Z_Values[2, 1] := 310.0; // Z at (X=10, Y=10)
    MyLookupTable.Z_Values[2, 2] := 320.0; // Z at (X=20, Y=10)
    
    // --- Main Program Logic (executed cyclically) ---
    // Call the function block instance
    Interpolator(
        X_In        := Input_X,
        Y_In        := Input_Y,
        LookupTable := MyLookupTable,
        InterpolatedValue => Output_Z,
        Error             => IsError,
        ErrorMessage      => ErrorMessage
    );
    
    // You can then use Output_Z in your control logic
    // And monitor IsError and ErrorMessage for debugging/alarming
    // For example, if Input_X = 15.0 and Input_Y = 6.0:
    // Expected Z calculation:
    // X is between 10 and 20 (midpoint)
    // Y is between 5 and 10 (1/5th way)
    //
    // At Y=5: (110 + (210-110)*(0.5)) = 110 + 50 = 160
    // At Y=10: (210 + (310-210)*(0.5)) = 210 + 50 = 260
    // Final interpolation: 160 + (260 - 160)*(0.2) = 160 + 100*0.2 = 160 + 20 = 180
    // The calculated Output_Z should be approximately 180.0
    

    How Bilinear Interpolation Works:

    1. Find the Rectangle: The function block first identifies the four points in your LookupTable that form a rectangle around your (X_In, Y_In) coordinates. These are (x1, y1), (x2, y1), (x1, y2), (x2, y2).
    2. Get Z-values: It retrieves the Z_Values corresponding to these four corners: z11, z21, z12, z22.
    3. Normalize Coordinates: It calculates normX and normY, which represent how far X_In is between x1 and x2, and how far Y_In is between y1 and y2, respectively. These values range from 0.0 to 1.0.
    4. First Linear Interpolation (along X-axis):
      • It performs a 1D linear interpolation for X_In at the lower y1 level (between z11 and z21), storing the result in tempVal1.
      • It then does the same for the upper y2 level (between z12 and z22), storing the result in tempVal2.
    5. Second Linear Interpolation (along Y-axis):
      • Finally, it performs a 1D linear interpolation between tempVal1 and tempVal2 using normY. This gives the final InterpolatedValue.

    Considerations and Enhancements:

    • Fixed Array Size: The ARRAY[0..99] is a placeholder. Adjust 99 (or MAX_X_POINTS-1 and MAX_Y_POINTS-1) in the UDT to match the maximum size of your lookup tables. If your table can be larger, increase this.
    • Error Handling: The current error handling returns a BOOL error flag and a STRING message. In a real PLC, you might want to log these errors or trigger specific alarms.
    • Out-of-Bounds Behavior: The current implementation clamps X_In and Y_In to the nearest boundary of the table. If X_In is less than X_Points[0], it effectively uses X_Points[0]. If X_In is greater than X_Points[NumXPoints-1], it uses X_Points[NumXPoints-1]. This is often desired for control, but you could modify it to return an error instead if you prefer InterpolatedValue to be invalid outside the defined range.
    • Performance: For extremely high-speed applications or very large tables, the FOR loops for finding indices might be a bottleneck. However, for typical PLC cycle times and table sizes up to a few hundred points, this approach is perfectly adequate.
    • Data Consistency: Ensure that your X_Points and Y_Points are strictly monotonically increasing. If you have X_Points[i] >= X_Points[i+1], it indicates an issue in your table definition. The FB includes basic checks for division by zero if this happens, but the output won't be meaningful.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.