Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
DeepSeekdeepseek-v3-0324· DeepSeekHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

You are an expert test writer for the TOEFL iBT tests by ETS. You are designing…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-3-5-sonnet-20241022’s answer.
  1. User

    You are an expert test writer for the TOEFL iBT tests by ETS. You are designing multiple-choice reading questions where students have to choose the correct answer based on a given passage. Create a multiple-choice question (with four options) that begins with the prompt: "Which of the following best summarises the passage?" Make sure that the answers include tricky and logically confusing "distractors" so as to detract students from choosing the correct answer. The options should be consistent in length and should make use of vocabulary of B1-B2 level (according to the Common European Framework of Reference). The writing style should be similar to that found in books such as Official TOEFL iBT tests (published by ETS). Goal: To measure your ability to understand and recognise the major ideas and the relative importance of information in a passage.

    The passage is as follows:

    In many countries, a growing number of people in their twenties are turning to social media in the hope of finding work. But with greater access comes a greater chance to make mistakes. When it comes to using social media for professional networking, our very knowledge and experience of sites like Facebook may actually be a hindrance. Using social media in a professional capacity is a completely different ball game, but for some twenty-somethings, the division is not clear cut. We first earned our online presence by being bold and over-confident, which could explain why some of us still come across like this. Just because a lot of people 'liked' your posts on Facebook, it doesn't mean you'll be able to use Linkedln to show potential employers that you're someone worth employing. We need to realise that what we learned about social networking as teenagers no longer applies, and we must live up to employers' standards if we want to get on in the world of work.

    One of the most common complaints from employers regarding young jobseekers on professional networking sites is that they are over-familiar in their form of address, and appear arrogant. This serves to perpetuate older generations' perceptions of us as an 'entitled generation'. In fact, we're very far from this; in many countries we're increasingly desperate about finding employment, which is why many of us are turning to social media in the first place. This impression of arrogance hurts the employment prospects of young people who – despite their communication errors - actually possess the skills and drive to become a valuable part of the workforce.

    So what's the right way to contact someone on a professional networking site? Firstly, explain clearly who you are, and let the person you're writing to know what's in it for them - maybe you could offer to do a piece of research for them, or assist in some other way. This approach gives you a much better chance of getting a useful reply. Refrain from sending impersonal, blanket emails, and keep the tone humble if you want to avoid leaving a sour taste in the recipient's mouth. Remember - social media can be a great way to make useful contacts, but it needs careful handling if you don't want the door slammed in your face.

  2. DeepSeek Assistant

    Question:
    Which of the following best summarises the passage?

    (A) While social media provides young jobseekers with new opportunities, their informal online habits often create negative impressions on employers, requiring them to adopt more professional communication strategies to succeed.

    (B) Young people today rely heavily on social media for job searches because traditional methods are no longer effective, but they must learn to balance confidence with professionalism to avoid appearing arrogant.

    (C) Employers frequently misunderstand the intentions of young jobseekers on professional networking sites, unfairly labeling them as entitled when they are actually highly motivated and skilled workers.

    (D) Social media platforms like LinkedIn have become essential tools for modern job hunting, forcing young professionals to abandon their personal online identities entirely in favor of strict corporate standards.


    Answer Key & Rationale

    ✅ Correct Answer: (A)
    This option accurately captures the passage’s main argument:

    1. Opportunity vs. Problem: Social media offers job opportunities ("growing number... turning to social media"), but informal habits ("bold and over-confident") backfire.
    2. Solution: The need to adapt ("live up to employers' standards") and use professional strategies ("explain who you are," "keep the tone humble").

    Distractor Analysis

    ✖️ (B) Partial truth, but misleading focus

    • Correctly notes the reliance on social media and the arrogance issue.
    • Flaw: Suggests "traditional methods are no longer effective" (never stated) and overemphasizes "balancing confidence" (the passage stresses humility, not balance).

    ✖️ (C) Overplays victimhood, ignores solutions

    • True that employers misinterpret young jobseekers ("perceptions of us as an 'entitled generation'").
    • Flaw: Focuses only on the employers' bias, omitting the key advice about how jobseekers should improve.

    ✖️ (D) Extreme and inaccurate

    • Correct that LinkedIn is important ("use LinkedIn to show... worth employing").
    • Flaw: Misrepresents the passage by suggesting "abandon personal identities entirely" (the text advises adaptation, not total abandonment).

    TOEFL iBT Design Features

    1. Parallel Structure: All options are 1–2 clauses long with similar complexity.
    2. Vocabulary: B1-B2 level (e.g., "strategies," "perceptions," "essential tools").
    3. Tricky Distractors: Each distractor contains a grain of truth but distorts the main idea (e.g., overemphasizing employer bias in C or exaggerating solutions in D).
    4. Holistic Testing: Measures comprehension of both the problem (informal habits) and solution (professional adaptation).

    This question challenges test-takers to distinguish the central argument from plausible but incomplete or exaggerated interpretations.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.